Madden: Editing Player Ratings in Franchise - Need Your Thoughts

[cletusdog]

Absolutely!
having control over injuries would just be a really nice touch.
apply or remove injuries, as well as remove the IR tag. Adjust length and injury type.

[daniverson1973]

personally i dont feel a need to edit players in franchise, althought it'd be a cool option to have, id probably use it

what i'd love, is the ability to edit incoming rookies (i.e.-imported d-classes), that would be sweet!!!!

[KuruptOwnz]

The way I see it is this;

If person A will get enjoyment out of making a team full of 99's and person B doesn't, then person A should be able to and person B can choose not to. Online, however, is another story entirely. Have one set of roster for online, period.

With the issues facing this years Madden, I believe a few things such as Cornerbacks tackle rating, incoming rookies, etc... should be editable in terms of ratings. To make a more fluid and enjoyable game for the user.

Again, to reiterate my initial point; have the option there, people who don't want to edit them during franchise wont and people who want to should have the ability to do so.

Hell, you could have the option to turn it on or off in Franchise should you chose.

[michapop9]

Quote: Originally Posted by chia51

I would like to be able to edit every attribute and physical attribute of the player. To be able to have the ability to change the ratings as I see fit throughout the season. (ex: Maybe a player is playing very well during the season in the game but the default progression is "not enough IMO" so then I could go into and adjust.) Yes I believe that the best way to do this would be to have the "edit" abiltity only opened/allowed during the following weeks: 1st week of preseason 1st week of the season 4th week of the season 8th week of the season 12th week of the season 16th week of the season No, there would be no other option other than full league control that would make sense. At least I don't see any. Maybe not having the salaries change when editing players that way the teams salaries will not change when someone edits their players. Maybe having an option to edit the salaries in the off-season.

great stuff, and the injury options as well, good thoughts

[KuruptOwnz]

Quote: Originally Posted by michapop9

great stuff, and the injury options as well, good thoughts

Why? For the sake of and arguement here; why not allow someone to do it year round, not just at set times?

People who don't want to do it, wont and those who would, will. Why limit it to certain weeks, rather than just allowing it to begin with? Don't use it if you don't want to...

[Vizen]

I agree with Kurupt. Since this is for offline franchise, its up to the user how to implement it, so I don't want anyone suggesting restrictions that most people won't agree with...

[michapop9]

Quote: Originally Posted by KuruptOwnz

Why? For the sake of and arguement here; why not allow someone to do it year round, not just at set times? People who don't want to do it, wont and those who would, will. Why limit it to certain weeks, rather than just allowing it to begin with? Don't use it if you don't want to...

ALL the time would even be better, absolutely theres no argument, more control more often is always better.

[KuruptOwnz]

Quote: Originally Posted by michapop9

ALL the time would even be better, absolutely theres no argument, more control more often is always better.

Did you read my initial argument? It was actually for allowing us to change ratings ALL the time and not just for set weeks.