Is it safe to say this game is the best NCAA Football game of all time?

[Bumble14]

After playing the game for going on 3 weeks this is the best NCAA game this generation, but not all time. My take is below:

1.) NCAA 04
2.) NCAA 11
3.) NCAA 06

[DoomsDayD1978]

Quote: Originally Posted by Bumble14

After playing the game for going on 3 weeks this is the best NCAA game this generation, but not all time. My take is below: 1.) NCAA 04 2.) NCAA 11 3.) NCAA 06

I have to agree with you on the this generation take...I want to say so bad that this is the best of all time, because trust me this game is REALLY GOOD, but I view that debate much like most do when trying to decide which college football team or NFL team was the best of all time. It's hard to do. Heck, I loved NCAA 2000 on the old PS1 and I logged countless hours on that game, probably more than I have any other game to date... but I promise that if I were to put that game into a PS1 right now and try to play it, I would shut it off in less than a quarter...LOL

Jury is still out on 11 of course, but here's my 3

1. NCAA 11
2. NCAA 04
3. NCAA 00

Worst

1. NCAA 05
2. NCAA 05
3. Did I mention....NCAA 05

[SECElit3]

This is the most playtime I have put into a NCAA title within 24 hours. I would say that this game is easily the best.

[djordan]

Wait 2 weeks before making this decision.

[S1ARk5]

Quote: Originally Posted by dopeboy206

First off I just want to say I've been playing college football games since NCAA Gamebreaker 98 and NCAA football since 99. I played Madden since 95 so I am not new to football games. Just one day into the game I already know and could safely say this is the best NCAA Football game so far. Out the box this game is GOOD TO GO! Other NCAA games this gen needs to be patched to improve gameplay and even when they were patched they still have nothing on NCAA Football 11 out the box. Trust me I owned them all. NCAA 11 = G.O.A.T. when it comes to college football games. Yes even better than NCAA Football 06. I said it! PS: The way I feel about this game might be premature but I could feel that this game is going to be great. NCAA is headed in the right direction.

I have played all of them and my favorites are 04, 06, 07..and yes this is hands down better then all of them so this is the best NCAA Football game without question and one of the best football games I have played ever, right next to NFL 2k5.

[bling1202]

In terms of gameplay experience, most definitely. I have not played dynasty, online dynasty, or RTG(lol) yet so this is my opinion just based on how the games play out ans feel.

[AUChase]

I must really be one of the few out there who's favorite NCAA is 05.

I'll give it a week or so before I vote. I want to vote yes, but at the same time I don't want to jump the gun. I'll reserve my vote till I get some rosters and start messing with Dynasty more.

[CrossTown]

I haven't gotten into Dynasty yet but if the new recruiting system delivers then I'll for sure say this is best I've ever played. Locomotion and dual-stick controls make every single time you touch the ball feel so unique.

Ah **** it, I'm sold before even finishing typing this. This is the best I've played. Edges out 06. The gameplay this year is fantastic.