Ryan Grant Madden 2008-2009

[adqttr]

Quote:

Steven Jackson < He hasnt been the same Steven Jackson for awhile. - might not be same jackson but still better then grant Frank Gore < Frank had one good season. Same situation as Grant. - Just plan wrong, similar situation both had a good season, but gores good season was almost 2000 yards, and grant didnt even have 1000 Ronnie Brown < Injury prone, not that great of a line, but raw talent - In the games he played he was the best running back in the league man Edgerrin James < 3 years ago sure, but not now - Lets see Grant Run behind that line Clinton Portis < nope - I couldnt agree with you less on this one, he has been good for a few years and doenst even get all the carries Laurence Maroney < nope. - I cant agree or disagree with you Marshawn Lynch < nope. - I disagree, he gave you a full season of great play behind a worse line Jamal Lewis < similar to Edge, 3-4 years ago yes. But not now. - I do agree with you here

I think that you have to take a look at some of these players and think about it.

Madden Cant make it so that a guy who plays 10 games is one of the top running backs in the game.

as for speed which i see was the original debate, 93 is perfect for him, means he can break some away, but he def isn't a speed back, so we have to have some room for those guys to be faster.

[Tengo Juego]

Quote: Originally Posted by adqttr

I think that you have to take a look at some of these players and think about it. Madden Cant make it so that a guy who plays 10 games is one of the top running backs in the game. as for speed which i see was the original debate, 93 is perfect for him, means he can break some away, but he def isn't a speed back, so we have to have some room for those guys to be faster.

True, he isn't blazing fast. But can escape from a defense very quickly. I have the same question, does he feel fast? Is he a bruiser type player in madden? He runs with a reckless type style. Not shying from contact.

[destroyer]

Matt Forte FTW

[Tengo Juego]

Quote: Originally Posted by destroyer

Matt Forte FTW

I hope Da Bears, utilize Garrett Wolfe more this season. In no way is he an every down back, but a complete change of pace. I loved watching Garret at NIU.

[adqttr]

the bears are screwed, none of there backs are every down backs, so they better get some good coaching and substitutions. Wolfe better learn how to block if he wants go get good minutes as a 3rd down back.

[g2thecore]

Quote: Originally Posted by DonRSD

of course im gonna say that why was grant BEHIND jacobs, ward, droughns, bradshaw? grant was on the practice squad you got some football learning to do, my young padawan

Wow so that's your rebuttal? And I have some football learning to do??? Typical Giants fan...

[PuddleMonkey]

Sweet jesus, and here I thought there was nothing more annoying than a Cowboys fan. At least when this season is over and the Giants are a .500 team not in the playoff they'll shut up... maybe.

[Jaysworld26]

Quote: Originally Posted by adqttr

haha I am sure that fact that u use the green bay symbol as your avatar means you are not a packers fan, but hopefully you can see clearly enough to see where i am coming from. I am not saying the grant isn't a good back, and i am not saying he is terrible, but it seems like the person who started this thread (dun remember if it was you or not) wants him to be a top 10 HB in Madden. and sorry to burst your giant bubble, he is not proven that he should be yet. Grant is around the 20th back in the league. I think ur crazy if you think his overall should be higher then any one of these guys: LaDainian Tomlinson Brian Westbrook Steven Jackson Adrian Peterson Fred Taylor Larry Johnson Willie Parker Frank Gore Ronnie Brown Edgerrin James Maurice Jones-Drew Clinton Portis Joseph Addai Willis McGahee Laurence Maroney Marshawn Lynch Jamal Lewis Please Let me know.

Grant is listed as 11th overall in FF just for your info...