Official "Who To Start" Thread

[RoundingThird]

Okay, never thought I would have this problem:

Tom Brady @ Buf or Aaron Rodgers @ SF?

[wwharton]

Quote: Originally Posted by BlackNGold

yeah I post the trade there. But in the meantime, if I can't work a trade, which to start between the two and who to start instead? Randle or Bey. I'm leading towards Bey since he's a #2 and Randle is a #3.

I wouldn't use that logic with those two, to be honest. Randle is a 3 in an offense that will run a lot of 3 WR sets. Similar examples (offensive style, not necessarily talent) would be James Jones and his 10+ TDs last year in GB or Stokley's 1000+ yards in Indy in 2004. Meanwhile, TY Hilton is going to get plenty of time for Indy. He and DHB had about the same amount of looks in the preseason even with DHB being listed as #2 (it's been said that's more because he's a very good run blocker which brings more versatility).

That wasn't to say one or the other for this week, just that I would never decide between the two of them using that to break a tie. Personally I really like DHB's match up this week so that's where I would go.

[wwharton]

Quote: Originally Posted by Po1soNNN

Okay, never thought I would have this problem: Tom Brady @ Buf or Aaron Rodgers @ SF?

Poor drafting there... and I think the answer is obvious considering the opponents.

[IlliniM1ke]

Quote: Originally Posted by Po1soNNN

Okay, never thought I would have this problem: Tom Brady @ Buf or Aaron Rodgers @ SF?

Brady easy.

Ideally you solve that problem by unloading one of them on a team that has a QB that lays an egg in week 1 or even after first 2 weeks when an owner starts to panic.

Last year I had Rodgers and got Matt Ryan late, I was able to flip Matt Ryan for Julio Jones (they had Rivers as their only QB) so if Brady and Rodgers play as capable I'm sure you can pawn one off on someone.

[Jr.]

Quote: Originally Posted by CardsFan27

Brady easy. Ideally you solve that problem by unloading one of them on a team that has a QB that lays an egg in week 1 or even after first 2 weeks when an owner starts to panic. Last year I had Rodgers and got Matt Ryan late, I was able to flip Matt Ryan for Julio Jones (they had Rivers as their only QB) so if Brady and Rodgers play as capable I'm sure you can pawn one off on someone.

I did the same thing.. got Ryan for $12 in an auction draft and ended up trading him and Cedric Benson for AD.

[WeLLWeLL]

PPR league

Owen Daniels vs SD
Zach Sudfeld vs BUF

Leaning towards Owen Daniels but it's a tossup at this point.

Sent from my HTC One X using Tapatalk 2

[DerkontheOS]

Quote: Originally Posted by WeLLWeLL

PPR league Owen Daniels vs SD Zach Sudfeld vs BUF Leaning towards Owen Daniels but it's a tossup at this point. Sent from my HTC One X using Tapatalk 2

I think Sudfeld will get more targets.

[DerkontheOS]

I would start Sudfeld till Gronk comes back.