MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

[mjh91]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

The playoff crowds on this game are pretty bad. The entire system needs to be re-done from the ground up.

[jcar0725]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

The playoff crowds on this game are pretty bad. The entire system needs to be re-done from the ground up.

In what way do you think they're bad?

[Armor and Sword]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

Expanded Rosters - Full minor leagues, International Free Agency, non roster invitees

Expanded scouting and draft - Baseball teams have lot's of scouts. We only have 3 (down from 4). The draft is 20 rounds IRL. We need the draft to mimic real life MLB baseball.

AI improvement - Lineup logic, free agent logic, draft logic

Made exclusively for current generation consoles.


That's it for me....those 4 bogeys (they are not an easy task) to me take this game to new heights in terms of depth, and playability vs the CPU.

The gameplay is fantastic. I love the presentation as well. I think it's slick and clean and well done. Audio has been pretty amaizng too.

Those 3 things to me will give this game a much needed refresh for offline franchise mode players.

[swiftsport]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

I get the unrealistic but "wouldn't that be incredible" one out of the way first: OOTP + MLBTS integration. Manage in OOTP, export roster to MLBTS. Gold.

For the actual game:

1. AI improvments to roster handling, trades, bullpen and lineups
2. 20 round draft, expanded farm systems incl. rookie ball. Wouldn't even care if both A and Rookie ball stay simulated w/o the ability to playing them
3. Switch 2 launch day support with MLBTS 25

[bronxbombers21325]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

I know this is a very minor thing that really has no effect on anything other than visuals. But I'd love the option for players to be able to wear eye black all the time. Most players that wear it wear it during night games as well as day games. I know it isn't much but it would add to immersion.

[Karle]

Re: A WishList - MLBTS25.

I would like to see the game make it less difficult to create historic players and rosters. In the days before the game came with full minors it was possible to take a fictional player and transform him into a minor league or historic player. People created historic rosters which could be used multiple years due to carry over saves.

As we all know, carry over saves are no longer in game. The game also no longer has fictitious minor leagers which is great for the current year roster. However, converting these players, without face scans, to minor leagers present two problems:

1. These players all contain certain data which is hidden and not editable (when drafted etc.)
2. If you convert the minor leager to an historic player, no matter how much service time you put in the game always sees the player as a rookie.

Sent from my CLT-L29 using Operation Sports mobile app

[Ghost Of The Year]

Re: A WishList - MLBTS25.

I would like to see the game make it less difficult to create historic players and rosters. In the days before the game came with full minors it was possible to take a fictional player and transform him into a minor league or historic player. People created historic rosters which could be used multiple years due to carry over saves.

As we all know, carry over saves are no longer in game. The game also no longer has fictitious minor leagers which is great for the current year roster. However, converting these players, without face scans, to minor leagers present two problems:

2. If you convert the minor leager to an historic player, no matter how much service time you put in the game always sees the player as a rookie.

Yeah, I know nothing of 1 but 2 is, you have to export a player from within franchise mode with enough simmed stats to get him over the rookie qualification threshold, then adjust his service time accordingly.

What I think would be great is if the ShowNation website would build in a calculator app where you punch in the stats it asks for and then it spits out the appropriate attribute ratings. And what a fantastic way to pull in foot traffic to the website.

[ricket]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

Want to correct an incorrect statement I made regarding inability to edit logos in Franchise mode. Going back to Franchise mode, instead of just downloading my newly uploaded logo and expecting it to take (which it doesn't), I also inserted the new logo onto all the team uniforms and caps. Wouldn't you know my new team logo is now functional in Franchise. So, this a me issue all the way.

Also, kudos to SDS and 2K for giving us the level of customization in Franchise to edit teams as we see fit, particularly when it comes to logos. For me, I'm a big fan of retro logos with teams like the 90's Marlins and early 00's Rays and Dbacks. Awesome to have this ability.

[jcar0725]

Re: A WishList - MLBTS25.

These outside shots of the stadiums look pretty good, great addition to 24. I really hope they add ALL the stadiums in the 25, instead of just the handful of stadiums they have now.

[Vinrich]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

MLB Eras & PC

[buckeye02]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

Sounds of the Show for PS5.

[MannybeingManny]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

I know this has been mentioned before because I’ve brought it up several times before. The fact that instant replay is only utilized at first base and only by the user just baffles my mind. It’s literally a rule in Major League Baseball that has been utilized for years now. I don’t even use it in the game because the computer doesn’t have the option to do so.

[bronxbombers21325]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

I know this has been mentioned before because I’ve brought it up several times before. The fact that instant replay is only utilized at first base and only by the user just baffles my mind. It’s literally a rule in Major League Baseball that has been utilized for years now. I don’t even use it in the game because the computer doesn’t have the option to do so.

I turn it off as well. I don't want it in the game if it doesn't work properly. But this is high on my list as well. Not having official MLB rules in an officially licensed MLB game is just bonkers to me. They've had more than enough time to implement this.

[Mitchrapp]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

I want to create a CF that is already fast, like 80 (RTTS), not 50. This game is so dumb. Fortunately I got it free otherwise its a waste of money.

Btw, the announcers blow. In RTTS they talk about my player during and after the game and say the exact same thing. Every game.

[MTLExpos4Ever]

Re: MLB The Show 25 Wishlist

Online cooperative season/franchise play.
Relative speeds of players that are more realistic.