I agree. If I have a 4* player drop from a 75 to a 69 and a 2* player go from a 63-69 I still go after the 4* guy as I feel they still progress more. Who knows if true.
I use scouting to determine who is the better player at a position I have a lot of recruits on my board rated closely and not sure which ones I want, athletes and lower tier guys to see if they are a gem or bust.