Just Traded in Madden 11 for NCAA Football 11, Wow!

[nolesfan69]

I have both games and I love both games. I think both games has something to offer me thats keeps my interest. I mostly play NCAA
more than Madden and it isn't because I like Madden less. I just
prefer college football more than the pros.

[DirtyJerz32]

FYI to the OG poster but, this should go in the football other forum.

Also, you're comparing a patched & tuned game for "out the box game" so it's really not fair to compare them right now.

[big_larry]

I bet everybody that says they like Madden better does not play online.

[PGaither84]

I like both games. I haven't played NCAA since I got Madden and i have no idea what the tuning thingy is, but I really enjoyed NCAA. Both games represent their sport really well. I plan on using a modified version of Playmakers sliders.

[UndeniableSkillz9]

i give ncaa more game time this yr more than madden b/c not really feeling madden this year go wait for the patches to tune the game up usually jump straight into a franchise soon as i get it but the whole game just dont feel right with how they set it up in my 6 season n ncaa i never make it past 4 since i been getting both college n nfl

[erickonasis]

Quote: Originally Posted by big_larry

I must say this is one of the best decisions I have ever made, this game is 100x better than Madden, the Defense is played near perfect, you can blitz and dont have to worry about the backs being wide open, lb's cover, D-ends get up field and form pockets, the db play is kind cheesy sometimes, because they run the receivers routes before they do, but it's not that big of a deal. This is the first time NCAA Football has been better than Madden. If yall dont believe me, go rent NCAA Football 11 after playing Madden 11 for a few weeks now, you will see what im talking about. I might give Madden 11 another chance once the big patch comes out, but if it's gameplay is not on par with NCAA Football 11 then I wont buy it again.

Could not agree more..on ncaa you can actually get a decent game of football

[erickonasis]

Quote: Originally Posted by DirtyJerz32

FYI to the OG poster but, this should go in the football other forum. Also, you're comparing a patched & tuned game for "out the box game" so it's really not fair to compare them right now.

Upatched NCAA was still better than Madden Unpatched...even the Demo was better than the madden demo IMO

[big_larry]

Quote: Originally Posted by PGaither84

I like both games. I haven't played NCAA since I got Madden and i have no idea what the tuning thingy is, but I really enjoyed NCAA. Both games represent their sport really well. I plan on using a modified version of Playmakers sliders.

Madden does not come close to representing real NFL defense this year, seems to me the defense in these games should be swapped, NCAA defense play more like NFL D, and Madden's D this year plays more like a college football defense.