2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[TheFlyingDingos]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

In my franchise looking to make a deal between the Rockies-Dodgers. The Rockies would send CarGo to the Dodgers for Kemp. Should these teams include some more players to make it "fair", and if so which players?

(Obviously I am not looking for realism as this deal would never happen....Just want it to be as fair as possible.)

Thanks.

[msuboy11]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I am the padres and I want Chris Sale. What would I have to trade? Also want Mike Trout. What would I have to trade to get these two players? At start of my franchise! None is untouchable!

[AC]

In my franchise looking to make a deal between the Rockies-Dodgers. The Rockies would send CarGo to the Dodgers for Kemp. Should these teams include some more players to make it "fair", and if so which players?

(Obviously I am not looking for realism as this deal would never happen....Just want it to be as fair as possible.)

Thanks.

Throw in Arenado (that's the Rockies 3B prospect, I think) and it'll be fair.

Does anyone really care where I sent this from?

[Totte]

I am the padres and I want Chris Sale. What would I have to trade? Also want Mike Trout. What would I have to trade to get these two players? At start of my franchise! None is untouchable!

Venable, Grandal and Erlin for Sale

Trout is a tough catch...he'd obviously cost a lot and a good mix of major leaguers and prospects. Clayton Richard, Huston Street, Will Venable, Yasmani Grandal and a pitching prospect like Robbie Erlin. That should fetch you Trout and a filler prospect from the Angels.

Hard to speculate in Trout but his value is sky high. Fantasy podcasts has listeners mailing in asking if they should accept CarGo for Trout. Insane that a young guy like that is compared to established studs like CarGo but if Trout keeps it up, he'll be a sure first round pick next year and for years to come

[msuboy11]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Venable, Grandal and Erlin for Sale

Trout is a tough catch...he'd obviously cost a lot and a good mix of major leaguers and prospects. Clayton Richard, Huston Street, Will Venable, Yasmani Grandal and a pitching prospect like Robbie Erlin. That should fetch you Trout and a filler prospect from the Angels.

Hard to speculate in Trout but his value is sky high. Fantasy podcasts has listeners mailing in asking if they should accept CarGo for Trout. Insane that a young guy like that is compared to established studs like CarGo but if Trout keeps it up, he'll be a sure first round pick next year and for years to come

Do ou think I could do Hundley instead of Grandal? I could add another ok prospect!

[msuboy11]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Venable, Grandal and Erlin for Sale

Trout is a tough catch...he'd obviously cost a lot and a good mix of major leaguers and prospects. Clayton Richard, Huston Street, Will Venable, Yasmani Grandal and a pitching prospect like Robbie Erlin. That should fetch you Trout and a filler prospect from the Angels.

Hard to speculate in Trout but his value is sky high. Fantasy podcasts has listeners mailing in asking if they should accept CarGo for Trout. Insane that a young guy like that is compared to established studs like CarGo but if Trout keeps it up, he'll be a sure first round pick next year and for years to come

As the white sox don't have a closer in their organization, could I trade away street or gregerson?

Also what do you think I could get for Arodys Viscaino from the braves? I like Ike Minor also!

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Venable, Grandal and Erlin for Sale

Trout is a tough catch...he'd obviously cost a lot and a good mix of major leaguers and prospects. Clayton Richard, Huston Street, Will Venable, Yasmani Grandal and a pitching prospect like Robbie Erlin. That should fetch you Trout and a filler prospect from the Angels.

Hard to speculate in Trout but his value is sky high. Fantasy podcasts has listeners mailing in asking if they should accept CarGo for Trout. Insane that a young guy like that is compared to established studs like CarGo but if Trout keeps it up, he'll be a sure first round pick next year and for years to come

why would SD trade Grandal if they just got him this year?...and the Angels wouldnt trade Trout for that package u proposed....outside of Grandal and maybe Erlin, the other 3 guys wouldnt attract the Angels enough and yes i know they're a win-now team but still Trout is #1 in prospect rankings for a reason...especially after what he's done IRL

[msuboy11]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

why would SD trade Grandal if they just got him this year?...and the Angels wouldnt trade Trout for that package u proposed....outside of Grandal and maybe Erlin, the other 3 guys wouldnt attract the Angels enough and yes i know they're a win-now team but still Trout is #1 in prospect rankings for a reason...especially after what he's done IRL

Ya, I was just wondering about trout, but knew it was a long shot! What do you think about Sale?

[Carbon]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

As the white sox don't have a closer in their organization, could I trade away street or gregerson?

Also what do you think I could get for Arodys Viscaino from the braves? I like Ike Minor also!

Addison Reed is generally regarded as the best closing prospect in baseball. So, you may want to double check that.

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Ya, I was just wondering about trout, but knew it was a long shot! What do you think about Sale?

i think the WhiteSox aren't entertaining offers for him either

[Carbon]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Looking to trade for Jonathan Broxton on the Royals. They're 20 games out of first, and it's nearing the deadline, so my guess is they'd be looking to deal him. What do you guys think would be a fair offer for him?

[msuboy11]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Addison Reed is generally regarded as the best closing prospect in baseball. So, you may want to double check that.

I'm using the OSFM rosters, and he's not listed as a closer.nhes listed as a rp!

[msuboy11]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

i think the WhiteSox aren't entertaining offers for him either

If they were, what do you think they'd ask for?

[37]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

If they were, what do you think they'd ask for?

2 A's and a B

[msuboy11]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

2 A's and a B

Who from padres you think?