An actual POLL!!! Your grade

[btseroyer]

6, average at best.

[Herky]

8 for me. It's 2 patches away from a 9.

[BoomerSooner11]

Quote: Originally Posted by VikingFan4Ever

8 for me. It's 2 patches away from a 9.

Agreed.

[adembroski]

Quote: Originally Posted by adembroski

I'm shocked no 1 votes.

Quote: Originally Posted by heavy_hitter

The game is a 1 for me. EA failed and IMHO 2008 was a better game. This game has so many faults I don't see how any hard core football person rate this game above average with all the issues at hand. 1. Roster Bug. 2. Bad Defensive AI. 3. Poor Pursuit Angles. 4. Defensive Players standing and watching. 5. Lack there of a pass rush. 6. Offline Play Slider screw up. 7. Offline Robo QB. 8. FG kickers. 9. Ratings mean nothing on defense. 10. Return Game. 11. Most turnovers go for six. 12. Can still pitch ball late on option. 13. Having to invite someone to a game by going to the leader boards online. 14. Onside Kicks go at well over a 50% recovery rate. 15. Getting the ball back after missed FG's in the end zone. I am sure I could think of more if I really wanted to put thought into it. I look at the NCAA Series as replay value. After a 2 months most of you won't be playing this game anymore. I am still playing, but have already gone back to COD4 for some games. The patch, if they even give us a second patch, will not cover all of these issues.

I stand corrected

[aggro77]

I own the PS2 and PSP versions and I give them a solid 8.

[servo75]

Quote: Originally Posted by aggro77

I own the PS2 and PSP versions and I give them a solid 8.

No roster bug on last-gen versions? If FIU is really the culprit you'd think the bug would be on last-gen versions too.

[Tengo Juego]

Quote:

The game is a 1 for me. EA failed and IMHO 2008 was a better game. This game has so many faults I don't see how any hard core football person rate this game above average with all the issues at hand. 1. Roster Bug. 2. Bad Defensive AI. 3. Poor Pursuit Angles. 4. Defensive Players standing and watching. 5. Lack there of a pass rush. 6. Offline Play Slider screw up. 7. Offline Robo QB. 8. FG kickers. 9. Ratings mean nothing on defense. 10. Return Game. 11. Most turnovers go for six. 12. Can still pitch ball late on option. 13. Having to invite someone to a game by going to the leader boards online. 14. Onside Kicks go at well over a 50% recovery rate. 15. Getting the ball back after missed FG's in the end zone. I am sure I could think of more if I really wanted to put thought into it. I look at the NCAA Series as replay value. After a 2 months most of you won't be playing this game anymore. I am still playing, but have already gone back to COD4 for some games. The patch, if they even give us a second patch, will not cover all of these issues.

Its not a 1. But it is just an average(6 according to this poll) year to year NCAA football game. Few new upgrades. This and that are better and we have newer/funner items that make you believe it will be better. But its not the revolutionized football game that I have been waiting for. Hopefully Madden will be a bit better, but hoping is what I do every year, only to be somewhat satisfied, mostly displeased. Am I being a brat as a consumer? No, I don't think so. I know its hard to create a revolutionary game in less than a years time. So, maybe its time EA takes MORE time. I am more than willing to wait two years for a game. Longer if needed. I really wish EA would consider doing this.

[mgoblue678]

Pass Rush getting overblown? Watch this video and then get back to me. This was with pass blocking at 0 and human break block at 100.

http://www.easportsworld.com/en_US/video/39643

Simply put the pass rush, pass coverage and kick/punt return game are broken.Sure this game must be fun for people who like no defense and all offense but for people like myself who enjoy a sim style this game is a waste of $60.

BTW the magnet glitch/ catch from last year is still not fixed. Completely inexcusable for this game to come out with this many problems and glitches. I gave it a 2 but I really should have given it a 1 because it feels like we are the beta testers for this game.