EA REALLY needs to work on the "Instant Replay Challenge" feature!

[TallTell]

That sucks for the the original poster, because even if they do overturn the fumble, if the ball didn't hit the ground before your guy catches it, it's still an interception.

[winb83]

Quote: Originally Posted by wikdSTi

Theres been a few times when theyre defense gets too me and my arms going forward and they call it a fumble and ill challenge it but the play stands as a fumble.

i don't think you can challenge that a fumble was a foward pass in this game. all its gonna check to see is if his knee was down.

[Gagnon39]

My main problem with the challenges is that the CPU never makes a mistake. Every time the CPU challenges a play, I just keep pressing buttons to skip through everything because I know its going to wind up being overturned.

[Miles_Yuhas]

Quote: Originally Posted by ItmannWV

So, I go and buy Madden today and pop it in after a long day of work just to fiddle around for a few minutes and get some first impressions. Well, I don't even make it through half of a preseason game before something happens that really makes the game feel pretty cheesy. It's the second quarter of the Eagles-Saints Week 1 preseason game and the second stringers are already in. Detmer drops back to pass. I don't remember who it was, but somebody from my team blitzes and hits him as he's throwing. The ball goes flying in the air (forward) and it's called a fumble. Jay Bellamy picks the ball clean out of the air. OH, WAIT! THE EAGLES WANT TO CHALLENGE THE PLAY! I knew what was coming, and, indeed, it happened. The fumble call was overturned and the Eagles were given back the ball on the incomplete pass call. Yeah, that's great, Ref, but if that was a pass, I just intercepted it, too. So, I essentially recover a fumble and intercept a pass on the same play, yet I don't even get the ball.

Yeah the AI it is terrible.

[Glenn33]

Quote: Originally Posted by Gagnon39

My main problem with the challenges is that the CPU never makes a mistake. Every time the CPU challenges a play, I just keep pressing buttons to skip through everything because I know its going to wind up being overturned.

YES! YES! YES! I feel the same way.

[dark_warhawk]

from what i can tell there is no "come back code" in 04 yes i was 100% sure there was. the one game that i was sure there was no come back code was when i beat denver 30-6. if that was 04 it would of been shoot out. as challenges i seen the cpu worng one time but i only seen like 5 done by the cpu

[the_jared]

just another reason why madden sux, and is inferior to ESPN

[fossen]

Quote: Originally Posted by the_jared

just another reason why madden sux, and is inferior to ESPN

That's just straight up trolling, and will get you banned quick-like.

Consider this a warning.