New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

[Jimmydm90]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

to be fair, 2k presentation and announcers were better than the Show's. Maybe it's just the announcers themselves. I love Matty V but you can have Karros and Lyons! Who's decision was Lyons? Karros and Lyons sound too much alike, they need to keep one of them and add a different personality to the mix

They should get Nick Nolte. That dude's voice would totally shake up the personality mix.

[cusefan74]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

Honestly, I have had some whacked out trades go down in my franchise but I just let them be, it is a video game after all and it's something different happening than real life MLB.

But how simple would it be if they could just add an "approve all trades" option in franchise, call it a commissioner's option or something along those lines.

I'm the same way. I don't mind the whacked out trades. It's my own little universe. Who am I to decide who gets traded and where?

Although I do understand people that don't like it and want some control over it.

[SoxFan01605]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

Lastly, the one guy was saying he wants this control in RTTS (road to the show). In my opinion, you shouldn't have that type of control in this mode, because you are strictly playing (no pun intended) the role of a player. Just as in real life, you don't get to make those calls.

htcONE [M8] 5.0 | Tapatalk

If that is really an issue (though, as usual, I don't personally see the problem with letting users dictate their own experience offline through such options), I think a potential solution to that is to have options or sliders for trades, trade frequency, trade types, etc that can be set instead of manually controlling transactions.

That way, it balances between the "integrity" of RTTS' intent and giving users a way to combat logic they feel is wonky.

[OhioCub]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

forgetting the most important part of the game, the stats, milestones, injuries, contracts, budgets...

Strange, I always though the most important part of the game was what happens between the foul lines, not contracts and budgets.

Sure, the game, any game, has a few hiccups but if 2k was able to satisfy your baseball cravings I have no doubt you'll be happy with The Show. It's more than eye candy, it's simply the best, most realistic representation, of video baseball ever made.

[OhioCub]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

to be fair, 2k presentation and announcers were better than the Show's. Maybe it's just the announcers themselves. I love Matty V but you can have Karros and Lyons! Who's decision was Lyons? Karros and Lyons sound too much alike, they need to keep one of them and add a different personality to the mix

I'd love to see them go with a two man team of Matty V and Harold Reynolds. Any of the mainstays from MLB Network would be good with me.

[dubplate]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

I'm the same way. I don't mind the whacked out trades. It's my own little universe. Who am I to decide who gets traded and where?

Although I do understand people that don't like it and want some control over it.

Yeah, I'm kind of on the fence with this one myself. I usually reject all trades until the All-Star game gets close and then I'll look at the teams involved to see if it makes sense as far as records and playoff pushes are concerned.

[soldaderyan]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

Strange, I always though the most important part of the game was what happens between the foul lines, not contracts and budgets.

Sure, the game, any game, has a few hiccups but if 2k was able to satisfy your baseball cravings I have no doubt you'll be happy with The Show. It's more than eye candy, it's simply the best, most realistic representation, of video baseball ever made.

You are correct, 2k was able to satisfy my baseball passion I know this will be a huge leap, Anyway I still fell the stats, Contracts and budgets are the most important things, at the end of the the you play for that results, im more in the General Manager mentality.

I already made my decision thank you guys for all the effort and time responding this!!!!!!!!!

[CubFan23]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

I'd love to see them go with a two man team of Matty V and Harold Reynolds. Any of the mainstays from MLB Network would be good with me.

I think Plesac would be great!

[CubFan23]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

You are correct, 2k was able to satisfy my baseball passion I know this will be a huge leap, Anyway I still fell the stats, Contracts and budgets are the most important things, at the end of the the you play for that results, im more in the General Manager mentality.

I already made my decision thank you guys for all the effort and time responding this!!!!!!!!!

Glad to hear it! You won't be sorry! Just remember, have patience at the plate or this game will eat you alive! This is not a get in the box and hack at everything type of game.

[WaitTilNextYear]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

I'd love to see them go with a two man team of Matty V and Harold Reynolds. Any of the mainstays from MLB Network would be good with me.

Harold Reynolds? HAROLD REYNOLDS?? HAROLD REYNOLDS?? Are we talkin' 'bout Harold Reynolds?

I thought we wanted to improve the commentary? Harold Reynolds is one of the worst baseball commentators of all time. Sure, bring over someone from MLB Network, but please god not Harold Reynolds.

[Bobhead]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

Don't worry OP, I'm disappointed that you're wrong, as well.

[Acts 4 12]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

Hello guys, ive always been a 2k guy because I had 360, NOW im getting a ps4 mainly for The Show 15.
But im starting to doubt about getting the game, a have never played a single inning in the show, but im worried about the fact that the game seems almost unchanged since 08 or something, for me the game is just a eye candy nothing more, the game lacks immersion with the lack of stats or franchise depth, fake contracts, messed up budgets, wierd retirings, they just add superficial stuff, forgetting the most important part of the game, the stats, milestones, injuries, contracts, budgets...

Plz guys tell me if im wrong, maybe you can change my mind!

I know that you've said that you have made up your mind to make this purchase but I just wanted to chime in. This game is far from perfect but no sports game comes close to recreating its respective sport in my opinion. The support of the devs and this community in particular make this game something extremely special.

[extremeskins04]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

Like I can't even understand the OP's complaint. He complains about stats, authenticity, milestones, etc., when MLB The Show has this perfect over any other sports game to date including NBA 2k series.

And me having played every The Show year, THIS year I have been blown away with just how many changes there are compared to even last year's game.

[cusefan74]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

Like I can't even understand the OP's complaint. He complains about stats, authenticity, milestones, etc., when MLB The Show has this perfect over any other sports game to date including NBA 2k series.

And me having played every The Show year, THIS year I have been blown away with just how many changes there are compared to even last year's game.

I can understand about the stats, because they are aweful. One complaint every year about The Show is that the stats aren't good enough. When the only career stats I can see is AVG, HR, and RBI for hitters, I wouldn't call that perfect stats.

[CaseIH]

Re: New The show payer already dissapointed im wrong?

Hello guys, ive always been a 2k guy because I had 360, NOW im getting a ps4 mainly for The Show 15.
But im starting to doubt about getting the game, a have never played a single inning in the show, but im worried about the fact that the game seems almost unchanged since 08 or something, for me the game is just a eye candy nothing more, the game lacks immersion with the lack of stats or franchise depth, fake contracts, messed up budgets, wierd retirings, they just add superficial stuff, forgetting the most important part of the game, the stats, milestones, injuries, contracts, budgets...

Plz guys tell me if im wrong, maybe you can change my mind!

Well if you new to MLBTS, and you been stuck with that crap they called baseball with MLB2k, then even MLBTS08 would be a hug step up to the last MLB2k made,lol.


I actually thing this yr version probably has more added in 1 yr than they ever have, but MLBTS has definitely upgraded its game ever yr form previous versions, so this yr will be no different.


The thing about the devs of this game is they only add so much to make sure everything works, where as other companies in sports gameing like 2k and EA tryt o reinvent the wheel at times, and there game end up being a glitch fest and havemodes unplayable sme years.


I don't think you will be disappointed if you buy it, especially if your coming from playin that junk MLB2k.


Really the only people you ever here complain about MLBTS are gusy that will never be happy, or guys expecting big changes, when big changes yrly end up making glitches like with 2k and EA games.