Passing sucks in this game.
You have the CBs and Safeties still being able to know exactly where a ball is going better then the WRs do. They can also do knock downs and ints with their backs turned and from impossible angles.
Then there are the super LB and DL who leap to knock down any passes in real life they wouldn't be close to getting.
Plus EA has removed touch passing from this years game. I can't get any feel when using the controller. The ball is either straight or a lob no in between shading.
Why do they ruin something that was working fine. Just like they did with the BCS rankings.
I've got two words that can explain your whole dilemma... "Roster Glitch".