it's kind of in the middle for me. i'll have games where i can throw to whoever i want whenever i want, then i'll have games where i simply can not complete a pass. i find getting screens to the WRs really softens the coverage, as well as draw plays from the gun.
but i really love the great defenses in this game. playing the raiders, santana moss had 3 catches for 8 yards. 21 shut him down. it's insane how good that dude is. unfortunately, their other corners aren't half as good and i won by 2 scores
point being, it depends on the defense mostly. i don't get a huge rush from certain teams, but when playing against teams like the giants or eagles, i've got cooley and portis blocking on 80% of the plays to give myself a chance. awesome.
my defensive rush is not bad. with orakpo at de, i've gotten 11 sacks in 10 games. haynesworth, griffin and carter all have 4 or more. with the d-line pressure, it really helps my dbs so they're looking good too. i think it may depend on who your using.
just my 2 cents. maybe tweak the sliders a little if you're unhappy with it. for me, i like the unpredictablity. that's what made me sell the game back last year.