No one safe in Conference Championship Week
Not many people could've predicted what happened this week in college football. Even our own Kirk Herbstreit could only muster a lowly three out of seven right. Let's start with the ones that went the predictable way.
Marshall (9-3) defeated Western Kentucky (6-6) 33-24 in Huntingdon to earn their first conference championship since 2002, succeding Tulsa as Conference-USA champions. In the MAC, Ball State (8-4) has successfully defended their title with a 24-17 win against Ohio (7-5), becoming the first Ball State team to defend a championship since their days in the Heartland Conference in the late 60's. Then in the Mountain West, Boise State (8-4) also are crowned champions for the third time in a row as they took care of San Diego State (8-4) 33-14 in the conference championship game, in a rematch from the 2013 championship matchup. Finally, the undefeated Washington Huskies (12-0) had pretty much everything going their way against USC (10-2), winning 27-10 in San Francisco. USC has now lost two championship games in a row, losing last year against the Oregon Ducks.
In the Big Ten, the 10-2 Michigan State Spartans were facing off against the 10-2 Iowa Hawkeyes, a team they had barely beaten earlier in the seaon to a score of 28-21 in overtime. This time it was the Hawkeyes that would claim the win, 37-20 over the Spartans, along with their first conference title since 2004.
The 11-1 Florida Gators were facing the 10-2 Texas A&M Aggies for the SEC Championship, and while Florida were going for their 9th conference championship and first since 2008, the Aggies were looking to win their first title in their new conference, and their first conference title since winning the Big XII back in 1998. In a game that ended in a shootout, Texas A&M overcame Florida 63-42, and most likely knocked the Gators out of the playoffs.
And finally, in the ACC Championship game, the Heisman candidates duo of Teddy Bridgewater and Michael Dyer tried as much as they could, but they could not prevent the 10-2 Miami Hurricanes from pulling off the upset win over undefeated 12-0 Louisville, as they claimed the ACC Championship title with a 35-25 win over the Cardinals. It is their first ACC title, and their first conference title since the days of the Big East, when they won four straight titles from 2000 to 2003.
How will that shake up the College Football Playoff rankings ? We'll have to wait until the final committee rankings are issued to know who will play who and when.
I have the top teams' schedule following, so readers can voice their thoughts about the next rankings. The game has already re-ranked the teams automatically, but depending on potential discussions I may tweak the ratings to reflect other thoughts. I've included the entire top 10 plus the teams outside the top 10 that were involved in their conference championships. The schedules are in order of the last rankings issued :
To start off the conversation, I'll go with my own top 6, and why I ranked teams where they are :
1. Washington (13-0)
The lone undefeated team in the nation, ranked #2 for the latest weeks, and not because it's my own team. We had some tough games on our schedule even though there were only two ranked teams, but we've got one of the best defenses in the country, and it showed in the important moments.
2. Texas (11-1)
Basically, simply because I don't think a team should lose its own spot by not playing, and also because of the other losing teams high up (Louisville, Florida). They've been ranked high pretty much all season, and only lost against the Big XII champions, while having a better all-around schedule than Oklahoma, in my opinion.
3. Louisville (12-1)
Losing to #12 ranked Miami in the championship game could've cost them a playoff spot, but for that to happen we should've seen wins from Florida and likely Michigan State. Hence they don't fall lower than third in my view, but like I said, only because other teams around the 4-6 spots didn't win either.
4. Oklahoma (11-1)
And here we are, two teams from the same conference, and it being the Big XII, without a championship game, seemed pretty unlikely given the circumstances. The fact that most other high-ranked teams also lost (Florida, Michigan State), however, gave them a spot in the top 4. Now we'll have to see how many, if any, Big XII teams can get to the National Championship.
5. Texas A&M (11-2)
The first of the left-outs, the Aggies would've ranked higher in my view if they had convincingly won against Florida, instead of the game going to a shootout, showing their not-so-good defense. They would've also prevented the first-ever occurence of a pair of teams from the same conference in the top four.
6. Michigan (9-3)
There again, a team that could hardly be dropped because of not playing, and that was helped by those higher teams losing out.
And the rest of the top 12 would go like this :
7. Florida (11-2)
8. Miami (11-2)
9. Iowa (11-2)
10. Ohio State (9-3)
11. Michigan State (10-3)
12. USC (10-3)
But that's only my opinion, I'd like to know what other readers see as well.