Anyone trade NCAA in for MAdden? if so..How do you feel after doing it?

[grandchampbaby117]

I've never traded ncaa in for madden but was thinking about doing so this year...if you guys did..are you fully satisfied or do you want your college game back? Should I just keep both? or will Madden make me not want to play college anymore??

[misterkrabz]

I thought about it but I'm glad I kept the college game...I was going back and forth playing both last night and both are good in their own way...I have the PS3 versions and for the first time on next gen I'm actually happy with both. If I had to pick one I'd probably choose Madden because I'm not a huge fan of all the recruiting stuff in NCAA...but for now, I'll keep both and play both until both are completely patched and then I'll re-evaulate.

[Sydeburnz]

Quote: Originally Posted by grandchampbaby117

I've never traded ncaa in for madden but was thinking about doing so this year...if you guys did..are you fully satisfied or do you want your college game back? Should I just keep both? or will Madden make me not want to play college anymore??

Madden imports RTG and Dynasty Rookies so it's best to have both if you are serious about SIM football.

I have borrowed my Son-in-laws Madden 12 and I'm digging the NFL Superstar mode on 15 min quarters... but the sound is quirky, there is a corrdinator repeating himself every other play and it's just not as engrossing as NCAA, but I may go ahead and get it at some point. Graphics look great, same animations as NCAA for the most part, still have some slider tweaking to do .. which is probably why I'd enjoy it ... slideritis

[splff3000]

I feel great. I honestly haven't thought about NCAA since I've done it. I will say this though. You prolly should have traded NCAA in last week or something while a lot places had a special promo going on. I got $40 credit towards Madden for NCAA so I was quite happy.

[RGmoney]

OP, you've been told this before: No comparison threads in either game's forum. You want to compare/discuss both games, take it here: http://www.operationsports.com/forum...ootball-games/

Closed