Rate My Trade Thread

[trick02]

So i am Pitt and this is the trade I am thinking of doing(feel free to add your own trades)

Pitt Sends - Doumit(C), Moss(LF), Pearce(1B)

Bal - Weiters(C)

[nld230]

Well, if I'm rating it for realism, it's a terrible trade for Baltimore. There are no three prospects that are worth Wieters, especially not in Pittsburgh's system. Maybe if you had some combo of prospects like Heyward, Kershaw, and David Price.

Or if you had a time machine, the Pirates could simply draft the young man when they had the chance.

[trick02]

Haha I will get to work on that time machine.

[JJ_Bills9]

Quote: Originally Posted by nld230

Well, if I'm rating it for realism, it's a terrible trade for Baltimore. There are no three prospects that are worth Wieters, especially not in Pittsburgh's system. Maybe if you had some combo of prospects like Heyward, Kershaw, and David Price. Or if you had a time machine, the Pirates could simply draft the young man when they had the chance.

I don't think any GM would trade Heyward for Wieters straight up let alone along with two of the best pitching prospects.

[Buckeye]

What would be a good trade for hafner??

What I am looking for is some prospects or a young person to step in right away

[12]

Quote: Originally Posted by Codyjohnpaul

What would be a good trade for hafner?? What I am looking for is some prospects or a young person to step in right away

A bag of baseballs?

I guess a mid-level prospect if you're being realistic. As far as a good young player who could play right away, Hafner would not be enough. Pronk is all but done.

[trick02]

Quote: Originally Posted by Codyjohnpaul

What would be a good trade for hafner?? What I am looking for is some prospects or a young person to step in right away

To me the Giants are in big need of a 1B even one on decline like Hafner since they are going to be in a playoff race and need the peaces.

you could do :

1) Cle Sends - Hafner(1B), a few minor league guys..maybe Marte
Giants Send - Velez(OF)


Trading guys like Carmona,Sizemore and Marte would be a good idea near the deadline. I would try and get a catcher.

[goh]

Don't trade Doumit. He's batting .346 with 8 HRs and 28 RBIs in 29 games for me.