MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • 2ndBase
    Rookie
    • Dec 2002
    • 450

    #196
    Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

    Originally posted by TheBrew101


    NBA 2K showed with their ERAS mode that there are creative things that can be done to enhance the game. MLB The Show needs to take a similar step in my opinion otherwise this game just becomes a tweaked version with updated rosters. Give us multiple broadcast crews. Give us an ERAs mode. Give us league customization modes. Or maybe it is something else outside of what has been done in other sports games. I feel more should be done. I'm sure the games creators work hard and there is a ton of behind the scene stuff they are doing but on the surface it is hard to see when I can plop a version in from 3-9 years ago and not notice huge differences.



    Negativity aside. MLB 23 feels good so far and I will enjoy it

    The Show would benefit greatly from an ERA mode. They added 6 new stadiums this year, they could add 6 or so from the 80s or 90s, a roster update to that era and add the old rules and done. Could have a new era each year.

    Comment

    • NYJin2011tm
      MVP
      • Oct 2011
      • 2766

      #197
      Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

      I would love an ERA type mode in MLB!

      Comment

      • gr18
        MVP
        • Sep 2007
        • 2315

        #198
        Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

        Originally posted by Jeffrey99
        NHL is behind every other sports game.
        That's EA for ya.They have to put more into Madden than an NHL game though and when they get something right it's only by accident.You can add things but when you make something like penalties non-existent....

        Comment

        • JHedges2
          MVP
          • Jan 2007
          • 4652

          #199
          Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

          To be fair, I think ALL sports games would be better if they weren't exclusive.

          Give us options (EA, 2K, etc.). Earn our purchases.
          Arsenal | New York Yankees

          Comment

          • sva91
            MVP
            • Feb 2005
            • 2019

            #200
            Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

            Originally posted by NYJin2011tm
            I would love an ERA type mode in MLB!


            I would be instantly sold if they could do an eras mode like 2k. Let the commuting handle the roster, just give us the filters, gear, uniforms.


            Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

            Comment

            • CornHoller
              Rookie
              • Mar 2009
              • 146

              #201
              Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

              Originally posted by Lisac
              Disappointed

              Graphics are a tad better
              Way 2 many Generic faces for MLB players and Minors

              Bat sounds i dont feel are good

              My 2 biggest issues are camera (as it seems it rotates with balls to LF or RF) and custom camera been using same custom camera every year and cant get it nailed down after trying for a hour

              Personally I wouldve liked to seem them build on 22
              Agree on the bat sound. Sounds cheap.

              I thought maybe the reverberation mode was off but no.

              Comment

              • DarthRambo
                MVP
                • Mar 2008
                • 6630

                #202
                Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

                Originally posted by TheBrew101
                I played 3 games last night. My experience was positive. The game feels really good to me.



                Quick thoughts:

                1) I need to figure out the new throwing meter. After hardly ever having errors in past versions, I had 6 in a game last night. 5 of them were off my bad throws. This used to be automatic but definitely not for me right now.

                2) The batting/pitching interactions feel great (they usually do which to me is the best part of the game but seems even more polished).

                3) After a couple games on 23. I decided to play MLB 20 and use a classic 1988 roster. Graphically, I could tell zero difference using MLB20 on my PS5 vs MLB23 on my PS5 (actually the game on MLB20 looked better but I think that was just because that was a bright sunny day in Philly vs a dreary day at Wrigley). This isn't to say graphics are bad as I think other than grass, everything looks good. But I notice zero upgrade here from MLB20, MLB21. MLB22, or MLB 23 on PS5.

                4) I hope they fix quick counts to how it was in past versions. Pitch counts are now sky high in MLB23.



                So overall, if you just look at MLB23 for the game it is, I think it is very good.



                If you compare it to MLB20 it is still great but I couldn't honestly say there is a significant difference. Subtle changes that I think make it feel better but I don't think anything significant.



                And to me that is my biggest complaint. I understand baseball is baseball but this game has really been stuck in neutral. Adding the Negro league stuff is a cool feature but it is in a mode that doesn't really interest me personally. I gave it a quick look and was really drawn in by the narration which is fantastic but I wasn't into having to do the tasks (i.e. strike out 4 batters with Satchel Paige). Franchise is essentially the same other than scouting tweaks (which I haven't explored as of now and have always used auto scouts).



                I feel this franchise has been in neutral even more than Madden, NHL. PGA. NBA is the gold standard for what can be done (multple broadcast crews, real arena PA voices, ERAs mode, etc).. There are so many modes and options in that game! But even Madden has tried things with XFaxtors, momentum, tackle meters, free form passing, graphics changes, scouting changes, player role tags . NHL has added xfactor, custom leagues and options. PGA2K added a lot around golfer skill trees.



                MLB The Show has added.......a tweaked throwing meter, new scouting and a Negro League Moments type mode. At the same time they eliminated year to year saves and sounds of the show.



                That being said, what MLB does do it does extremely well. It is probably the best replica of the sport of all the video games. It is fun to play if you like baseball. It just isn't significantly more fun than in 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019, 2018, etc.



                NBA 2K showed with their ERAS mode that there are creative things that can be done to enhance the game. MLB The Show needs to take a similar step in my opinion otherwise this game just becomes a tweaked version with updated rosters. Give us multiple broadcast crews. Give us an ERAs mode. Give us league customization modes. Or maybe it is something else outside of what has been done in other sports games. I feel more should be done. I'm sure the games creators work hard and there is a ton of behind the scene stuff they are doing but on the surface it is hard to see when I can plop a version in from 3-9 years ago and not notice huge differences.



                Negativity aside. MLB 23 feels good so far and I will enjoy it
                If MLB ever does that Xfactor crap EA has for Madden and NHL, imo it will ruin this game. I hope to God they never ever try to copy that in their game.

                They have the thing that shows some players excel at home, night/day games, etc. Can't remember what it's called, but that is far enough. Just my opinion of course.

                Sent from my SM-G996U using Tapatalk
                Last edited by DarthRambo; 03-29-2023, 07:07 PM.
                https://www.youtube.com/DarthRambo

                Comment

                • Kramer5150
                  Medicore Mike
                  • Dec 2002
                  • 7395

                  #203
                  Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

                  Originally posted by dreneel
                  This might’ve been mentioned… with this game being on Xbox… I just don’t think you will see the big time improvement on it going forward… just my opinion…
                  wait, WHAT? The lack of "big time improvements" is NOT due to the game being on Xbox.
                  People are for reviews if it backs their argument, and against them when they don't.
                  “I believe the game is designed to reward the ones who hit the hardest – If you can’t take it, you shouldn’t play!” Jack Lambert
                  “Quarterbacks should wear dresses.” Jack Lambert

                  Comment

                  • countryboy
                    Growing pains
                    • Sep 2003
                    • 52819

                    #204
                    Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

                    Here’s a box score for you




                    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                    I can't shave with my eyes closed, meaning each day I have to look at myself in the mirror and respect who I see.

                    I miss the old days of Operation Sports :(


                    Louisville Cardinals/St.Louis Cardinals

                    Comment

                    • Bullit
                      Bacon is Better
                      • Aug 2009
                      • 5004

                      #205
                      Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

                      CB, that is a rough day at the park. LOL
                      In Loving memory of my "Cricket" 1/2/96 - 11/19/2012

                      My heart and soul hurt for your lost presence in my life.

                      Comment

                      • DonkeyJote
                        All Star
                        • Jul 2003
                        • 9194

                        #206
                        Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

                        The AI shift logic is pretty bad. They just play straight up 95% of the time. Even against players labeled "Extreme Pull", it doesn't use the shift. Hopefully they'll adjust that; teams irl still shift most of the time, there's just limits on how far they can do so.

                        Also wish that they'd block mid-AB pitching changes online. Super annoying to fight through a 10 pitch AB only for them to bring in Ohtani on a 3-2 count.

                        Sent from my Pixel 6 using Tapatalk

                        Comment

                        • green94
                          MVP
                          • Feb 2004
                          • 3131

                          #207
                          Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

                          Originally posted by Junior Moe
                          I have a question. Which camera is the closest to The Show 15? That's the cam I have used forever but it's not in 23. I am currently using zoom but it doesn't feel quite right. It feels like a bit too much of the top of the screen is missing.

                          Sent from my SM-G991U1 using Operation Sports mobile app
                          Posted this in the Q&A thread… i think Catcher Near gets us closest to The Show 15 camera.

                          Comment

                          • Caulfield
                            Hall Of Fame
                            • Apr 2011
                            • 10986

                            #208
                            Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

                            Originally posted by countryboy
                            Here’s a box score for you




                            Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                            those K's are brutal but you at least had to feel good about the walks.
                            21 K's, I think I'd call a press conference complaining and blaming on the umps lol
                            OSFM23 - Building Better Baseball - OSFM23

                            A Work in Progress

                            Comment

                            • Funkycorm
                              Cleveland Baseball Guru
                              • Nov 2016
                              • 3159

                              #209
                              Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

                              Simmed to my first draft and draft signing period. I am impressed with the draft class generation. There are still some edits needed when it comes to corner OF and 1B/3B/C still but the ages are much better and honestly my first class was more balanced than I thought it would be. Still needs a bit of age editing too. The scouting is also more fun than I thought. I would like a sortable list but was fun nonetheless and took less time than I thought.
                              Funkycorm

                              Currently Playing:

                              MLB The Show 25 (PS5)
                              Red Dead Redemption 2 (PS4)
                              Pokemon Violet (Switch)


                              Twitch:

                              Twitch


                              Dynasties:

                              None at the moment

                              Comment

                              • cvantu
                                Banned
                                • Oct 2016
                                • 353

                                #210
                                Re: MLB The Show 23 Impressions (Xbox Series X|S, PlayStation 5)

                                Originally posted by dreneel
                                This might’ve been mentioned… with this game being on Xbox… I just don’t think you will see the big time improvement on it going forward… just my opinion…
                                We are barely seeing game patch quality of improvements. Let's not act like this series wad making great leaps before Xbox. Visual Concepts developers two yearly franchises for all systems with far greater improvements.

                                My guess? Those working on the game have lost their passion, lost some key developers, or Sony decided they can phone it in because fans of the game preach how perfect it is (much can be done.) and will buy it each year.

                                Sent from my moto g stylus (2021) using Tapatalk

                                Comment

                                Working...