Does the ratings team even watch the NFL?

[moneal2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by Stampede_94

They have had YEARS to work most of these things out, and instead of improvements, we get excuses. You can't blame the guy for being fed up at this point. You want to be the only NFL game in town, then come correct on all levels.

its fine to be upset but don't state your opinion as fact. and don't come out with statements that are blatant bs.

[TomSNC]

Quote: Originally Posted by moneal2001

its fine to be upset but don't state your opinion as fact. and don't come out with statements that are blatant bs.

What exactly are you talking about?

[Stampede_94]

Quote: Originally Posted by moneal2001

its fine to be upset but don't state your opinion as fact. and don't come out with statements that are blatant bs.

Lost me there.

[StrawHat Patriot]

Quote: Originally Posted by Stampede_94

Lost me there.

He replied to the wrong person I guess,.

[moneal2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by SA1NT401

There are plenty of guys here on OS including myself who could do me moores job 100x better.... Fact. I edited just about every player in M12 ( sad I know) where the highest rated player in the entire game was Rodgers at a 94..... Average starter was a 74. With great sliders, players actually played and felt completely different. With Donny's ratings, every single player just feels the same more or less where a 60 OVR WR played just like ....( insert any WR). We need editing back. Don't see how donny editing ratings is any different than us editing rosters for use in CC. They just DON'T want us doing it cuz they want us to play madden THEIR way.

Quote: Originally Posted by TomSNC

What exactly are you talking about?

was talking about the post that i quoted originally not the one i was replying to.

the first part is just opinion not fact. he dislikes moore's ratings. not everyone does, otherwise more people would use custom rosters.

the second part is blatant bs. using sliders and his custom ratings players felt different, but i'm to believe that with moore's rosters every player feels exactly the same.

[StrawHat Patriot]

Quote: Originally Posted by moneal2001

the first part is just opinion not fact. he dislikes moore's ratings. not everyone does, otherwise more people would use custom rosters. the second part is blatant bs. using sliders and his custom ratings players felt different, but i'm to believe that with moore's rosters every player feels exactly the same.

You replied to the wrong person.

[CRMosier_LM]

Quote: Originally Posted by raiderphantom

I can't say what they do or don't do, but do they not pay attention to detail, or they just don't care to fix it? Why should gamers even need sliders? As far as ratings go, I understand there will always be somebody complaining about something because there are differences of opinion. But there appears to be no formula for ratings. No standard, no consistency. Ex. Matt Forte: I don't think he even broke 1,000 yards this past season. In fact, I think he's only barely done it once or twice in his career. Yet he's the 6th best RB I believe? So statistic wise he doesn't belong there. Talent wise, he's up there, but so are other players. What exactly justifies that rating? I feel they just throw a handful of guys in a room and they debate the ratings but without much statistical data or even good insight.

You are assuming that the people that set the ratings also dictate what they control in game which is not correct. The ratings team only sets the ratings... How they reflect in the game is the Gameplay team I believe.

To whoever said I am being a jerk I don't know what to tell you other than the truth. Folks ask for honesty and when they get it then they don't want to hear it.

Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk 2

[moneal2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by StrawHat Patriot

You replied to the wrong person.

no i was replied to and replied back talking about the post that i quoted.