Official post your own Rosters and ratings

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by Krioniq

1 - Tarvaris Jackson arguably has one of the better defenses in the NFL on his team, and certainly Adrian Peterson is a special running back helping out their offense. 2 - If you think that Tony Romo was the sole reason for the Cowboys' collapse, you obviously didn't watch the Cowboys much. The offensive line was inconsistent, the secondary was shaky outside of Terence Newman, and the offense lacked a home-run threat to keep defenses honest after Felix Jones got hurt. Along similar lines, the offense was never the same once we started playing Terrell Owens and Roy Williams at the same time, either. I'll readily admit that Tony Romo certainly didn't play his best football down the stretch, but he wasn't the sole reason for the Cowboys' slide out of the playoff picture. I'd still take Romo over Jackson, and the majority of starting quarterbacks in the NFL, without having second thoughts about it. 3 - Shame on you for playing the race card, repeatedly. Race has absolutely nothing to do with it; if Jackson's performance coming into this season had indicated that he had the stuff to play NFL quarterback, he would have started. Injury or no, his history as a player is that of struggling to succeed under center, and thus why Frerotte started.

1 Jackson team is good no doubt but Romo's is better

2 Excuses! If your not gonna make'em for Jackson dont make'em for Romo

3 I call it like I see it! Vick bashed McNabb bashed Russell there starting to label him a bust. Why isnt Leftwich signed?

[Derrville]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

Understand the comparisons but Romo is no Manning!

manning didnt win a playoff game till his 6th full season as a starter, Romo's going on his 3rd

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by 83evans

Da Thorne, are you racist because you play the race card so much its not even funny. Those days are over. Travaris didnt get benched because he is black, its because he did bad in the beginning.

Ofcourse not I could ask any one of ya'll that same question! LOL

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by 83evans

Romo came in as a undrafted free agent a year before Jackson came in as a 2nd round pick. So far Romo has lived up to Jacksons expectations.

Romo is been treated like a top ten pick the last 4 years.

[da ThRONe]

Quote: Originally Posted by Derrville

manning didnt win a playoff game till his 6th full season as a starter, Romo's going on his 3rd

Im like the Tuna put away the anointing oil until he does something worthy of it!

Something other than out playing Brad Johnson old *** LOL

And the Vikings suck with Gus F. at Qb just as much as the Cowboys suck with Brad Johnson if not more!

[CM Hooe]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

1 Jackson team is good no doubt but Romo's is better

Minnesota made the playoffs, Dallas did not. Doesn't that make Minnesota better?

Quote:

2 Excuses! If your not gonna make'em for Jackson dont make'em for Romo

If we're going to play that way, I'll go this route: the difference between Romo and Jackson is that Romo has some sort of history of success in Dallas over a time span longer than a month; namely his teams have always had a winning record, which, given how the Cowboys have fared much of this past decade, is saying a little something. Jackson has no similar history of prolonged success whatsoever; it's therefore impossible to say he's better than Romo.

Quote:

3 I call it like I see it! Vick bashed McNabb bashed Russell there starting to label him a bust. Why isnt Leftwich signed?

Who's bashing McNabb? He's better than either Romo or Jackson. Russell's in a tough spot with Oakland, but I haven't written him off. And I don't know why Leftwich isn't signed.

If you want to discuss Michael Vick, there's a fairly active thread in the pro football forum about him, but suffice to say I don't think to highly of him, as either a football player or a person.

[83evans]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

Ofcourse not I could ask any one of ya'll that same question! LOL

Then why do you play the race card to bad QBs like Russell, McNabb, and Jackson but are fine with Orton, Roethlisberger, Freotte, Leinart, and Maddox when he got threatend.

[83evans]

Quote: Originally Posted by da ThRONe

Romo is been treated like a top ten pick the last 4 years.

Thats because hes a UFA that has played like one, and its 2 years, not 4.