Orton and Tebow's rating

[Boling4Humor]

For those who watch the Broncos...how would you rate Orton and Tebow thus far? What specifically would you adjust?

I would probably put Tebow at a 70 and Orton at a 75. I'm not sure whether I'd lower Orton's Awareness or Accuracy rating. I'd def lower Tebow's Med and Deep throw Accuracy.

[one5beast]

Tebows deep and medium is pretty good but his short accuracy is a problem.

[xblake16x]

I wish the OP rated players, sorta. I like the fact that not every QB is in the 80's, good for you.

Id like to see 80 overall and up be playoff caliber QBs and 90 and higher super bowl caliber players

[xElway7x]

After Tebow's 3 starts last season, and him coming in the second half today, I think his 75 rating is fine. If you were to lower his speed, he would be a high 60s player.

[Coast]

Madden 12s rating of Tebow is just right.

Anyone ever tried putting Tebow in at RB? Whats his OVR at that position?

[SteboSSK]

Quote: Originally Posted by Coast

Madden 12s rating of Tebow is just right. Anyone ever tried putting Tebow in at RB? Whats his OVR at that position?

Why would he be a good RB? He is only a threat at running b/c he is a QB, dude is slow compared to the avg NFL rb

[Instant C1a55ic]

Quote: Originally Posted by Boling4Humor

For those who watch the Broncos...how would you rate Orton and Tebow thus far? What specifically would you adjust? I would probably put Tebow at a 70 and Orton at a 75. I'm not sure whether I'd lower Orton's Awareness or Accuracy rating. I'd def lower Tebow's Med and Deep throw Accuracy.

Wish they had a dumb--- rating cause it would be at 100 for Orton...

[ghostlight85]

Quote: Originally Posted by xblake16x

I wish the OP rated players, sorta. I like the fact that not every QB is in the 80's, good for you. Id like to see 80 overall and up be playoff caliber QBs and 90 and higher super bowl caliber players

I think this is an excellent post. Madden rates players too high across the board. One of the things that allows NBA2k to differentiate good players from great players on the court is that fewer players have truly elite ratings. Madden just pushes everyone's numbers up to the top and very little separates the players or the teams.