MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • bigsteve15
    Rookie
    • Aug 2012
    • 123

    #76
    Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

    Customizable draft classes.


    Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports
    GT: Bigsteve15

    Comment

    • BBHH1989
      Rookie
      • Sep 2017
      • 76

      #77
      Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

      Originally posted by UTAllTheWay
      I just wish they would give me the option to review all of the accepted trades around the league before they actually happen (like 2K does on My League).



      That would cut down on the awful trades without having to go through the hassle of 30 team control.



      Provide that with improved team and player AI in free agency and I would be perfectly happy with Franchise mode.

      This!

      I mean there is obviously much more room for improvement but this would be huge for me as well and should be easy to implement?!

      Comment

      • Fukaria
        Rookie
        • May 2018
        • 14

        #78
        Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

        Some ideas to make a very good game great and more immersive.


        CUSTOMIZATION
        • More Minor League Teams!!!! A/A+ and Rookie pool at least!!! AA and AAA is not nearly enough for an immersive franchise. A farm system like the Yankees with so many teenage prospects is impossible to replicate right now. There are roster shortages all over the place with the current limit. Plus it would allow a deeper draft.
        • More than two uniforms for MiLB Teams!!! There are so many fresh and innovative uniforms in the minors. Show them some love!
        • More throwback uniforms: Yankees away pre1973, Braves 1969, Rangers 1990, Reds 1967, 1969 , 1995 White Sox 1988, 1967, Twins 2009…
        • spring training uniforms
        • Ability to create and import uniforms for MLB and MiLB Teams
        • Make name audio editable for SCEA PLayer
        • Ability to import SCEA Players
        • More and realistic MiLB ballparks!!!
        • Team Editor!!! (set home ballpark, change manager and GM, edit players uniform numbers, bullpen strategy (eg rays "openers"), lineup construction, organizational stage: rebuild/contention/all-in, switch affiliates
        • editable Manager, GM and Ownership Traits
        • Unite player editor und roster management= No switching between editing a player and moving up or down!!!
        • Two way Players
        • Better and more diverse generic faces in Player creation, more non-coloured glasses, more and realistic haircuts
        • Exported CAPs from other Rosters should be automatically named
        • Editable service time and career stats
        • Possibly an external roster editor…
        • tradeable single A-players. do not assign players to 40 man and MLB automatically, make Free Agents and Legends editable without having to trade them to MLB first, release players without switching. No need to have exactly 90 players...rather have a min. and max. roster size
        • Player Trade Menus sortable by Position, Ability, Age, trade value....
        • Sortable tab "all players" for global editing (eg. fastest players in the league)
        • return to the exact position/tab after editing a player (eg. Brewers left Fielders or Double A) instead of all Players!!! its so annoying to always have to revert to the last position

        PLAYER RATINGS AND ATTRIBUTES
        • Consistency/Volatility Attribute
        • Baserunning attribute
        • Fielding attribute position relative? No hard penalty for premier defenders, true Utilitymen
        • Defensive Positions with a qualifier. Something like that: A skills 100% of defensive Attribute, B skills 80%, C Skills 60%, Not his position 30% No Reason why Javi Baez should be a worse 2B than a SS
        • Real utility players: every combination of positions selectable as second position
        • Player rating: use projections instead of just last seasons stats. Poor guy just had a cup of coffee and is now a 59 OVR?
        • More advanced stats, FIP, WRC...
        • Make potential grades a little more subtle and meaningful: a+/a/a-

        PRESENTATION AND MENUS
        • More exterior views of stadiums, cutscenes of cities.
        • Extended scoreboard: pitchcount, name of pitcher/ batter, nr. in batting order
        • more information about Players: tendencies, splits, past accomplishments, streaks, records....and the league: stat leaders, standings
        • No blocked submenus in game menu during cutscenes
        • In team selection screen dont always return to favorite team when switching sides!!
        • Display useful information in lineup/bullpen screen: Pitch count, splits, …
        • Practice mode: sliders available, information and tendencies available, bench players available, lineup experiments, rtts fielding!!!

        GAMEPLAY
        • Make pitchers throw more balls
        • Better baserunning controls, stop sign for basestealing
        • More fielding opportunities in player lock/RTTS! more involvement, tagging, relays..
        • Batting practice: RTTS Options, Pitch recognition drills, select pitch types, so you only get curveballs or high fastballs or inside stuff
        • Tutorials, practice: Real Fielding Practice with a wide variety of situations. play catch! Batting Cage, Bullpen Session …
        • customizable fielding camera (look up for fielding Flyballs)
        • Option to only hit/pitch in games!
        • More diverse Hitting animations, twisted bodies, reaching, leaning, golf swings....
        • More trouble on the basepaths
        • A quick manage button on-screen.
        • A sped-up quick manage mode in-game: Watch and control the game


        FRANCHISE
        • Full MiLB stats after the season and in the player menu!!!
        • Top Prospect Listing for every organization!
        • A List of interesting player: My watchlist with stats etc. to monitor trade candidates
        • Draft history lists
        • Transaction list for full season and past seasons

        ---Transactions and roster management---
        • better Franchise trade logic (corresponding with GM and organizational traits, roster strategy): Production should be more relevant in trades, e.g. hot hitter to a contender for a playoff push, make contract lenght relevant in trades, Three team trades, More than three tradeable players, Trade for cash, Have CPU convert players /switch positions in Franchise (eg 3B to 1B, CF to the corners) instead of trading away prospects to get a halfdecent player to fill a certain undermanned position.
        • Batting Practice (like in RTTS) in Franchise!!!
        • make Training effective and maybe playable (fielding and hitting drillst o gain development points…)
        • minor league contracts
        • Full Spring Training with Non-Roster-Invitations.
        • Ability to import players into existing Franchise
        • Revisit the morale system: No reason a called up prospects morale should go down. Raise the pay automatically
        • Better bullpen AI
        • More roster shuffle, DFAs, signings and releases by CPU.
        • Minor league signings

        ---Player Development---
        • Custom draft classes to edit, share and download!!!
        • Rookie/draft pick ratings are way too low. most of them wont reach the majors until age 27/28
        • Revisit scouting system: start earlier, cover more prospects
        • expand the draft!!!
        • Edit and assign draftpicks immediately after signing
        • make progression more volatile and dynamic. More D prospects making the jump to B and reverse. Like a 26th rounder becoming an allstar.
        • Development curves! Different types of development to assign to players
        • Development relative to Position. Catchers slowest, Shortstop fastest...
        • realistic deterioration: eg. strike zone judgment almost always getting better. Some Players play into their late thirties, late bloomers
        • Position Changes in Franchise: converting starting Pitchers/Relievers; Prospects coming up as SS, CF and only later move down the defensive spectrum according to positional relevant skills, Players change Positions according to attributes and organizational needs
        • Pitcher development: learn pitches, improve pitches, Improvable pitch qualities (command, break, speed) not just /9s
        • A solution for pitchers who shuffle between rotation and bullpen. Reliever stamina for SP automatically assigned maybe?

        Comment

        • sacbillsfan
          Rookie
          • Mar 2010
          • 154

          #79
          Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

          Originally posted by BBHH1989
          This!

          I mean there is obviously much more room for improvement but this would be huge for me as well and should be easy to implement?!
          This used to be a thing a few years back. It's so stupid that they took it out.

          Comment

          • sacbillsfan
            Rookie
            • Mar 2010
            • 154

            #80
            Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

            The only thing I ask for every year for maybe the 6th straight year is the ability to edit both the windups and stretch motions of pitchers. It would help with immersion and roster creation.

            Since I've had so much success in getting this implemented, I figured I'd ask for the ability to pick any no doubt homer swing from any player. Having the same 6 realistic homer swings from RH batters is insane in 2019. If I want to use Josh Donaldson's stance and Kris Bryant's home run swing I should be able to do it.

            Comment

            • ripcandlestickpark
              MVP
              • Aug 2014
              • 1174

              #81
              Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

              General
              • Playable High-A Teams
              • The ability to rename generic MiLB and Spring Training stadiums and assign them to certain teams. A similar feature currently exists in FIFA.
              • Full editing of managers, coaches and possibly even umpires.
              • Full editing of SCEA players

              Classic Stadiums
              Graphics and Visuals
              • I know this is a very negligible/small aesthetic request, but I think it would be cool if press box areas had journalists on laptops occupying them instead of regular fans.
              • Camera operators in camera wells

              Equipment
              • Team color option for fielding/pitching gloves
              • The ability to add chin guards to Minor League Players' batting helmets

              Franchise
              • Rotating Interleague schedules

              Presentation
              • Just as there are already broadcast packages that mimic NBC Sports (Theme 1) and FOX (Theme 2), there should be an additional one to replicate an AT&T SportsNet telecast.

              Uniforms
              Last edited by ripcandlestickpark; 08-01-2019, 01:28 PM.
              MLB: San Francisco Giants, Oakland Athletics (Sell The Damn Team, Fisher!)
              NFL: San Francisco 49ers
              NHL: San Jose Sharks
              MLS: San Jose Earthquakes
              EPL: Brentford FC

              RIP San Francisco Deltas | 2017 NASL Champions

              Comment

              • TonyMoraco15
                Rookie
                • Mar 2019
                • 180

                #82
                Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

                Even tho Im sticking with 19 for a few years (its a great game) boy oh boy I want Batting and Pitching practice INSIDE Franchise Mode sooo bad.

                And have a uniform creator or at least able to edit the uniforms colors etc..

                Thats it for me. Everything else is good!

                Comment

                • JTommy67
                  Pro
                  • Jul 2012
                  • 598

                  #83
                  Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

                  My wish is that they have more than one guy working on franchise mode.

                  Comment

                  • RogerDodger
                    MVP
                    • Sep 2016
                    • 1082

                    #84
                    Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

                    Add a punch accuracy rating for the Reds guys, might want to make it about a 10 for Amir Garrett though.

                    Comment

                    • Pitbullz4Life
                      Rookie
                      • Aug 2008
                      • 217

                      #85
                      Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

                      RTTS:
                      - no more showcase, it’s boring and hasn’t changed in the last 4-5 years
                      - Let’s started in high school. play around 10 games
                      - have option to go to college, have real colleges add the college world series.
                      - no more late draft rounds unless you play bad. if i play great in high school/college i want to try to get drafted #1 overall.
                      - add a storyline into the game

                      Comment

                      • Mitchrapp
                        E=MC(2)
                        • Jul 2011
                        • 805

                        #86
                        Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

                        Originally posted by Pitbullz4Life
                        RTTS:
                        - no more showcase, it’s boring and hasn’t changed in the last 4-5 years
                        - Let’s started in high school. play around 10 games
                        - have option to go to college, have real colleges add the college world series.
                        - no more late draft rounds unless you play bad. if i play great in high school/college i want to try to get drafted #1 overall.
                        - add a storyline into the game
                        They already have a story line. Its just awful.
                        Favorites:

                        Detroit Red Wings
                        Detroit Tigers
                        Michigan Football


                        I didn't mean to hit the umpire with the dirt, but I did mean to hit that bastard in the stands. -- Babe Ruth

                        Trying to sneak a pitch past Hank Aaron is like trying to sneak the sunrise past a rooster. -- Joe Adcock

                        Comment

                        • shanev
                          Rookie
                          • May 2003
                          • 410

                          #87
                          Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

                          I think this game already has the most complete and playable franchise mode. But I’d love to see an option to export stats to a CSV file. And the ability to create and share teams, uniforms and stadiums


                          Sent from my iPad using Operation Sports

                          Comment

                          • zello144
                            MVP
                            • Jul 2013
                            • 2182

                            #88
                            Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

                            Originally posted by Pitbullz4Life
                            RTTS:
                            have option to go to college, have real colleges add the college world series.
                            NCAA licensing costs money.

                            I really don't want college. I want to be an international prospect who gets signed as an international Free agent.

                            Comment

                            • Pitbullz4Life
                              Rookie
                              • Aug 2008
                              • 217

                              #89
                              Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

                              Originally posted by zello144
                              NCAA licensing costs money.

                              I really don't want college. I want to be an international prospect who gets signed as an international Free agent.
                              If Madden (EA) and Nba2k (2K)can do it MLB (SDS) can to. Maybe they would sell more. This game hasn’t change in the 6 years

                              Comment

                              • countryboy
                                Growing pains
                                • Sep 2003
                                • 52692

                                #90
                                Re: MLB 20 The Show Wishlist!

                                Originally posted by Pitbullz4Life
                                If Madden (EA) and Nba2k (2K)can do it MLB (SDS) can to. Maybe they would sell more. This game hasn’t change in the 6 years
                                Well sure they could do it, but would the benefit of having a NCAA license in a MLB game that is only available in RTTS really worth the cost of the license to SDS?

                                I don't think they would sell anymore copies, or maybe a better phrase is enough copies, to offset the cost of NCAA licensing. I just don't think its that sought after by the MLB gaming community.
                                I can't shave with my eyes closed, meaning each day I have to look at myself in the mirror and respect who I see.

                                I miss the old days of Operation Sports :(


                                Louisville Cardinals/St.Louis Cardinals

                                Comment

                                Working...