Nobody else noticed it was 2 2K games 3 years apart from each other that were battling it out?
ESPN NFL 2K5 until Madden got scared so they had to license in order to make money.
And College Hoops 2K8, a game they stopped making, and EA made 2 more CB games after that,
And to this day I keep hearing CB '10 is better than 2K8.
A game in 2009 should not be compared to a game in 2007, and a game in 2011 (Madden '11) should not be compared to a game in 2004 (ESPN 2K5) Sad.
Anyway, my list goes as followed,
ESPN NFL 2K5
College Hoops 2K8
MVP Baseball 2005
NBA Live 2005