09-03-2009, 05:34 PM
|
#157
|
|
Rookie
|
Love how the review has all the positives have nothing to do with specifics in gameplay, and all the negatives are gameplay specific, yet it's still a 9. GameSpot got it right -- the game is a 7.5 (at best). Sure, there are huge improvements to Madden 09, but Madden 09 still sucked like the years before, so to make a huge improvement on something that wasn't that great to begin with shouldn't earn it an amazing score. While it is much improved, the feel of it still isn't right. I know many people hate it when people compare it to NFL 2K5, but I'm going to do it anyway. While Madden 10 does some things better than 2K5 (Madden 10 is, after all, a game that 5 years newer), the players in NFL 2K5 had a way better feel to them -- weight, momentum, etc. Plus, this whole thing about ProTak... go back and look at NFL 2K5...the tackles are way better and more realistic...and the game is 5 years older! Get with it EA (and the reviewers out there too). The only sports games EA has been superior at making in recent years is baseball and hockey. Madden needs to be completely revamped if it really wants to be great, and NBA Live as well (because that game is just a complete joke).
|
|
|
