Would you make this trade?

[Venom_2K]

I'm seriously considering making this trade and I would like your all's opinions on this. Edge for Marshall Faulk. Yes, I'm considering making this trade to the Rams. Faulk was there when P. Manning first came there AND he is used to being in a high power offense.

[Cpre5]

Whats wrong with the young Edge? He can run and catch like faulk.
I agree Faulk is better, but Edge has youth.

Cpre5

[dave360]

If I were gonna do anything, I would do Edge to the Fins for Ogunleye and Travis Minor. You get some defensive help and a decent backup RB for Rhodes. Faulk for Edge is a rip on you.

[hotwire]

yeah, Edge has lots left in the tank and he's good anyways.

[Sully]

I wouldn't take Faulk unless they through in at least a 2nd round draft pick.

[kirkangil]

Youth for Old Age. Id say no. There pretty equal in my book except for a small difference in speed. But Faulk has at the most 2 more years left in your franchise while edge may have 5-7.

[Venom_2K]

The only reason why I'm even considering this is 1, Tony Bruno talked about Edge being a free agent at the end of the season and 2nd, if I did trade Edge, I would like a experience back like Faulk is.

[theguru14]

Quote: Originally Posted by gr8fuldave

If I were gonna do anything, I would do Edge to the Fins for Ogunleye and Travis Minor. You get some defensive help and a decent backup RB for Rhodes. Faulk for Edge is a rip on you.

I am not sure about the Colts Off Line, but if they are as bad as the Phins Line it will be a bad trade. I use the fish in my Dynasty and I have no running game what so ever because the line is just terrible. I had to adjust the sliders in my favor just to gain a couple of yards.