The game is good but...

[MAzing87]

I'm very disappointed in the fact that challenging plays was never even touched. No options to choose what you want to challenge, bad replay angles that aren't long enough to even see the play. And in some cases the challenge option isn't even available even when you have more than 2 mins left in a half.

Scenario that happened to me last night, I was playing against Peyton Manning and the Colts. He threw a TD pass at the back of the endzone with about 2:56 minutes left on the clock. The play was a bit suspect and I wanted to challenge it. The challenge option wasn't there. I didn't hit replay. I wanted to challenge. It wasn't there.

[kcq71]

Same thing Im having problems with."Everything you see on Sunday you will see it in Madden 10." Its that not what they advertised?

[RoyalBoyle78]

Quote: Originally Posted by MAzing87

I'm very disappointed in the fact that challenging plays was never even touched. No options to choose what you want to challenge, bad replay angles that aren't long enough to even see the play. And in some cases the challenge option isn't even available even when you have more than 2 mins left in a half. Scenario that happened to me last night, I was playing against Peyton Manning and the Colts. He threw a TD pass at the back of the endzone with about 2:56 minutes left on the clock. The play was a bit suspect and I wanted to challenge it. The challenge option wasn't there. I didn't hit replay. I wanted to challenge. It wasn't there.

I have challenged 3 plays so far and all 3 times the AI new what I was challenging.

[bigsmallwood]

THey should give us the choice like 2K5 did. This challenge system is too much of a toss up!!!!

[kcq71]

Quote: Originally Posted by bigsmallwood

THey should give us the choice like 2K5 did. This challenge system is too much of a toss up!!!!

Remember the game producer for Madden 10 stated this regarding 2k5:

"I have the Xbox version that I actually play quite regularly on 360. Every so often I'll take it into work and have it looping in demo mode on my TV to remind people of all the little things they did.

Believe me I know that product extremely well...I studied the hell out of it when it came out since I was in direct competition with it, and I study the hell out of it now because I personally don't want people to ever to be able to compare us to them any more."

[boooey]

there was a huge challenge thread that stated all of these issues in last years game, this was even before the game went gold.. Ian just ignored it

so lame..

[Chris Smoove]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zmdRqBKKIfs

^^^ video of faulty challenge!!!!!!!!! aaaaaaa EA comon

[mrprice33]

the challenge system should definitely be refined. i hope it's on the list for next year. as much stuff as they crammed into the game this year though, i'm not mad at them.