NCAA or Madden

[cferg21]

(Current Gen) Which one will be the better game?

[sreha]

will from what i play of the madden demo it suck like bad but it is a demo so i wont put to much on it his for ncaa will it good but good luck playing D in the game

[UWfan206]

After playing the Madden demo and owning NCAA 14....I will say Madden is a better game. I had more fun with the Madden demo than I did with NCAA...It just feels smoother to me...

[vhhsfu0509]

lol @ these threads on both boards... every year... multiple times per year

In my humble opinion (this is overall and not specific to 14):

Madden is better if you like to play online/ranked matches. You'd also prefer Madden if you like pro football significantly more than college. Lastly, I think Madden is always "smoother," both in terms of gameplay and menus.

With that said NCAA's dynasty mode has much more residual value than franchise/CC. Recruiting, roster turnover, the 120+ schools. There's a variety of options.

I think Madden is a better game if you're only planning on playing every once in a while. But I believe NCAA is the best choice for full immersion in a game.

[Earl1963]

Quote: Originally Posted by vhhsfu0509

lol @ these threads on both boards... every year... multiple times per year In my humble opinion (this is overall and not specific to 14): Madden is better if you like to play online/ranked matches. You'd also prefer Madden if you like pro football significantly more than college. Lastly, I think Madden is always "smoother," both in terms of gameplay and menus. With that said NCAA's dynasty mode has much more residual value than franchise/CC. Recruiting, roster turnover, the 120+ schools. There's a variety of options. I think Madden is a better game if you're only planning on playing every once in a while. But I believe NCAA is the best choice for full immersion in a game.

Exactly how I feel. For single player NCAA14 has a whole lot more to offer. 100 more teams to start. And for play now vs friends the weather channel actually works.

[ezio]

Quote: Originally Posted by UWfan206

After playing the Madden demo and owning NCAA 14....I will say Madden is a better game. I had more fun with the Madden demo than I did with NCAA...It just feels smoother to me...

I agree with you. I went back and played Ncaa after playing the Madden demo and didn't really enjoy it.

[BadAssHskr]

Quote: Originally Posted by vhhsfu0509

lol @ these threads on both boards... every year... multiple times per year In my humble opinion (this is overall and not specific to 14): Madden is better if you like to play online/ranked matches. You'd also prefer Madden if you like pro football significantly more than college. Lastly, I think Madden is always "smoother," both in terms of gameplay and menus. With that said NCAA's dynasty mode has much more residual value than franchise/CC. Recruiting, roster turnover, the 120+ schools. There's a variety of options. I think Madden is a better game if you're only planning on playing every once in a while. But I believe NCAA is the best choice for full immersion in a game.

that's an ashton kutcher caliber message right there.

[ncaa13]

There the same game this year same engine. I feel madden is a little more
smoother than ncaa and obviously has better presentation. will have both games.