Werewolf L Kate Beckinsale - day 7, deadline Thursday 10pm Eastern Time

[Schmidty]

I really think the better play tonight is voting for Schmidty.

Again, more "solid" reasoning.

I think that green beans go with pork better than asparagus. Why? Because.

Genius!!!!

[DaddyTorgo]

See now just about the time I begin to trust you a little bit you post something like this.

You're not a lazy WW gamer, but this entire game you've been one. Why this game? Why the shift from the normally very precise and active role you normally take on in a game?

actually I am fairly. Normally I don't go back and pull quotes out. I'll just say "that post a little while ago where they talked about x" or whatever.

my normal M.O. has just been to throw stuff at the wall and sorta see what sticks, sorta try to throw all kinds of theories out there.

But I myself have noticed that my playing style has been changing to be less crazy-theoried and more calmed-down. I'll still throw theories out there, but my paranoia level has gone down.

[DaddyTorgo]

Thanks Dr. Phil.

You have no idea how epically wrong you are.


something you want to tell us? leave us time

[LoneStarGirl]

You know what, I was sitting and eating dinner with Goldeneagle and I was talking to him about the game and how freaking confused I was about everything. Well I told him how I had been suspicious of Gonzo the WHOLE game and how now people are putting pressure on Schmidty but I didn't think he was bad.... then I realized, if I don't think Schmidty is bad, why vote for him?

I hate doing this to Gonzo, especially with only 12 minutes left, but I have to do what my gut says, and supposidly gut is what everybody is basing their vote on... and if my gut is wrong with Gonzo then I will apologize and will vote schmidty tomorrow

unvote schmidty

vote Gonzo

[DaddyTorgo]

I have been very indecisive though, that's true. Which I can't really explain. Just the way this game has been I guess.

[DaddyTorgo]

gonzo 4
schmidty 3

[LoneStarGirl]

I have been very indecisive though, that's true. Which I can't really explain. Just the way this game has been I guess.

Honestly Daddy you have been playing so out of character I am surprised that you haven't been voted for more often...

[DaddyTorgo]

reason why you don't think schmidty is bad LSG?

[KWhit]

Again, more "solid" reasoning.

I think that green beans go with pork better than asparagus. Why? Because.

Genius!!!!

Mock all you want. I have no idea if you are a wolf or not. But I have my reasons for believing that Gonzo is a normal villager.

[LoneStarGirl]

I wish we had a full on vote count... but I dont think Cronin will be here for another 30 minutes or so

[Schmidty]

something you want to tell us? leave us time

I am a vanilla villager. I don't have some last ditch explaination to dream up.

I was just using hyperbole, because of the fact that I know that it would be an epic mistake for another villager to die for crappy reasoning.

[DaddyTorgo]

I have been? really? huh. Interesting.

[Telle]

You know what, I was sitting and eating dinner with Goldeneagle and I was talking to him about the game and how freaking confused I was about everything. Well I told him how I had been suspicious of Gonzo the WHOLE game and how now people are putting pressure on Schmidty but I didn't think he was bad.... then I realized, if I don't think Schmidty is bad, why vote for him?

I hate doing this to Gonzo, especially with only 12 minutes left, but I have to do what my gut says, and supposidly gut is what everybody is basing their vote on... and if my gut is wrong with Gonzo then I will apologize and will vote schmidty tomorrow

unvote schmidty

vote Gonzo

Just FYI, Gonzo is the fifth person you have voted for today. Just thought that was interesting considering you were pointing out DaddyTorgo's indecisiveness based on voting earlier :)

Also, this vote moves the lead from Schmidty to Gonzo (just mentioning in case we want to analyze today's votes later).

[Schmidty]

Mock all you want. I have no idea if you are a wolf or not. But I have my reasons for believing that Gonzo is a normal villager.

Honestly, please don't take offense to my jibe. I hate when people do that stuff in anger, but my comment wasn't meant to be mean. Sorry.

[KWhit]

My circle of trust:
Gonzo
Cartman
DaddyTorgo

[Telle]

Mock all you want. I have no idea if you are a wolf or not. But I have my reasons for believing that Gonzo is a normal villager.

Care to share? 'Cause right now he's in the lead for lynching.

[KWhit]

Honestly, please don't take offense to my jibe. I hate when people do that stuff in anger, but my comment wasn't meant to be mean. Sorry.

None taken.

[LoneStarGirl]

I know Telle... I really neglected the game until today so I spent WAY Too much time analyzing everything today because I had a paper to do and i was procrastinating. I really wish I could have devoted more time this weekend and I wouldn't be this indecisive right now

I am not saying that Schmidty is not a wolf.... in fact I am like path (I think it was path) I think both Gonzo and Schmidty are wolves, but I believe in Gonzo more right now so I am going to vote for him

[KWhit]

Jeez, is nobody reading what I'm writing?

[DaddyTorgo]

i'd really rather we lynched schmidty people...in light of some of what has been said here in the last little while, I don't think lynching gonzo is the right play (course if he's a wolf i'm dooming myself there). I have no idea if schmidty is good or bad, but I am more certain gonzo is good

[DaddyTorgo]

i'm reading it kwit. And getting damm frustrated!

[DaddyTorgo]

LYNCH SCHMIDTY PEOPLE!!! JEEZUS!!!

[Schmidty]

i'd really rather we lynched schmidty people...in light of some of what has been said here in the last little while, I don't think lynching gonzo is the right play (course if he's a wolf i'm dooming myself there). I have no idea if schmidty is good or bad, but I am more certain gonzo is good

WHY!!!!!!!!!!!!

People keep f'ing convicting me mysteriously, but not explaining anything!!!!!

[KWhit]

I am the seer (who can spot the wolves). These are who I scanned (all villagers):
Gonzo
Cartman
DaddyTorgo
Tanglewood

I also scanned Olliegirl but couldn't complete the scan. This is what I received:
"You are unable to complete your test, as you black out shortly after dinner. You wake up in the morning with no memory of what happened during the night, and oliegirl's dna sample, having been left out overnight, is no longer good."
I took that to mean she was either a wolf or the Mad Scientist, but I'm not sure.

[Telle]

Are we saying KWhit's a deadman tonight?? Shit...

UNVOTE GONZO
VOTE SCHMIDTY

[KWhit]

So I don't know Schmidty's bad... But I know Gonzo's not a wolf.

[DaddyTorgo]

BECAUSE GODDAMM KWIT BASICALLY CAME OUT AND SAID HE WAS THE SEER!!! AND NOW HE JUST DID COME OUT AND SAY IT!!!!

[DaddyTorgo]

and now we've lost our seer

[KWhit]

Also remember that I can't tell who the mad scientist is...

[Schmidty]

Last ditch self-preservation vote:

Vote Gonzo

Sorry man.

[DaddyTorgo]

it was obvious

look at the people who have stayed on gonzo despite being here

jhandley...LSG...render...schmidty are all in thread. So is telle but she just switched

[KWhit]

Just to note who's around the thread:

JHandley, Telle, DaddyTorgo, LSG

[Schmidty]

KWhit is the Seer??

WHY DIDN"T HE SAY IT EARLIER?

[JHandley]

Last ditch self-preservation vote:

Vote Gonzo

Sorry man.

Are you sure you don't want to rethink that?

[DaddyTorgo]

well that makes schmidty a wolf

if he won't vote with the seer

SWITCH NOW

[Telle]

Also remember that I can't tell who the mad scientist is...

So in theory.. you may have just revealed yourself in order to save the mad scientist. Now wouldn't that suck? :)

[JHandley]

it was obvious

look at the people who have stayed on gonzo despite being here

jhandley...LSG...render...schmidty are all in thread. So is telle but she just switched
I've never been on Gonzo.

[DaddyTorgo]

didn't say you were on gonzo jhandley. Just noting who was in thread

[Schmidty]

Are you sure you don't want to rethink that?

Yeah, but it's too late.

I'm screwed. No matter what I say now, I'm done.

I don't know who the wolves are, but I have never felt so railroaded in a game. :(

[DaddyTorgo]

DEADLINE

[DaddyTorgo]

fucking a

[Telle]

It's a tie.. 4-4 Gonzo and Schmidty.

So KWhit, was it worth it to reveal yourself to save one villager right now? Maybe we'll get lucky and the wolves will have already put their kill in and not have a chance to move it to you before deadline.

[JHandley]

didn't say you were on gonzo jhandley. Just noting who was in thread
Gotcha. I thought you were pointing out those who stayed on Gonzo even after Kwhit left such obvious clues.

[cartman]

Dang, that's what I get for eating dinner and missing the deadline excitement

[DaddyTorgo]

4-4??

so we don't even get a goddamm lynch out of it?

what a fustercluck!

[KWhit]

It's a tie.. 4-4 Gonzo and Schmidty.

So KWhit, was it worth it to reveal yourself to save one villager right now? Maybe we'll get lucky and the wolves will have already put their kill in and not have a chance to move it to you before deadline.

Well.. I decided not to gamble again. I figured I'd be a target before too long anyway, and didn't want to lose any advantage I had. Gonzo is a valuable villager, since I can confirm that he is not a wolf. I didn't want him to go down.

[RendeR]

Methinks we've just done blown this game. Talk about a good job by the wolves keeping us utterly and completely confused.

[LoneStarGirl]

Fucking ass... I didn't even see that post until 9:02... I had to reboot the damned computer, at least its a tie and we didn't end up lynching an villager because of it

[Telle]

Well.. I decided not to gamble again. I figured I'd be a target before too long anyway, and didn't want to lose any advantage I had. Gonzo is a valuable villager, since I can confirm that he is not a wolf. I didn't want him to go down.

Well I think I stated earlier that it's up to the seers to decide when they think the time is right to reveal... soooo, there ya go.

[KWhit]

I tried to leave a lot of hints hoping that just one person would pick up on them and move their vote, but.... no. Either people weren't paying attention, I wasn't obvious enough, or there are wolves out there.

:)

[RendeR]

I tried to leave a lot of hints hoping that just one person would pick up on them and move their vote, but.... no. Either people weren't paying attention, I wasn't obvious enough, or there are wolves out there.

:)



Umm....YES.

[DaddyTorgo]

I tried to leave a lot of hints hoping that just one person would pick up on them and move their vote, but.... no. Either people weren't paying attention, I wasn't obvious enough, or there are wolves out there.

:)

i'll be honest...i didn't pick it up until you said "i have my reasons". and then I started kicking and screaming. and that's why I listed who was in thread at that point and didn't move...i think that's important

[Telle]

I tried to leave a lot of hints hoping that just one person would pick up on them and move their vote, but.... no. Either people weren't paying attention, I wasn't obvious enough, or there are wolves out there.

:)

Well of course there are wolves out there... otherwise the game would be over! :)

[KWhit]

At least you have some kind of COT now.

[RendeR]

I admit it, I didn't get the hints.

[KWhit]

Well of course there are wolves out there... otherwise the game would be over! :)

I was trying to be funny.

[Telle]

At least you have some kind of COT now.

Yep. Updating my spreadsheets as we speak :)

[LoneStarGirl]

I admit it, I didn't get the hints.

Yah I feel kind of stupid myself now :mad:

[RendeR]

I was trying to be funny.


Yeah umm...see, we didn't get the HINTS, so why would we get the HUMOR either ;)

[DaddyTorgo]

true...there are 3 of us. We just need to work together.

[LoneStarGirl]

KWhit is right, at least we do have some sort of a cot now

But Kwhit, I am curious, what made you scan Gonzo?

[KWhit]

KWhit is right, at least we do have some sort of a cot now

But Kwhit, I am curious, what made you scan Gonzo?

Same reason you guys were voting for him. He was saying some weird things. And I think I did it because he was so skeptical of Alan's reveal.

[KWhit]

Oh well. I probably revealed too early. Hope there aren't many wolves left.

[Gonzo]

I am the seer (who can spot the wolves). These are who I scanned (all villagers):
Gonzo
Cartman
DaddyTorgo
Tanglewood

I also scanned Olliegirl but couldn't complete the scan. This is what I received:
"You are unable to complete your test, as you black out shortly after dinner. You wake up in the morning with no memory of what happened during the night, and oliegirl's dna sample, having been left out overnight, is no longer good."
I took that to mean she was either a wolf or the Mad Scientist, but I'm not sure.

Haven't scanned Path12?

UNVOTE KWHIT
VOTE SCHMIDTY

This hasn't been a stellar first game for me.

[Telle]

Haven't scanned Path12?

UNVOTE KWHIT
VOTE SCHMIDTY

This hasn't been a stellar first game for me.

Ummmm... you're about 19 minutes too late.

[KWhit]

Haven't scanned Path12?

UNVOTE KWHIT
VOTE SCHMIDTY

This hasn't been a stellar first game for me.

This is kind of funny.

[LoneStarGirl]

Anybody remember what time Cronin said he would be back?

[Gonzo]

Ummmm... you're about 19 minutes too late.

I thought the deadline was brought forward because St Cronin was going to be late.

[JHandley]

Oh well. I probably revealed too early. Hope there aren't many wolves left.
FWIW, there's no way the wolves missed the clues you were dropping. I think it was the right play to come out in the open and share what you have.

[DaddyTorgo]

ya know...path could be a wolf

he's a hell of a wolf, and as I was walking home from work the thought did cross my mind...no proof at all.

anyways...barring a second reveal that would throw things into question

TRUST:
Kwhit
Gonzo
Cartman
DaddyTorgo

low trust:
all of the rest of you

[Gonzo]

But Kwhit, I am curious, what made you scan Gonzo?

Because I'm insane. It was all part of my brilliant plan to be scanned and form a COT. :cool:

[JHandley]

Because I'm insane. It was all part of my brilliant plan to be scanned and form a COT. :cool:
Does your brilliant plan also include voting for the only scanner we have left? ;)

[Gonzo]

ya know...path could be a wolf

he's a hell of a wolf, and as I was walking home from work the thought did cross my mind...no proof at all.

Yep. No proof, but it's fairly obvious.

[Telle]

I thought the deadline was brought forward because St Cronin was going to be late.

KWhit, you SURE it was worth it to save this guy?? :)

[Gonzo]

So it wasn't brought forward? Oh well.

[RendeR]

Cronin did post that night actions could be changed up to the point that he posts the lynch results.


Good game Kwhit, yer a dead man later I'm betting =(

[DaddyTorgo]

maybe not the worst thing ever. Because we're not sure what schmidty is...we could have been another villager down.

VOTE PATH12

presuming I survive the night. Let's see what that does.

[LoneStarGirl]

I am so impatient

[LoneStarGirl]

I am getting very very sleepy, I dont think I can stay awake much longer

[LoneStarGirl]

I am going to bed

[path12]

See now just about the time I begin to trust you a little bit you post something like this.

You're not a lazy WW gamer, but this entire game you've been one. Why this game? Why the shift from the normally very precise and active role you normally take on in a game?

Catching up, but this is a very good point. If I'm dead for some reason never mind.

[path12]

Jeez, is nobody reading what I'm writing?

I am, but I wasn't here. :(

[Chief Rum]

Excuse me? Find a post of mine where I defended Chief Rum.

Man, I get no love. :)

[path12]

FWIW, there's no way the wolves missed the clues you were dropping. I think it was the right play to come out in the open and share what you have.

I agree.

[path12]

Yep. No proof, but it's fairly obvious.

Huh?

[DaddyTorgo]

keep catching up Path. You missed the point where I'm clear.

[path12]

maybe not the worst thing ever. Because we're not sure what schmidty is...we could have been another villager down.

VOTE PATH12

presuming I survive the night. Let's see what that does.

OK, let me get this straight. I put in damn near the only analysis all friggin' day, point to Schmidty and Render, you guys fuck around and end up with a tie because people IN THE DAMN THREAD don't switch, so path must be a wolf?

DT, I believe KWhit that you're a villager, but you are not playing your best game here.

[path12]

I also think that was a very nice save for Schmidty. Very well played.

[DaddyTorgo]

I freely stated that I have no proof path, that it was just a thought that popped into my head as I was walking home, when I didn't remember your analysis during the day.

I also just said i'd vote for you to "see what it did" it isn't necessarily my final choice, and you know i'll switch 2-3 times tomorrow

[Neon_Chaos]

KWhit, Gonzo, Cartman, DT, I'm sorry I wasn't around for the deadline. Seeing as how KWhit practically sacrificed himself to reveal who the villagers are, I'm going to go with whomever you vote this day.

[DaddyTorgo]

i'm a crappy villager though, you all forget that.

[Neon_Chaos]

But you're a CONFIRMED villager. And that's all I need.

[JHandley]

OK, let me get this straight. I put in damn near the only analysis all friggin' day, point to Schmidty and Render, you guys fuck around and end up with a tie because people IN THE DAMN THREAD don't switch, so path must be a wolf?

DT, I believe KWhit that you're a villager, but you are not playing your best game here.

To be fair, DT and I were both in the same spot. We both understood what KWhit was saying and were both already on Schmidty. If we moved off him, to lynch Gonzo, then KWhit's sacrifice was for absolutely nothing.

[DaddyTorgo]

I think path is more upset that I suspect him

[Chief Rum]

Hmm, I thought st.cronin said he would only be a couple hours late. Didn't think I wouldn't be around when he did the deadline, but I'm almost ready to go to bed.

[path12]

I think path is more upset that I suspect him

Occasionally I overreact. I'm rarely upset.

[path12]

To be fair, DT and I were both in the same spot. We both understood what KWhit was saying and were both already on Schmidty. If we moved off him, to lynch Gonzo, then KWhit's sacrifice was for absolutely nothing.

Fair enough. Who was in the thread who wasn't on Schmidty?

[path12]

I could look it up, I guess. Looks like LSG and Schmidty were.

[Neon_Chaos]

So, who do we lynch next? Schmidty or LSG?

[Schmidty]

I could look it up, I guess. Looks like LSG and Schmidty were.

Just got home from work, and about to head for bed. Maybe I'm just tired, but what do you mean?

[KWhit]

Wow. I wasn't expecting to still be alive this morning.

[Neon_Chaos]

KWhit, I think you sould try and give information to everyone before the night actions come through.

[KWhit]

My scan information is that Gonzo, Cartman, Tanglewood, and DaddyTorgo are human.

I also scanned Oliegirl and this is what I got:

You are unable to complete your test, as you black out shortly after dinner. You wake up in the morning with no memory of what happened during the night, and oliegirl's dna sample, having been left out overnight, is no longer good.

Like I said before, I think this means she was the Mad Scientist (and was why I was pushing so hard for us to lynch her). I actually thought I was a bit too forceful on that and was afraid that I made it obvious I was the seer.

After having to be pretty heavy handed in saying we should save Gonzo last night, I knew the jig was up if people were paying attentin and figured I would be a target for wolf-kill soon anyway, so I decided it was time to get the info out there.

[KWhit]

My other thoughts on people:

Good Trust (I know they aren't wolves, but could be Mad Scientist):

DaddyTorgo: Human
cartman: Human
Gonzo: HumanSlight Trust:

Neon Chaos: Cast what he thought was the tie-breaking vote against Chief Rum after Alan's reveal. However, he isn't totally trusted, because the writing was kind of on the wall for CR and this could be a savvy wolf play.
JHandley: Came out supporting me pretty early, so he has a slight positive vibe - but could still be a bad guy.Neutral:

Path12: Advocated the seer outing himself. Could be a suspicious move. I looked through all of his other posts yesterday and didn't see anything else to indicate he is a wolf/mad scientist.
Telle: Pretty quiet. Did move her vote off of Gonzo last night at the last second, but it would have been very suspicious of her not to, so it could have been a ploy.
RendeR: I had a lot of suspicion on him early, but something in his voting record made me move him back to neutral (but I can't remember exactly what now). So he's at the very bottom of my neutral list.Slight wolf vibe:

LoneStarGirl: Check last night's voting record closely. Read: slight wolfish
Schmidty: Not much to go on other than his suspicious voting history. He'd be my #1 candidate to look at tonight.

[Barkeep49]

I hope everything's OK with cronin.

[LoneStarGirl]

Render and Jhandley were in the thread at the time of Kwhit's reveal and didn't move their vote, and I rebooted my computer 5 minutes before deadline because I wrote a long ass post and the post quick reply button wasn't working, I didn't ssee Kwhit's post until after deadline....



I am also worried about Cronin... he is almost 12 hours late on the vote. I think we should stop playing the game until he comes back and confirms he is okay

[Neon_Chaos]

My other thoughts on people:

Good Trust (I know they aren't wolves, but could be Mad Scientist):
DaddyTorgo: Human
cartman: Human
Gonzo: HumanSlight Trust:
Neon Chaos: Cast what he thought was the tie-breaking vote against Chief Rum after Alan's reveal. However, he isn't totally trusted, because the writing was kind of on the wall for CR and this could be a savvy wolf play.
JHandley: Came out supporting me pretty early, so he has a slight positive vibe - but could still be a bad guy.Neutral:
Path12: Advocated the seer outing himself. Could be a suspicious move. I looked through all of his other posts yesterday and didn't see anything else to indicate he is a wolf/mad scientist.
Telle: Pretty quiet. Did move her vote off of Gonzo last night at the last second, but it would have been very suspicious of her not to, so it could have been a ploy.
RendeR: I had a lot of suspicion on him early, but something in his voting record made me move him back to neutral (but I can't remember exactly what now). So he's at the very bottom of my neutral list.Slight wolf vibe:
LoneStarGirl: Check last night's voting record closely. Read: slight wolfish
Schmidty: Not much to go on other than his suspicious voting history. He'd be my #1 candidate to look at tonight.

I voted to break the tie, and CW was the only choice after AlanT's reveal.

I have no doubt that we have to vote for either Schmidty or LSG tonight.

Render may be a wolf, and was saved by some good strategic play from CR, blowing me right off his trail. However, since his acquital several days ago, he hasn't taken advantage of the situation and hasn't really been overly vocal trying to help us weed out the wolves, something highly suspicious of someone who practically has been given a pass as a villager.

He should be next on the line for choices on the chopping block.

Telle and path have both been playing a steady game. They aren't on my trust list, but aren't on my guilty list either.

One wolf lynched goes a LONG way, guys. The numbers are working against us. We lynch one wolf and we can extend this game (which I feel is headed towards the end-game already, considering we've only been able to lynch one) by a day or two.

[Neon_Chaos]

DT, cartman, Gonzo...

KWhit is probably going to be the wolves' target tonight. We NEED to be united with our vote. You take the lead, and I will follow.

[RendeR]

I didn't get my vote moved last night, was dealing with my son at the time. I'm not sure moving it would have mattered to anyone anyway. Every time I've moved my vote late like that the rest of you have screamed WOLF about it.

[Neon_Chaos]

I am also worried about Cronin... he is almost 12 hours late on the vote. I think we should stop playing the game until he comes back and confirms he is okay

I understand. But it helps if we don't think of the worst. I'm sure st.cronin will pop up soon.

[Neon_Chaos]

I didn't get my vote moved last night, was dealing with my son at the time. I'm not sure moving it would have mattered to anyone anyway. Every time I've moved my vote late like that the rest of you have screamed WOLF about it.

RendeR, can you give us your take on the people left, that haven't been confirmed by KWhit as villagers?

Myself
Schmidty
LoneStarGirl
Telle
Path12
JHandley

[Neon_Chaos]

Same with you Telle, since you're online... what's your take on everyone left?

Myself
Schmidty
LoneStarGirl
RendeR
Path12
JHandley

[RendeR]

I have my suspicions about LSG. I'm curious about ehr voting history. Has she ever made a move close to deadline? I don't remember it happening. One thing wolves don't need to wory about is the deadline, they KNOW who the wolves are and can set their vote at any point without fear of a reveal affecting their choices.

Gonna look back through the analysis posts and see what I can find out.

LSG, Neon Chaos, Schmidty... these are my options for voting. I'm not sure on Telle but she's been playing a pretty normal game thus far. Could be wrong but I just don't get that wolfy vibe off her.

I'm a little worried about Cronin as well, but I'm sure he'll be along to catch everything up soon.

[st.cronin]

Ok, sorry for the long wait.

[Neon_Chaos]

Alright. st.cronin's back! Woohoo.

[RendeR]

I'll add path12 to my possible voting list. He's been on top of things this game but I also know he's a damned good wolf when he is one...he could be the "helpful villager" wolf this game.

[Neon_Chaos]

I'll add path12 to my possible voting list. He's been on top of things this game but I also know he's a damned good wolf when he is one...he could be the "helpful villager" wolf this game.

Care to put in some in-deth analysis?

Myself
Schmidty
LoneStarGirl
Telle
Path12
JHandley

[Telle]

Pretty much everybody is in my "neutral" category. Even with all my note taking I don't feel like I have anything to really pin someone down as either a potential wolf or a potential villager.

Neon_Chaos - Earlier on I was thinking wolf.. but that tie-breaking vote on Cheif Rum makes me reconsider that.

Schmidty - Not a whole lot to go on.. been quiet, but that's due to being busy in real life. So no real info to be able to go either way on him. He did miss the whole KWhit reveal thing last night when he moved his vote to save himself.. but it was all happening in the last couple of minutes before deadline.

LoneStarGirl - I had thought she was "player x" due to post #732 where she told Alan T he should have known she wouldn't have voted for him, or something along those lines. With KWhits reveal, that theory's gone. I haven't had a chance to go back and re-evaluate her since then.. but she seems kinda wishy-washy.

RendeR - Been acting odd, but not more so than in the last game.

Path12 - Been helpful with analysis.

JHandley - Been helpful with analysis.

[st.cronin]

4 - Gonzo - cartman (1333), RendeR (1339), LoneStarGirl (1504), Schmidty (1530)
4 - Schmidty - KWhit (1415), JHandley (1420), DaddyTorgo (1463), Telle (1525)
1 - LoneStarGirl - Neon_Chaos (1329)
1 - RendeR - path12 (1459)
1 - KWhit - Gonzo (1446)


The result of today's discussion is: NO LYNCH

[st.cronin]

KWhit has been murdered! Day 7 has begun.

[Telle]

Well that wasn't exactly unexpected.

[st.cronin]

dola

KWhit was the good scientist.

[RendeR]

Care to put in some in-deth analysis?

Myself
Schmidty
LoneStarGirl
Telle
Path12
JHandley

If I were awake enough for in depth analysis I'd have posted it already ;)

Schmidty: A bit over the top in his reactions to being voted for, has a busy schedule and hasn't been that active. Its a prime UTR play or just a really busy guy. I'm not sure, but there has been nothing to clear him in any way.

LSG: Another fairly typical LSG game. In the last 5 games I've played I felt she was a wolf in almost all of them and was wrong. I Don't really THINK she is this time, so based on prior experience she MUST be this time ;)

Telle: I got nothing on telle at all. She plays such a straightforward game that I get no real vibe from her at all.

Path12: as posted above, I tihnk he could be playing the helpful villager role at this point to stay off the radar.

JHandley: No real feelings on him either, he's been on the block at least once. he's not pinging my senses at all so I'll concetrate on others first.

[Neon_Chaos]

As expected.

cartman, DT, Gonzo...

you guys have the ball.

[Neon_Chaos]

I am out. I'll log back in later.

I suggest Schmidty, LSG, and to a certain point, RendeR to be on the voting block tonight.

Telle has been "playing it safe", keep an eye on him... I have a funny feeling about him.

It's path12 that I have no read on.

[Neon_Chaos]

That's supposed to read...

It's path12 that I have no read on

[RendeR]

I

Telle has been "playing it safe", keep an eye on him... I have a funny feeling about him.



Umm...HER you mean ;)

[Telle]

Telle has been "playing it safe", keep an eye on him... I have a funny feeling about him.

Ahem... HER :)

[RendeR]

*chuckles*

[Neon_Chaos]

Oops. :)

Her. :p:D

[cartman]

well, to kick things off:

VOTE SCHMIDTY

It is pretty clear at this point he is a wolf.

[cartman]

Dola,

I pretty much agree with the CoT analyses, and I would move Telle to the 'likely villager' list. She hasn't been acting very wolfish IMO.

[Telle]

Well at least someone thinks I'm doing a good job :)

And maybe Neon_Chaos had a "funny feeling" about me because he was confused regarding my gender :)

[Telle]

And at this point I think we should either lynch Schmidty or LSG today.

VOTE SCHMIDTY

[KWhit]

KWhit has been murdered! Day 7 has begun.

Gurgle gurgle gurgle, choking on my own blood...

Gasp.




Rosebud.

[DaddyTorgo]

UNVOTE PATH12

VOTE SCHMIDTY

i think this is the direction we should look to move today. Path...told you that vote on you wasn't likely to mean anything in the grand scheme of things.

I think it's important that we not all bandwagon onto schmidty right away though. let's at least...discuss others and see if we can't work through stuff here, hmm?

[RendeR]

I've trusted Cartman from the beginning. I've gotten nothing but good vibes from him so:

VOTE SCHMIDTY

[Telle]

Ok, so then let's talk about LSG.

She was busy the first few days and so wasn't really active then.. understandable. But then when she is here and more active yesterday, she's all over the damn map with her votes: JHandley #1336, unvote JHandley #1428, DaddyTorgo #1442, RendeR #1456, Schmidty #1469, Gonzo #1504. And I haven't gone back and checked, but as I recall many of the times she switched her vote she did it very soon after somebody else vote.. maybe trying to jump on whatever bandwagon there might be?

She was the last one to move her vote to Gonzo, putting him in the lead at the time. Then she was one of the ones that was here-but-not at the end (along with Schmidty and RendeR) and didn't move her vote off of Gonzo.

[DaddyTorgo]

Ok, so then let's talk about LSG.

She was busy the first few days and so wasn't really active then.. understandable. But then when she is here and more active yesterday, she's all over the damn map with her votes: JHandley #1336, unvote JHandley #1428, DaddyTorgo #1442, RendeR #1456, Schmidty #1469, Gonzo #1504. And I haven't gone back and checked, but as I recall many of the times she switched her vote she did it very soon after somebody else vote.. maybe trying to jump on whatever bandwagon there might be?

She was the last one to move her vote to Gonzo, putting him in the lead at the time. Then she was one of the ones that was here-but-not at the end (along with Schmidty and RendeR) and didn't move her vote off of Gonzo.

she claims she had computer problems. don't know if we can believe that or not. i've had times where i've had computer problems and nobody believed me...that's just a fact of life. and i've had times as a wolf where i've used computer problems as an excuse for not moving my vote.

[Telle]

she claims she had computer problems. don't know if we can believe that or not. i've had times where i've had computer problems and nobody believed me...that's just a fact of life. and i've had times as a wolf where i've used computer problems as an excuse for not moving my vote.

Oh yeah, none of what I said is anywhere near to being a "nail in the coffin". It's all beyond circumstantial. But you wanted to talk about other people.. so that's what I got :)

[DaddyTorgo]

Oh yeah, none of what I said is anywhere near to being a "nail in the coffin". It's all beyond circumstantial. But you wanted to talk about other people.. so that's what I got :)

right. i know. just adding my $.02 to the conversation

i specifically remember a time as a wolf where i used the excuse of "laggy internet" to hide the fact that i wanted to keep a vote on a villager instead of moving it...submitted so that it showed up a minute after deadline and then bitched and moaned about the internet messing up my vote.

[Telle]

right. i know. just adding my $.02 to the conversation

i specifically remember a time as a wolf where i used the excuse of "laggy internet" to hide the fact that i wanted to keep a vote on a villager instead of moving it...submitted so that it showed up a minute after deadline and then bitched and moaned about the internet messing up my vote.

Well aren't you just the devious one when a wolf :)

[DaddyTorgo]

Well aren't you just the devious one when a wolf :)


yep! :D

much better wolf than villager IMO

[path12]

I have no doubt that we have to vote for either Schmidty or LSG tonight.

I agree completely. I know which one I'm going for but will wait for results.

[Neon_Chaos]

I go where you go, guys. I'm off to bed.

VOTE SCHMIDTY

[path12]

VOTE SCHMIDTY

He would have taken one for the team if he was a villager. And since he claims he has no role then I can only assume he is a wolf.

[DaddyTorgo]

very true path. schmidty didn't do a very good job of "taking one for the team" and i think once we dispose of him, providing he's a wolf, we need to look at those who were in-thread at the time but didn't switch to him, for whatever reason they may profess. that's why both jhandley and i were posting the names of whoever was in-thread at that point. because that's valuable information for building a suspect-list.

this late in a game it wouldn't surprise me if none of the rest of the wolves voted for schmidty (maybe 1 on gonzo and one somewhere else with a throwaway?, depending on how many we have left)

[path12]

Right now I'm feeling that LSG is the other wolf.

[path12]

Dola, assuming two. I don't know what happens about the mad scientist stuff.

But the fact we're getting as far as we have leads me to think there's not a ton of conversion, depending on whether or not KWhit would be able to detect a converted person.

[DaddyTorgo]

Dola, assuming two. I don't know what happens about the mad scientist stuff.

But the fact we're getting as far as we have leads me to think there's not a ton of conversion, depending on whether or not KWhit would be able to detect a converted person.

i hope there's just 2. maybe started with 2 and then one conversion by DC/oliegirl?

[JHandley]

Ok, I'm doing this this way because I really don't feel I have much left to offer the game in my role. I'd also like to expand the CoT.

I am the young Sherlock Holmes. Here's what I have.

Day 1: Investigated Barkeep. Came up clean. Turned up dead on day 2.
Day 2: Investigated Lathum. Came up clean. Turned up dead on day 3
Day 3: Investigated Tanglewood. Came up clean.
Day 4: Investigated KWhit. Came up Good Scientist.
Day 5: Investigated Gonzo. Came up clean.
Day 6: Investigated Path12. Came up clean.

Day 4 is where things got interesting. After 2 of my first three investigations came up dead the following day, I just fired a complete shot in the dark. Hit Kwhit. I probably should have investigated Oliegirl. But, I was very conflicted about that. I really felt it unfair to use that information to help me form my leads when looking for the Mad Scientist. However, it kinda ended up working out. As soon as the night killing was done, KWhit came out wanting to kill Oliegirl. Knowing he was the Good Scientist, I was determined to follow his lead, so I jumped on board. I am still as certain as I can be that she's the Mad Scientist.

That brings us to last nights vote. Again, I was determined to follow Kwhit's lead, so when he came out wanting to lynch Schmidty, I was completely on board. I didn't know if Schmidty was a wolf, but I knew he wasn't a confirmed villager.

By the way, this is why I kept defending BK when he went after Alan. BK was a no-lynch voter and wasn't the mad scientist. I was operating under the assumption that the MS needed some of the other players to complete his research. Therefore, it made sense that Also, I may never understand the way in which Alan first semi-revealed. Everyone thought he was bad in someway, and only a few were willing to give him a day or two to sort it out. If Alan hadn't revealed on day 3, he would have had to on day 4. BK was hard after Alan for all the right reasons and instead of working on his theories, or more importantly working on finding a real wolf, he had to spend time defending himself from Alan.

Anyway, that's all I got. I have no new information at all, I have no hints, tips or any semblence of direction of the next vote. At this point, anyone who hasn't been cleared explictly by Kwhit is a target. I just wish I had more to go on.

[JHandley]

Dola, assuming two. I don't know what happens about the mad scientist stuff.

But the fact we're getting as far as we have leads me to think there's not a ton of conversion, depending on whether or not KWhit would be able to detect a converted person.

I stumbled upon the idea that maybe the Mad Scientist doesn't convert, but rather is a timer for us. If we don't find or kill the Mad Scientist in time, then he creates his army and the wolves win.

[JHandley]

Triple Dola -

In my reveal post, where it says "Therefore, it made sense that Also, I may never understand the way in which Alan first semi-revealed." It should read: "Therefore it made sense that the mad scientist would not want a day 1 lynching."

[DaddyTorgo]

young sherlock only searches for the mad scientist though right? so he could run right into a wolf and not realize it...

[Telle]

young sherlock only searches for the mad scientist though right? so he could run right into a wolf and not realize it...

Yep. At least that's how the rules read.

[JHandley]

Yep, exactly. Which is why I felt my role was worthless, except to exonerate me from accusations of being a wolf. I really do believe that DC/OG was the Mad Scientist due to what Kwhit saw and the odd way that whole thing played out.<br>

[JHandley]

And I realize I wasn't on the block, but I felt the last thing I could offer was to at least take one more target off the list.<br>

[Telle]

Ok.. so this at least tells us that JHandley is a villager and Gonzo is completely 100% clean since both JHandley and KWhit scanned him.

So, the CoT has expanded and that's definitely a good thing.

[DaddyTorgo]

TRUST:
JHandley
Gonzo
Cartman
DaddyTorgo

low trust:
Schmidty, LSG

Medium-Trust
RendeR, Telle, Neon_Chaos

who else am i missing who belongs in medim-trust?

[DaddyTorgo]

dola - updated

TRUST:
JHandley
Gonzo
Cartman
DaddyTorgo

low trust:
Schmidty, LSG

Medium-Trust
RendeR, Telle, Neon_Chaos, Path12

[JHandley]

Path<br>

[Telle]

dola - updated

TRUST:
JHandley
Gonzo
Cartman
DaddyTorgo

low trust:
Schmidty, LSG

Medium-Trust
RendeR, Telle, Neon_Chaos, Path12

That's pretty much what I got right now too. Well except I trust myself :) But really the only people that belong in the top trust category in general are special characters and those who have been scanned by KWhit.

[JHandley]

Also, I've got plans tonight for dinner. So I will not be around for the deadline vote. <br><br>I'm going to hold off on voting until 4pm pst and then cast then. I understand we're on Schmidty now, but I'd rather wait to see how the rest of the day plays out before casting a vote that I may not be able to change.<br>

[DaddyTorgo]

That's pretty much what I got right now too. Well except I trust myself :) But really the only people that belong in the top trust category in general are special characters and those who have been scanned by KWhit.

you don't trust your man? ouch!! :D

[DaddyTorgo]

Also, I've got plans tonight for dinner. So I will not be around for the deadline vote.

I'm going to hold off on voting until 4pm pst and then cast then. I understand we're on Schmidty now, but I'd rather wait to see how the rest of the day plays out before casting a vote that I may not be able to change.


solid plan. just don't forget to vote!! we'll likely need all the votes we can get

[DaddyTorgo]

out for lunch. better part of an hour likely

[JHandley]

Hey, looks like we have a pretty constant visitor to the thread. Cap Ologist, are you planning on playing in the next game?<br>

[Telle]

you don't trust your man? ouch!! :D

Hell no :)

[Cap Ologist]

Hey, looks like we have a pretty constant visitor to the thread. Cap Ologist, are you planning on playing in the next game?<br>

Only if you are.

[Poli]

.

[LoneStarGirl]

she claims she had computer problems. don't know if we can believe that or not. i've had times where i've had computer problems and nobody believed me...that's just a fact of life. and i've had times as a wolf where i've used computer problems as an excuse for not moving my vote.

Daddy, I would NEVER lie about real life stuff... that is going to far... and I just got back from volleyball practice or I would have done this earlier

vote Schmidty

[LoneStarGirl]

Yep, exactly. Which is why I felt my role was worthless, except to exonerate me from accusations of being a wolf. I really do believe that DC/OG was the Mad Scientist due to what Kwhit saw and the odd way that whole thing played out.<br>

Well if that is true then after we get one more wolf that should be game right?

[JHandley]

That's my hope. Even if all I did was narrow the suspects, then I think it was a worthwhile reveal at this point in the game.<br>

[JHandley]

Well if that is true then after we get one more wolf that should be game right?

Now I understand your question. I don't know. It's my belief that there's 3 wolves plus the mad scientist.

[LoneStarGirl]

Now I understand your question. I don't know. It's my belief that there's 3 wolves plus the mad scientist.

I was hoping it was only two wolves with the mad scientist but maybe not

[LoneStarGirl]

I think that we need to start looking at a conversion ability... Shouldn't the mad scientist be powerful enough to create another wolf? I think after we kill schmidty tonight, tomorrow we need to look at people that were cleared in the first three days

[path12]

I think that we need to start looking at a conversion ability... Shouldn't the mad scientist be powerful enough to create another wolf? I think after we kill schmidty tonight, tomorrow we need to look at people that were cleared in the first three days

Actually, if Schmidty comes up wolf I'm likely voting for you tomorrow.

[cartman]

Actually, if Schmidty comes up wolf I'm likely voting for you tomorrow.

+1

[DaddyTorgo]

+1

+2

that smells very much like "i'm a wolf and i'm going to try to turn suspiscion back on the CoT" at this point

[LoneStarGirl]

+2

that smells very much like "i'm a wolf and i'm going to try to turn suspiscion back on the CoT" at this point

If you say so... but if Schmidty is a wolf tonight and the game isn't over with, then it is highly likely a conversion happened.

[DaddyTorgo]

If you say so... but if Schmidty is a wolf tonight and the game isn't over with, then it is highly likely a conversion happened.

but that doesn't necessarily mean that the converted person is in the CoT, since the CoT wasn't declared/publicly known until after the converter died

[JHandley]

If you say so... but if Schmidty is a wolf tonight and the game isn't over with, then it is highly likely a conversion happened.

Highly likely based on what? Two wolves and one mad scientist against 15 villagers doesn't sound highly likely to me.

[DaddyTorgo]

i think we started with 3 and had a conversion possible. now whether that conversion happened is anybody's guess. we don't know what conditions if any there were on the mad scientist converting...maybe it was a 2 night process and we lynched in the middle of it or something? or maybe it only had a % chance of success and it failed...who knows.

[Telle]

If this game isn't over once we lynch Schmidty and LSG I'll be pretty darn shocked. And I guess that's the point that we need to start concerning ourselves with whether or not one of the trusted people may have been converted.

[JHandley]

Doesn't look like there's going to be any movement on this before 4 pst, so I'll vote now.

VOTE SCHMIDTY

[cartman]

Doesn't look like there's going to be any movement on this before 4 pst, so I'll vote now.

VOTE SCHMIDTY

I don't really see any movenment at all before the deadline. It appears that the die has been cast, and both sides are in a race to the finish.

[Telle]

Schmidty and Gonzo are the only two that have not yet voted. All others have voted for Schmidty.

[RendeR]

If Gonzo votes for schmidty also can we then get a Nightfall vote?

[Schmidty]

Highly likely based on what? Two wolves and one mad scientist against 15 villagers doesn't sound highly likely to me.

A conversion has happened. That person just doesn't know quite yet.

Wanna play a guessing game, Sherlock???

[st.cronin]

I will accept nightfall votes, but will require a unanimous decision.

[DaddyTorgo]

A conversion has happened. That person just doesn't know quite yet.

Wanna play a guessing game, Sherlock???

the only way you'd know this is if you were the mad scientist, or if the scientist could communicate with the wolves...

either way...looks like a lynch of you is the right move

cronin...can you process early?

i think we'd all agree nothing seems likely to change, and those 2 votes can't change anything

VOTE NIGHTFALL

[JHandley]

VOTE NIGHTFALL

[Schmidty]

the only way you'd know this is if you were the mad scientist, or if the scientist could communicate with the wolves...

either way...looks like a lynch of you is the right move

cronin...can you process early?

i think we'd all agree nothing seems likely to change, and those 2 votes can't change anything

VOTE NIGHTFALL

How perfect that you were the one to respond to my post.........

[st.cronin]

dola

I'll also need night actions from players with night actions.

[Telle]

VOTE NIGHTFALL

[Telle]

How perfect that you were the one to respond to my post.........

As path said during the after-game discussion last game, "Sew fear, confusion and doubt. A fun way to play as a wolf."

[Schmidty]

As path said during the after-game discussion last game, "Sew fear, confusion and doubt. A fun way to play as a wolf."

I agree with that, and I might be lying, but I might not be. Would I be stupid enough to out a "potential" wolf? Apparantly I am.

But it won't matter after this lynch, because tomorrow is your last day. :) :) :)

[Telle]

I agree with that, and I might be lying, but I might not be. Would I be stupid enough to out a "potential" wolf? Apparantly I am.

But it won't matter after this lynch, because tomorrow is your last day. :) :) :)

So then why don't you go ahead and vote nightfall and bring on your wolf-winning day? :)

[Schmidty]

Because I want to prolong your suffering!!!!!!!! :D

[DaddyTorgo]

i can say this. i'm not a wolf right now, and i have not had any notice that i was converted at all.

i get really pissed off when i get converted too. because then it's like...stabbing the team you've been fighting for in the back. so i hope i wasn't.

[DaddyTorgo]

well...least we found 2 of them. out of how many...who knows.

[path12]

VOTE NIGHTFALL

That really was a good play to save yourself last night, Schmidty.

[Schmidty]

One note - I have never lied one time about real life stuff in this game. It really has been hard for me schedule-wise, and I really do work graveyards at the Bellingham Herald.

I just wanted to make sure no one thought I was trying to be slimey about that kind of stuff.

[Schmidty]

VOTE NIGHTFALL

That really was a good play to save yourself last night, Schmidty.

Thanks man.

By the way, for various reasons, I really can't vote nightfall quite yet.

[cartman]

VOTE NIGHTFALL

[DaddyTorgo]

still not sure how the hell we didn't get a lynch last night...that's pretty absurd.

well done schmidty

[cartman]

My fault for the no lynch. It took longer to cook dinner last night than I expected, and I missed the scan info and wasn't able to move my vote off of Gonzo.

[path12]

still not sure how the hell we didn't get a lynch last night...that's pretty absurd.

well done schmidty

Because Schmidty bullied himself out of it.

[DaddyTorgo]

yes. and i compliment him for that.

[Schmidty]

Well, it's a beautiful day here, and I have a 1:36 p.m. tee time at Lake Padden, so I'm off to shoot 9.

See you all in a few hours!!!!

[Poli]

I'm disappointed in the relatively low number of Kate Beckinsale pics in this thread. I thought Cronin would post some each day.

[DaddyTorgo]

I'm disappointed in the relatively low number of Kate Beckinsale pics in this thread. I thought Cronin would post some each day.

barkeep cried foul. something about public places and internet filters and such.

[st.cronin]

I'm disappointed in the relatively low number of Kate Beckinsale pics in this thread. I thought Cronin would post some each day.

I had intended to. I was also actually hoping to find pics of guys getting eaten by wolves, too. It's not as easy to find those as you might think.

[Poli]

Bah, pictures free float through general discussion with ease.

[LoneStarGirl]

vote nightfall


not that it matters though

[RendeR]

VOTE NIGHTFALL

[cartman]

VOTE SHOVING SCHMIDTY'S 3 WOOD SIDEWAYS UP HIS ASS FOR PLAYING GOLF AND NOT VOTING FOR NIGHTFALL

[cartman]

man, cartman can be such a tool sometimes

[KWhit]

man, cartman can be such a tool sometimes

Don't be a Schmidty.

[JHandley]

Don't be a Schmidty.

Relax, Cartman doesn't pull for a university that makes losing an artform.

[Gonzo]

VOTE NIGHTFALL

So...we're boned, right?

[JHandley]

I don't think it's a done deal just yet. Is there really any reason to believe Schmidty?

[Schmidty]

Ok, I'm back. Shot a 41. I need to work on my chipping.


Vote Nightfall

Sorry to hold things up.

[Barkeep49]

barkeep cried foul. something about public places and internet filters and such.
I was just making a statement. It was not my intention to try and ruin the fun for everyone. And Ardent: I pretty much stay away from GD at work for that very reason. But it would be cruel and unusual for you to suggest I stay away from WW at work :)

[RendeR]

Cronin's gonna be away right up till deadline isn't he =) damn I hate waiting...

[DaddyTorgo]

I was just making a statement. It was not my intention to try and ruin the fun for everyone. And Ardent: I pretty much stay away from GD at work for that very reason. But it would be cruel and unusual for you to suggest I stay away from WW at work :)

dood...i wasn't saying you ruin the fun. It's all good. Honestly...a 2 second GIS could find those pix if people really wanted to see them. No big deal.

[Neon_Chaos]

With 19 players, there are probably 4 wolves. There is no reason to think of a conservative number. Too many players to have less than 4. Given that estimation, with one down, there are about 3 left.

Let's concentrate on killing off the highly suspected Wolves.

Of course, Schmidty thinks he's all up there with his reveals. There's one more reveal that hasn't been done yet. ;)

[Neon_Chaos]

VOTE NIGHTFALL

[LoneStarGirl]

bah, where is Cronin when you need him?

[st.cronin]

The result of today's discussion is, Schmidty is lynched. He is a wolf! A brutal wolf! Before he can be lynched, he kills JHandley!

[RendeR]

Ok, so we're on a roll:

VOTE LSG

[RendeR]

Sorry, jumping the gun prior to night actions ;)

[Telle]

So is JHandley the night kill or are we still waiting for night actions to happen?

[st.cronin]

The game is over, as the wolves have no chance of winning. The roster of roles is:

LoneStarGirl - Mad Scientist
Schmidty - Brutal Wolf
Chief Rum - Wolf

JHandley - Young Holmes
KWhit - Good Scientist
Alan T - Van Helsing
cartman, Telle - members of a secret society with the ability to exchange one pm per day, and with a one time ability to turn one lynch to a no lynch.

Lathum, Barkeep49 - potential converts

LoneStarGirl could attempt to convert one player per day, which would double as a block on night actions. This is what happened to Alan and KWhit, on seperate nights.

[cartman]

WOOT!

[KWhit]

Yes!

[Telle]

Yay!!!! :)

[KWhit]

Nice game, villagers!

[path12]

Woo!

[DaddyTorgo]

so wait...how was it determined that we won???

[DaddyTorgo]

couldn't LSG still convert someone?

[cartman]

couldn't LSG still convert someone?

Only Lathum or Barkeep, and they were both gone.

[KWhit]

Last night was a very key night for the villagers. Told us a TON and pretty much made it a done deal.

I was totally second guessing myself about the reveal, but it couldn't have worked out better. From their actions (or lack thereof) we were all over Schmidty and LSG as the remaining two baddies.

The timing (which at the time, I admit, I thought was a disaster) really contributed to outing the remaining two bad guys.

I'm just happy it worked out.

[DaddyTorgo]

oooh. Cuz lathum+barkeep were the only potential converts.

and lsg counts as a human.

gotcha.

[KWhit]

Still confused about the Oliegirl thing...

:)

[hoopsguy]

couldn't LSG still convert someone?

Not with both potential converts out of the way early.

Bad luck for them that LSG went to convert Alan when he went to guard a wolf.

[DaddyTorgo]

well done kwhit!! and jhandley for that matter!!

GO VILLAGE!!!

[RendeR]

Good Game Cronin!

The wolves had us seriously guessing for the first few days.

[cartman]

The result of today's discussion is, Schmidty is lynched. He is a wolf! A brutal wolf! Before he can be lynched, he kills JHandley!

Looks like Dr. cartman Phil was right...

:D

[KWhit]

I mean, the Dodgerchick thing.