Madden vs NCAA

[bsb13]

Which game do you think has been the best in the last 8 years? Dont judge by whether or not you like the NFL or College better, but vote simply from a gameplay standpoint. And give reasons why you think one has been better than the other.

[MassNole]

NCAA by a country mile. It has generally been more innovative and just plays better than Madden. In a small way NCAA is geared more towards the sim based gamer whereas Madden has been aimed at the arcade types who bastardize the sport every time they fire up their console.

[silvister]

Right now I prefer the NCAA game hands down. The game has just appeared to get better every year unlike Madden. Even though I have the last 2 Madden games I really wasn't a fan of them and I don't plan on getting the new one. Over the past couple of years Madden just hasn't done anything significant that makes the game stand out, it is just more of the same.

[Sausage]

Quote: Originally Posted by MassNole

NCAA by a country mile. It has generally been more innovative and just plays better than Madden. In a small way NCAA is geared more towards the sim based gamer whereas Madden has been aimed at the arcade types who bastardize the sport every time they fire up their console.

D to da ITTO

[SkinsFan4Life]

Holy BALLS! I can't beleive the current results for this poll. All votes for NCAA except one, which was mine. A few years back I played more NCAA. Now, I play just Madden. Of course, I love franchise mode in Madden. Maybe I'll pop NCAA in again soon.

[GAMEC0CK2002]

NCAA easily.

[bigbuttnugget]

I'd have to say NCAA- no contest. The quality of the game, and the game's features always seemed more fun, and more thought out than Madden's.

For football fans and stat heads.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/signup.pl?ref=5120159

[Altimus]

NCAA.

20 to 1 right now vote wise, wow.