I have returned 3 punts in like 2 1/2 seasons. I have broke 1 TD return on a kickoff - endzone to endzone.
I am playing with the Bears, so this might be accurate... But, after playing 2 seasons I feel like I am better at returning kicks/punts. So, I don't know that I am ready to say it's a bad thing. It seems as if there is a bit of a learning curve, cause I have been able to get better returns by finding the right seams and following blocking. I think that's pretty true to the NFL.. Sometimes it's breaking that one tackle that opens you up to the extra yardage.
I haven't thought about that... But I wonder what the BreakTackle rating is for my returnman. I wonder if putting a better tacklebreaker might be a key to getting better returns.