I am a stickler for authenticity. I agree with making accurate stats also. 99 all is ridiculous if you want a sim experience. If you want an arcade experience then whatever floats yer boat ey. I have every Madden released, ever so I have all the stats saved if you need that info. If you are creating rosters that include players no longer in the game and you are attempting to use the actual in game photo of them I would suggest keeping a log of all the player photo data that you find in order to share on here. There are many modders on here that would most likely be happy to share what they have found as well. As for my suggestions? Priest Holmes from 2004, Leslie O'Neal from 1992, and Pat Swilling from 1991.