Who's your TOP 5 Recivers in Madden 11 ?

[Mr360BeasTx]

1.Andre Johnson
2.Brandon Marshall
3.Rnady Moss
4.Calvin Johnson
5.Larry Fitzgarled

[DCEBB2001]

My completely unbiased answer would be:

Pure OVR
1. L. Fitzgerald
2. A. Johnson
3. S. Smith (CAR)
4. V. Jackson
5. S. Rice

Statistically
1. V. Jackson
2. S. Rice
3. R. Wayne
4. W. Welker
5. A. Johnson

[Mr360BeasTx]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

My completely unbiased answer would be: Pure OVR 1. L. Fitzgerald 2. A. Johnson 3. S. Smith (CAR) 4. V. Jackson 5. S. Rice Statistically 1. V. Jackson 2. S. Rice 3. R. Wayne 4. W. Welker 5. A. Johnson

as your Statistic Andre ahould be first he had a better season then any WR in that list

[The Gravy Train]

I'd probably go with:

1. Larry Fitzgerald
2. Andre Johnson
3. Calvin Johnson
4. Brandon Marshall
5. Steve Smith

[Mr360BeasTx]

Quote: Originally Posted by The Gravy Train

I'd probably go with: 1. Larry Fitzgerald 2. Andre Johnson 3. Calvin Johnson 4. Brandon Marshall 5. Steve Smith

Thats a nice fair List but i can tell your a Arizona Homer lol

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by Mr360BeasTx

as your Statistic Andre ahould be first he had a better season then any WR in that list

Not true. What hurts Johnson are the following:

1. He was thrown to 152 times last year and recorded 101 receptions. That is only 66.4%...28th in the league.

2. He was 22nd in the league with 15.5 yds/rec.

3. Had 9tds receiving...tied for 7th in the league.

4. He had 6 INTs that were thrown his way...10th most in the NFL.

5. 9 drops...tied for 5th in the league among WRs.

6. Only 8 missed tackles all season...1 every 2 games.

These tell you that despite his high yardage, he wasn't as great as he seems and has a ton of room for improvement...which is scary. So statistically, he is not at the top.

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by Mr360BeasTx

Thats a nice fair List but i can tell your a Arizona Homer lol

I had Fitz at the top of my list and I'm not an AZ homer? I think he is just the best in the league for what he does and has done.

[Pringles]

Quote: Originally Posted by Mr360BeasTx

1.Andre Johnson 2.Brandon Marshall 3.Rnady Moss 4.Calvin Johnson 5.Larry Fitzgarled

there is noway randy moss should be on the list i would put austin miles on there before randy.