I think this is an awesome idea. Id like to have to wait a few years to tell that my first round pick qb is a bust. Id like to see that corner back i grabed in the 4th round slowly turn into a new Asante Samaul and id like to see myself considering cutting him because he doesnt seem promising at first and my depth at cb is awesome.
I like what both of you guys are saying. However, what makes the NFL fun is that sometimes teams give up on a player like your system would suggest. But, that player catches on with another team that gives him a chance and then he becomes a star player. You won't have that in Madden tho because the computer does not sign people off the free agent list that are viewed as bad players. (50 or 60's overall.)