Is (Insert Player Here) A Hall of Famer?

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by Kaiser Wilhelm

Does Vick even get into the hypothetical Hall of Very Good?

What has he done to even warrant that argument?

I bought in to the "He will revolutionize" the position pre-draft hype. Never happened. Tremendous athlete, mediocre QB.

[kehlis]

Quote: Originally Posted by Yrogergj24

Closing and changing the vote now. Michael Vick Argument For: He revolutionized the position for a short time Argument Against: He did some illegal things

For reason's beyond the football argument, please pick a new player.

We don't need to have an argument/debate we've had time and time again.

I don't do this often, but as a mod, I'm asking you to pick a new player.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by kehlis

I can already give you the argument: "They win games"

Yeah that philosophy has really worked out for the Raiders.

[Kaiser Wilhelm]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

What has he done to even warrant that argument? I bought in to the "He will revolutionize" the position pre-draft hype. Never happened. Tremendous athlete, mediocre QB.

Well there were the few rushing seasons, but yeah. I do believe he will forever be in the Madden Hall of Fame though, or Hall of Cheese, if you like.

I think we need better players to debate. I know I'm not the guy, but if I could recommend Champ Baily?

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by Kaiser Wilhelm

Well there were the few rushing seasons, but yeah. I do believe he will forever be in the Madden Hall of Fame though, or Hall of Cheese, if you like.

Madden HOF argument I can buy. Him and Tim Dwight.

[z Revis]

Not a chance in hell Vick gets in.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Candyman5]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Guys who play maybe 4 snaps a game should not be in the hall. Not to mention they aren't even football players. I mean seriously? Someone in this thread tried to state Lechler had a bigger impact on his teams success than someone like Jerry Kramer, or Terrell Davis or Drew Pearson? Are we being serious here? It's the Hall of Fame.

So by your logic a NFL coach should not make it when they dont play in any plays at all?

I believe kickers/punters should be in the Hall of Fame. They play in the NFL and are under the same rules that every other player are under.

[Yrogergj24]

Quote: Originally Posted by kehlis

For reason's beyond the football argument, please pick a new player. We don't need to have an argument/debate we've had time and time again. I don't do this often, but as a mod, I'm asking you to pick a new player.

Okay, Chad Johnson