RG3 or Andrew Luck who will show more promise......

[Redskins_Hokies]

Quote: Originally Posted by Murderousllama

Luck, If RGIII was a pocket quarterback he wouldn't be getting the attention he is. RGIII is more entertaining to watch though.

Ah, when I read this type of comment I automatically know this is someone who has not followed Griffin at all

[TheDelta]

Quote: Originally Posted by mjhyankees

Luck lacks the great arm strength to make some throws IMO....

Arm strength is really the only negative thing anyone could possibly find about Luck, and to be honest, reading some of the guys trying to anti-hype Luck you'd think he had a noodle arm like Greg McElroy or something. Yes, he's not as strong as Aaron Rodgers or Jay Cutler. But so is Tom Brady, and Eli Manning isn't among the strongest armed QBs in the NFL either. Elite arm strength is nice, but given the choice between a guy with elite arm strength and good accuracy and decision-making or the other way round, I'll take the accurate QB six days a week and twice on Sundays.

[ConnSKINS26]

Quote: Originally Posted by Redskins_Hokies

Ah, when I read this type of comment I automatically know this is someone who has not followed Griffin at all

Exactly. RG3 is a pocket passer. He just happens to also be a world-class sprinter.

[CRMosier_LM]

Luck for the simple fact that he played in a pro style offense.

Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk 2

[JoeRyan33]

I'll bet Luck is a very good and eventually top 5 NFL QB. I'll also bet RG3 is a bust, a below average NFL passer. The Redskins will be drafting another QB in 5 years.

[xblake16x]

I don't think RGIII will be a bust at all. On the field he is spectacular, just as Cam Newton was (I had high hopes for him coming out too).

Andrew Luck though, watching him, nothing is spectacular about him. Sure he has good arm strength, but the ball doesn't pop out of his hand. Sure he has nice accuracy, but when I watched him, they weren't pretty throws. But I guess what his best assets are can't really be seen. And that is his work ethic, his game preparation, and his leadership. I wouldn't be totally surprised if he actually somewhat doesn't become the star he is 'slated' to progress into. He has had 3 years of pressure of becoming the second coming of John Elway.

[StrawHat Patriot]

Quote: Originally Posted by JoeRyan33

I'll bet Luck is a very good and eventually top 5 NFL QB. I'll also bet RG3 is a bust, a below average NFL passer. The Redskins will be drafting another QB in 5 years.

You obviously haven't watched RGIII play at all.

[kehlis]

This discussion has nothing to do with Madden and is being discussed in several threads in the appropriate NFL forum.