01-31-2024, 04:26 PM
|
#1164
|
#ITFDB
OVR: 14
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: LAX > CLT
Posts: 1,207
|
Re: What Are You Working On? - MLB The Show 23 Edition
I posted this in the Year in Review Thread
|
Quote: |
|
|
|
|
Originally Posted by sbmnky |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
This is about the time I head back to OS for a DD recap - it's like catching up with old friends.
Cory - thanks for your article. I'd be curious on a follow up to your competitive mode article now that's it been 2 game cycles since you wrote it.
Below are my notes - keep in mind, I mostly play DD online in competitive modes
Content- Too many repeated cards with similar rating - I'm looking at you Schwarber, Harper, and Ohtani!
- Rating progression throughout the year is fun - let's go back to ratings creep
- Keep 99s to the collections and end of the year cards. Let the rewards ratings creep up and leverage captains to make them relevant throughout the year (see Captain notes below)
Gameplay- Gameplay was balanced this year, but online gameplay can change from game to game based on connection; I hope this is addressed
- Great addition making tasks online or offline
- I would like pitcher confidence to be removed from online game mode or adjusted - it shouldn't impact the batter's EV or probability of a hit
- Moments and Showdowns feel like chores where I'm only completing them to make progress within a program
Sets & Seasons- I was hopeful for seasons because I thought they would be team building themed. But themes were just card types which was dull and repetitive
- Sets was a cool idea, but it caused too many repeat cards (my biggest gripe of the year) yet we only got one 99 Lou Gehrig (did they lose his rights? Hope not, especially with the MLB 4ALS campaign)
Online Mode- I echo the need to have multiple competitive 9 inning game modes. One where the player can choose any card to use (typical ranked) and the other that has roster restrictions (a Live Series only league would be fun). Maybe ranked is open for two week and themed for the other two week - rinse and repeat throughout the year. Or maybe DD needs to start a weekend league (I don't have a deep understanding of how they work), but qualifying for better rewards sounds challenging
- Stricter card restrictions for Events. Not just team overall, but limits on card overall or specific attributes - bring back silver card theme, Live Series, and Low Power (Dead-Ball) events
- BR is fine - still my least favorite competitive mode
Captains- Cool idea, too bad it wasn't adjusted throughout the year to be used as a testing ground for '24
- Too many OP and overpriced captains (Cal & Rollins)
- Remove Captain glitch so that Captain has to be used in the line up to take advantage of its boost. Also let the Captain get its own boost
- Best time to use Captains IS NOW when every card is available. For example, I've starting to copy a streamer I watch by using themed hitting and pitching captains (Twins Captain hitter and Angels Captain pitcher). This has been fun and allows all sets to be used - in the Twins theme I used, I used 3 different sets for a competitive team. That wouldn't have worked with the 2 concurrent sets limitation
- In a discord I'm in, there was a proposal to make all sets available if using a Captain. I like this idea in its current format, although it will contradict my throught below (just wanted to shout out the idea if Captains don't receive a major overhaul)
- Maybe another way to make Captains more useable is make the boost higher to earlier captains. For example, Set 1 captains give a huge boost to cards because Set 1 cards have lower ratings, but Set 1 captains can only be used for Sets 1 & 2 throughout the game cycle. Set 2 captains give a slightly lower boost for Set 1, Set 2, and Set 3 cards because Sets 2 & 3 have better ratings than Set 1 cards - Set 2 Captains can only be used for Sets 1 -3. Repeat this process until the final set Captain has the lowest boost, because the final set cards will have the best ratings. Live Series captains have the biggest boost because most LS cards are too low to be used in competitive games (what happened to the Live series events?)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Last edited by sbmnky; 01-31-2024 at 04:36 PM.
Reason: I'm an idiot
|
|
|