Info from NCAA Football 2005 Strategy Guide

[soxboy7]

I'll trade you a cookie for some Illinois rankings...I'm almost afraid because I know they'll be low

[bdunn13]

"Clemson

ALL: 77
QB: 64"

I would not trust these ratings. Charlies Whitehurst IS a top 10 QB in the game and rated in the 90s.

[Nivek]

Quote:

---

bdunn13 said:
"Clemson

ALL: 77
QB: 64"

I would not trust these ratings. Charlies Whitehurst IS a top 10 QB in the game and rated in the 90s.

---

but it's a unit rating...correct?

Same thing applies to UConn as well.

[ycbs]

Quote:

---

bdunn13 said:
"Clemson

ALL: 77
QB: 64"

I would not trust these ratings. Charlies Whitehurst IS a top 10 QB in the game and rated in the 90s.

---

I agree. Some of these ratings look WAY off. Either they're not legit or there is going to be a lot of work to be done on these rosters.

[McLite]

I think you just opened a can of worms... prepare to be bombarded ! lol

[fossen]

These are ... odd.

Quote:

---

BYU Cougars
all - 82
qb - 91
rb - 70
WR - 77
OL - 87
DL - 75
LB - 74
DB - 85
Special teams - 78

Key off - P #38 awar 90 k pwr 96 k acc 95
Key Def -re# 49 spd - 76 strgth 76 awar 84 tackle 80
Underclassman to watch TE #20 spd 74 awar 70 catch 74 runbl 62

---

The comments at the end seem right - Coats as the Underclassman, and Payne as the offensive threat.

These are overall unit ratings? Or the #1 at each?

Either way, that QB rating seems really off.

[UofL]

A guy over on maddenmania is the one posting the rankings. To keep up with who he has done so far, go visit this thread: http://www.maddenmania.com/forums/sh...ad.php?t=52843

[ycbs]

Quote:

---

nivek said:

Quote:

---

bdunn13 said:
"Clemson

ALL: 77
QB: 64"

I would not trust these ratings. Charlies Whitehurst IS a top 10 QB in the game and rated in the 90s.

---

but it's a unit rating...correct?

Same thing applies to UConn as well.

---

Even if the two backup QBs are in wheelchairs, Clemson's QB rating should be higher than that, just off Whitehurst alone.