YYYYYYYYYYYYYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS SS!!!!!
I finally figured it out. YAY!!!
Here's what I was doing wrong -
Since every file on the Max Drive is automatically crushed (compressed) and must be uncrushed, I kept uncrushing the file from the MD to the MC. This time, I simply copied the crushed file from the MD to the MC. Then, I uncrushed the file that I just put on the MC to my MC giving me two files on the MC. One crushed and one uncrushed.
I had a feeling this was going to work because every other time, in the browser menu, the file would be listed as 620KB but this time, it was listed as 625KB. Obviously, when you uncrush a file from the MD to the MC, something gets lost or not transferred over.
Oh well. I'm so happy. I can keep playing 2K5 and avoid the temptation of buying Madden 2010 again since I now have an HDTV for my 360.
With my Xbox being sold earlier today, its onto finding a bulky PS2 and HDD.
THANK YOU bullitt and tarheelsunc for all your help. It's greatly appreciated.