Anyone with both Madden and NCAA?

[feeq14]

If your a Franchise/Dynasty Player NCAA definately, if you have the 360 cause the 360 Franchise mode for Madden is broken, not broken in ohh i dont like it, but Broken in that the Draft, the most important part of Franchise mode is a complete wash out,

[Mos1ted]

Quote: Originally Posted by cole46_51

a little off topic, but for the two guys that said they were returning madden???? i take it you played it? if so, where on earth did you get it from, cause i was under the impression, once u open a game, CD, DVD, you weren't able to take it back only exchange for same copy.

Well I traded it in. 35 dollars store cred.

[Walker8]

I have both current gen and madden is buggy. I wish it wasn't because I like the pro game better, plus I think Madden's graphics and control seems to be a bit smoother, but NCAA seems to be the better overall game. The sim engine is broken in Madden and rbs get like 450 carries in a season. Plus the cpu does not block on punt returns and I rarely see the computer return a punt. Plus the AI and clock management seems to be smarter in NCAA. And there are little things in NCAA that just make me say wow now that is realistic. IE hand offs on punts, kick offs. More penalties, etc.... It just seems to be a more realistic and refined game if you are into playing the cpu and doing dynasty.

[Carolina93]

I lost interest in Madden in the past few years, but picked it up this time for the 360.

I like both, but love NCAA.....I wish NCAA had Madden's lead blocker control. That is just SICK!


I'll play a dynasty/franchise game a week during the season with my two favorite teams and then get online and play whoever if I have additional time......