Honest Team Rankings

[BV11]

Quote: Originally Posted by astone1996

Marshall should be great in offense and bad in defense. They are really close. IMO this is what they should be Off-85 Def-70 ST-76 Overall-77

What do you think about Cato being an 81 OVR... He should be high 80's IMO.

[astone1996]

Quote: Originally Posted by BV11

What do you think about Cato being an 81 OVR... He should be high 80's IMO.

Im upset. I understand he's a non-BCS, but over 4200 yards. At least a 85 IMO.

[dustytaylor13]

well i did this a few weeks ago but here is how I would rate TN as of then...

QB - reserve true judgement until spring because this could change big time
14 Justin Worley JR 6'4 213 SC 81
12 Nathan Peterman FRrs 6'2 226 FL 77
Joshua Dobbs FR 6'3 190 GA 76
(I think he wins the job)
10 Riley Ferguson FR 6'2 190 NC 75

HB
20 Rajion Neal SR 5'11 211 GA 84
15 Marlin Lane JR 5'11 205 FL 84
30 Alden Hill FRrs 6'2 217 OH 78
Jabo Lee FR 5'10 180 SC 72
(doubt he makes it into school)
29 Tom Smith JR 5'11 213 FL 70

WR
18 Jason Croom FRrs 6'5 232 GA 78
Marquez North FR 6'3 205 NC 78
6 Vincent Dallas JR 5'11 187 GA 78
7 Drae Bowles FRrs 6'0 202 TN 77
1 Paul Harris FR 6'4 186 MD 75
83 Cody Blanc SO 6'3 202 TN 75
25 Josh Smith FR 6'1 185 TN 72

SR
2 Alton Howard SO 5'8 185 FL 79
19 Devrin Young JR 5'8 172 TN 77
5 Ryan Jenkins FR 5'10 180 GA 76

TE
85 Brendan Downs JR 6'5 254 TN 78
38 Justin King SO 6'2 225 GA 74
Woody Quinn JRrs 6'6 260 CA 72
82 Justin Meredith FRrs 6'5 223 SC 70
AJ Branisel FR 6'4 225 OH 70

LT
74 Antonio Richardson JR 6'6 332 TN 92
66 Marques Pair JRrs 6'5 321 SC 78

RT
70 Ju'Wuan James SR 6'6 323 GA 93
67 Alan Posey SOrs 6'5 321 TN 77
Austin Sanders FR 6'5 300 TN 75

LG
68 Marcus Jackson JR 6'2 310 FL 82
78 Alex Bullard SRrs 6'2 300 TN 81
Brett Kendrick FR 6'5 295

RG
72 Zach Fulton SR 6'5 324 IL 88
77 Kyler Kerbyson SOrs 6'4 320 TN 76
Dylan Wiseman FR 6'4 280 OH 70

C
64 James Stone SR 6'3 300 TN 86
57 Mack Crowder SOrs 6'2 283 TN 78

DE
55 Jacques Smith SR 6'2 244 TN 83
50 Corey Vereen FR 6'2 220 FL 77
4 LaTroy Lewis FRrs 6'4 238 OH 77

DE
80 Corey Miller SR 6'3 257 SC 81
54 Jordan Williams JR 6'5 256 FL 81
Jaylen Miller FR 6'3 265 SC 75
Malik Brown FR 6'3 250 FL 72

NT
98 Daniel McCullers SR 6'8 360 NC 87
95 Danny O'Brien FRrs 6'2 304 MI 77
97 Daniel Hood SRrs 6'4 292 TN 76
93 Greg Clark JRrs 6'2 323 GA 72
69 Allan Carson JR 6'1 323 AL 70

DT
44 Maruice Couch SRrs 6'2 299 FL 83
(they have him rated as UT's best player???)
96 Trevarris Saulsberry SOrs 6'4 285 FL 80
-- Jason Carr FR 6'6 280 TN 79
58 Marlon Walls SRrs 6'2 285 MS 78

OLB
56 Curt Maggitt JR 6'3 240 FL 86
52 Christian Harris SOrs 6'1 226 GA 77
40 Raiques Crump SR 6'1 218 AL 68

OLB
17 Brent Brewer SR 6'1 214 GA 82
41 Dontavis Sapp SR 6'2 224 GA 81
48 Greg King SRrs 6'2 239 TN 76

MLB
45 AJ Johnson JR 6'2 240 GA 90
51 Kenny Bynum FRrs 6'1 246 FL 79
47 John Propst SR 6'0 225 AL 74
46 Channing Fugate SR 6'1 239 KY 70

CB
27 Justin Coleman JR 5'10 182 GA 83
13 Naz Oliver SRrs 5'10 179 NJ 80
24 Eric Gordon SRrs 5'9 190 TN 78
-- Cameron Sutton FR 6'0 175 GA 75

CB
21 Riyahd Jones SOrs 6'0 185 GA 81
28 Lemond Johnson FR 6'1 190 FL 76
-- Malik Foreman FR 5'10 170 TN 75

SS
3 Byron Moore SRrs 6'0 193 CA 85
33 LaDarrel McNeil SO 6'1 195 TX 81
34 Jalen Reeves-Maybin FR 6'1 198 TN 77
(he has been on campus for a bit now and seems to be more of a LB style S in a nickle/dime package)

FS
37 Brian Randolph JR 6'0 195 GA 84
26 Geraldo Orta SOrs 6'0 179 GA 76
31 Tino Thomas FRrs 6'0 199 TN 72

K
1 Michael Palardy SR 5'11 177 FL 79
5 George Bullock FRrs 6'0 185 TN 76

P
43 Matt Darr JRrs 6'1 213 CA 76

[TreyDobbs]

Quote: Originally Posted by War34Eagle

Auburn might be one of the most over-ranked teams in the game, and that's coming from a fan. It would be much more realistic to have us around 83 overall or so, with a couple really good players but poor depth. No clue how we're in the 90s

You've got to consider how old the higher rated players are (are they about to graduate?), because a true freshman you recruit in dynasty mode shouldn't come in and start over a senior. It just doesn't happen. Don't get caught up in an overall rating all the time.

[The JareBear]

Quote: Originally Posted by astone1996

Marshall should be great in offense and bad in defense. They are really close. IMO this is what they should be Off-85 Def-70 ST-76 Overall-77

I agree one thousand percent.

A number of teams in college football should have one of their ratings be much higher than the other.

[catcher_0_3]

Quote: Originally Posted by dustytaylor13

well i did this a few weeks ago but here is how I would rate TN as of then... QB - reserve true judgement until spring because this could change big time 14 Justin Worley JR 6'4 213 SC 81 12 Nathan Peterman FRrs 6'2 226 FL 77 Joshua Dobbs FR 6'3 190 GA 76 (I think he wins the job) 10 Riley Ferguson FR 6'2 190 NC 75 SR 2 Alton Howard SO 5'8 185 FL 79 19 Devrin Young JR 5'8 172 TN 77 5 Ryan Jenkins FR 5'10 180 GA 76 CB 27 Justin Coleman JR 5'10 182 GA 83 13 Naz Oliver SRrs 5'10 179 NJ 80 24 Eric Gordon SRrs 5'9 190 TN 78 -- Cameron Sutton FR 6'0 175 GA 75 CB 21 Riyahd Jones SOrs 6'0 185 GA 81 28 Lemond Johnson FR 6'1 190 FL 76 -- Malik Foreman FR 5'10 170 TN 75

I scout the state of GA for colleges and yall got some talent last year. I agree with Dobbs, I think he is the future in K-ville and will play sooner rather than later. Ryan Jenkins actually played at my alma mater for a period of time, might have been the fastest guy in the state last year. My personal favorite is Cam Sutton, I think he will be the best CB from the state in that 2013 class. He is really something special IMO and I'm still pissed that UGA didn't pursue him harder.

PS: Any chance you can post that roster for UTk in the template thread on the rosters portion of the forum?

[OmahaKnights]

Quote: Originally Posted by ACardAttack

That would be awesome...it would really put am emphasis on the difference in teams...as it is now a good player can take a team like Indiana and be competitive with a team like Florida

Considering Indiana gave Ohio State all it could handle last year, I don't see how that's a problem. Indiana's a program on the rise, and Florida was massively overrated last year, in my opinion.

I get what you're trying to say, that's just kind of a bad example. :P

Team ratings can be fixed, so that's something I'm fine with and willing to wait on. It's prestige that I'm more worried about. Ranking Louisiana Tech 1* after they won their conference two years straight tells me the amount of research they put into it.

[nick11vols]

Quote: Originally Posted by dustytaylor13

well i did this a few weeks ago but here is how I would rate TN as of then... QB - reserve true judgement until spring because this could change big time 14 Justin Worley JR 6'4 213 SC 81 12 Nathan Peterman FRrs 6'2 226 FL 77 Joshua Dobbs FR 6'3 190 GA 76 (I think he wins the job) 10 Riley Ferguson FR 6'2 190 NC 75 HB 20 Rajion Neal SR 5'11 211 GA 84 15 Marlin Lane JR 5'11 205 FL 84 30 Alden Hill FRrs 6'2 217 OH 78 Jabo Lee FR 5'10 180 SC 72 (doubt he makes it into school) 29 Tom Smith JR 5'11 213 FL 70 WR 18 Jason Croom FRrs 6'5 232 GA 78 Marquez North FR 6'3 205 NC 78 6 Vincent Dallas JR 5'11 187 GA 78 7 Drae Bowles FRrs 6'0 202 TN 77 1 Paul Harris FR 6'4 186 MD 75 83 Cody Blanc SO 6'3 202 TN 75 25 Josh Smith FR 6'1 185 TN 72 SR 2 Alton Howard SO 5'8 185 FL 79 19 Devrin Young JR 5'8 172 TN 77 5 Ryan Jenkins FR 5'10 180 GA 76 TE 85 Brendan Downs JR 6'5 254 TN 78 38 Justin King SO 6'2 225 GA 74 Woody Quinn JRrs 6'6 260 CA 72 82 Justin Meredith FRrs 6'5 223 SC 70 AJ Branisel FR 6'4 225 OH 70 LT 74 Antonio Richardson JR 6'6 332 TN 92 66 Marques Pair JRrs 6'5 321 SC 78 RT 70 Ju'Wuan James SR 6'6 323 GA 93 67 Alan Posey SOrs 6'5 321 TN 77 Austin Sanders FR 6'5 300 TN 75 LG 68 Marcus Jackson JR 6'2 310 FL 82 78 Alex Bullard SRrs 6'2 300 TN 81 Brett Kendrick FR 6'5 295 RG 72 Zach Fulton SR 6'5 324 IL 88 77 Kyler Kerbyson SOrs 6'4 320 TN 76 Dylan Wiseman FR 6'4 280 OH 70 C 64 James Stone SR 6'3 300 TN 86 57 Mack Crowder SOrs 6'2 283 TN 78 DE 55 Jacques Smith SR 6'2 244 TN 83 50 Corey Vereen FR 6'2 220 FL 77 4 LaTroy Lewis FRrs 6'4 238 OH 77 DE 80 Corey Miller SR 6'3 257 SC 81 54 Jordan Williams JR 6'5 256 FL 81 Jaylen Miller FR 6'3 265 SC 75 Malik Brown FR 6'3 250 FL 72 NT 98 Daniel McCullers SR 6'8 360 NC 87 95 Danny O'Brien FRrs 6'2 304 MI 77 97 Daniel Hood SRrs 6'4 292 TN 76 93 Greg Clark JRrs 6'2 323 GA 72 69 Allan Carson JR 6'1 323 AL 70 DT 44 Maruice Couch SRrs 6'2 299 FL 83 (they have him rated as UT's best player???) 96 Trevarris Saulsberry SOrs 6'4 285 FL 80 -- Jason Carr FR 6'6 280 TN 79 58 Marlon Walls SRrs 6'2 285 MS 78 OLB 56 Curt Maggitt JR 6'3 240 FL 86 52 Christian Harris SOrs 6'1 226 GA 77 40 Raiques Crump SR 6'1 218 AL 68 OLB 17 Brent Brewer SR 6'1 214 GA 82 41 Dontavis Sapp SR 6'2 224 GA 81 48 Greg King SRrs 6'2 239 TN 76 MLB 45 AJ Johnson JR 6'2 240 GA 90 51 Kenny Bynum FRrs 6'1 246 FL 79 47 John Propst SR 6'0 225 AL 74 46 Channing Fugate SR 6'1 239 KY 70 CB 27 Justin Coleman JR 5'10 182 GA 83 13 Naz Oliver SRrs 5'10 179 NJ 80 24 Eric Gordon SRrs 5'9 190 TN 78 -- Cameron Sutton FR 6'0 175 GA 75 CB 21 Riyahd Jones SOrs 6'0 185 GA 81 28 Lemond Johnson FR 6'1 190 FL 76 -- Malik Foreman FR 5'10 170 TN 75 SS 3 Byron Moore SRrs 6'0 193 CA 85 33 LaDarrel McNeil SO 6'1 195 TX 81 34 Jalen Reeves-Maybin FR 6'1 198 TN 77 (he has been on campus for a bit now and seems to be more of a LB style S in a nickle/dime package) FS 37 Brian Randolph JR 6'0 195 GA 84 26 Geraldo Orta SOrs 6'0 179 GA 76 31 Tino Thomas FRrs 6'0 199 TN 72 K 1 Michael Palardy SR 5'11 177 FL 79 5 George Bullock FRrs 6'0 185 TN 76 P 43 Matt Darr JRrs 6'1 213 CA 76

Gotta say, you hit it right on the head. I can't say I disagree with you that much with any of them, maybe just a point or two. I do think Randolph is better than Moore though. I'll probably use this when doing my roster... Bravo!