MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

[Jakesparrow1008]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Jays fan here, so also wearing goggles.

However, Donaldson and Osuna have been discussed in this thread. If you're in 2017, and both are performing to career norms, you're looking at a good haul for both.

Donaldson to the Mets, for example, has been discussed for Amed Rosario+. Osuna has been discussed for a package headlined by Fedde of the Nationals+. Stats for both would be appreciated, as they help in terms of developing value. In a vacuum however, both are seriously valuable assets. Stats will help give you secondary pieces.

Edit: Totally skipped over Tulo and Martin!

Tulo doesn't have a ton of value. His bat is dropping off rapidly and he got paid. Ditto Martin, who gives lots of value as a game caller and veteran presence, as well as a strong OBP guy. He probably carries more ancillary value to the Jays than he does as a trade chip, but he probably fetches more than Tulo. I would recommend keeping both, as they hold more value in game than they do as trading pieces, unless you want to completely burn it down.

I'm also playing with the Jays. In my franchise Tulo is hitting .380 with 13 or so home runs nearing the end of May. If he keeps this up for another month or two how much would he be worth?

[ds4tw]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Jays fan here, so also wearing goggles.

However, Donaldson and Osuna have been discussed in this thread. If you're in 2017, and both are performing to career norms, you're looking at a good haul for both.

Donaldson to the Mets, for example, has been discussed for Amed Rosario+. Osuna has been discussed for a package headlined by Fedde of the Nationals+. Stats for both would be appreciated, as they help in terms of developing value. In a vacuum however, both are seriously valuable assets. Stats will help give you secondary pieces.

Edit: Totally skipped over Tulo and Martin!

Tulo doesn't have a ton of value. His bat is dropping off rapidly and he got paid. Ditto Martin, who gives lots of value as a game caller and veteran presence, as well as a strong OBP guy. He probably carries more ancillary value to the Jays than he does as a trade chip, but he probably fetches more than Tulo. I would recommend keeping both, as they hold more value in game than they do as trading pieces, unless you want to completely burn it down.

I was looking pretty full playing for 2019 FA class. so Martin/Tulo I was hoping to trade for younger assets. I don't really have much behind them unless I trade for something MLB ready.

Osuna is 1-3 19 SV 2.70 ERA in 31 innings
Donaldson is .294/373/573 22 homerun/ 62 RBI

I wasn't looking at miller/chapman deal for last year for osuna but thought his years of control should make the deal even better.

Donaldson I wasn't sure

[Beastboy2335]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Currently running a Braves franchise. Looking for Ace options with years of control as I am in the race for the NL East. Trade packages and pitchers for the deal are escaping me outside of Gray. Standings are similar to real life outside of ATL)

[whbaseball51121]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Currently running a Braves franchise. Looking for Ace options with years of control as I am in the race for the NL East. Trade packages and pitchers for the deal are escaping me outside of Gray. Standings are similar to real life outside of ATL)

The big ones are gonna be Gray, Chris Archer, Michael Fulmer and Gerrit Cole depending on how the Pirates, Tigers and Rays are doing. Quintana too if he hasn't been moved in your franchise. The real life Quintana deal is a good start to model it after, so probably Acuna/Gohara is a good start. Greinke could be had if ARI is out of it, although that would be more of a salary dump, as would Justin Verlander.

[pickle2002]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

What would a Donaldson to the cardinals trade look like?
STATS- .271/.374/.463 11 HR 44 RBI
Cards are second in division and 2.0 games back in wild card.

[Beastboy2335]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

What would a Donaldson to the cardinals trade look like?
STATS- .271/.374/.463 11 HR 44 RBI
Cards are second in division and 2.0 games back in wild card.

Alex Reyes, Harrison Bader, and Kolten Wong would be my best guess if you wanna start Gyorko at 2nd

[pickle2002]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Alex Reyes, Harrison Bader, and Kolten Wong would be my best guess if you wanna start Gyorko at 2nd

Could I replace Wong with another prospect/prospects? Just don't see him fitting at TOR with Travis there.

Something like this- Josh Donaldson for Alex Reyes, Harrison Bader, Alvaro Seijas, Bryce Denton
Is that too much or too little? (Both Seijas and Denton are C potential)

[Councilmann_Jamm]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Rumor has it for Dodgers to acquire Yu Darvish would have to be 2 of these 4 Alex Verdugo, Walker Beuhler, Willie Calhoun, or Yadel Alverez.

If anyone wants to know value for Darvish.

[Pirates0515]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Who is the best team to use for a rebuild? I want a team that I can get some A potential players in return and B potential players. The White Sox seem great, but I don't won't a team that is already in the middle of a tear down, I want a team that I can has great players that are on a team that needs to be tore down.

[rtwilli4]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Currently running a Braves franchise. Looking for Ace options with years of control as I am in the race for the NL East. Trade packages and pitchers for the deal are escaping me outside of Gray. Standings are similar to real life outside of ATL)

Michael Fulmer is far and away the best fit for Atlanta. The Braves are built for 2019 and beyond and Fulmer is controllable for through 2022.

I think it's crazy for anyone to trade a guy with that much control but the rumour is that if you take on one of the Tigers terrible contracts you can get Fulmer. The worse the contract the less you have to give up, although he'll still be expensive.










Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[kenp86]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Michael Fulmer is far and away the best fit for Atlanta. The Braves are built for 2019 and beyond and Fulmer is controllable for through 2022.

I think it's crazy for anyone to trade a guy with that much control but the rumour is that if you take on one of the Tigers terrible contracts you can get Fulmer. The worse the contract the less you have to give up, although he'll still be expensive.










Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

Take Zimmerman along with Fulmer and hes yours for Acuna and Maitan

[disk]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Who is the best team to use for a rebuild? I want a team that I can get some A potential players in return and B potential players. The White Sox seem great, but I don't won't a team that is already in the middle of a tear down, I want a team that I can has great players that are on a team that needs to be tore down.

Orioles, Tigers, Mariners, Blue Jays, Giants, Marlins, Dbacks, Rockies... you just never know with these teams, they could contend or fall flat, roll of the dice. Trade what little prospects they have and contend for a year or two or start the tear down off the bat, all have good trade pieces.

[wkmyers62]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Ok I'm nearing the 2018 trade deadline in my Braves franchise. I'm looking for a way to deal Matt Kemp so I can replace him with Acuna who is raking in AAA. I'm obviously not expecting anything of note back in return, but I hate to just release Kemp because I believe he could still help an AL team as a DH. Standings are fairly similar to real life right now with the exception of the Rangers clearly being in it and the Twins clearly being out. I'd be willing to take on bad contracts to facilitate a move as long as it freed up the spot for Acuna. Any ideas would be appreciated.

[beekay415]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Who is the best team to use for a rebuild? I want a team that I can get some A potential players in return and B potential players. The White Sox seem great, but I don't won't a team that is already in the middle of a tear down, I want a team that I can has great players that are on a team that needs to be tore down.

Orioles, reds are teams I'm looking at for same thing, Seattle maybe


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[Beastboy2335]

Re: MLB 17 Trade Discussion Thread

Take Zimmerman along with Fulmer and hes yours for Acuna and Maitan

This is a general question. I have no plans to trade for him but what is Miguel Cabrera value