For a $20 credit towards MVP 2005. Make is $9.99 when it come out. I really liked NCAA 2004, and feel EA really up out a sub-par game in 2005. I had it on PS2 Here is why.
#1. Dropped pass glitch. How annoying is it when good wideouts finish a season with over 20 drops. I also hated the fact that running backs could not catch a screen pass.
#2. Loading issues. Why after every play does it take so long to finish the cut screen? Same things when wanting to view stats between games.
#3. Create a sign mode. Never showed up in my dynasty when I called for it.
#4. Players getting in trouble almost every week. Gets rather old suspending guys each week.
#5. Recruting. Where was the "pipeline" that was advertised. Never got this to work.
#6. Time to upgrade the engine on this one.
I agree with you. I love college football games but I had no hesitation trading this game in for MVP 2005. NCAA was a huge disappointment but MVP is great.