2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[TheNumber35]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I haven't ever seen Peralta do that in Scott's rosters... Always .250, and 10-ish HRs. On the same level defensively, I'd take Jeter if I'm going for the WS, any day of the week.

Spoiler

I'm a Blue Jay fan, why the hell am I arguing FOR Jeter?

I have no clue. I wouldn't be. He retires after the first year, and Detroit is more than good enough on paper to win the WS without Jeter. So I wouldn't be going out and giving up Turner for a guy who isn't necessary and is guaranteed to retire after year 1.

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I have no clue. I wouldn't be. He retires after the first year, and Detroit is more than good enough on paper to win the WS without Jeter. So I wouldn't be going out and giving up Turner for a guy who isn't necessary and is guaranteed to retire after year 1.

They most certainly aren't, lol. They really need one more bat, and one more pitcher.

[TheNumber35]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

They most certainly aren't, lol. They really need one more bat, and one more pitcher.

On paper in The Show? That team usually wins between 90 and 100 games in most of the sims I've done and goes to the WS. Every starter on the team has 15+ HR potential, with at least 4 guys who will likely hit 20+ dingers with around 80-120 RBIs. Verlander, Fister, Scherzer, and Sanchez all typically pitch well in sims.

That team is stacked on paper AC, just like the Jays and Rockies in royals chise is stacked on paper. Doesn't mean things will go well, but on paper they look ridiculously good.

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

On paper in The Show? That team usually wins between 90 and 100 games in most of the sims I've done and goes to the WS. Every starter on the team has 15+ HR potential, with at least 4 guys who will likely hit 20+ dingers with around 80-120 RBIs. Verlander, Fister, Scherzer, and Sanchez all typically pitch well in sims.

That team is stacked on paper AC, just like the Jays and Rockies in royals chise is stacked on paper. Doesn't mean things will go well, but on paper they look ridiculously good.

Oh, in the show? Yeah, in the show, they're somewhat stacked, but Alex Avila never seems to do well at all, and always ends up as the Phillies 3B.

Hence the, "one more bat," comment. Avila's generally horrible.

[bluejaysfan19]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

It really depends on how he's playing. If he's playing like he is IRL, then he's worth the A.

he was hiting .220 w/3hr. he was pretty bad. how is the deal with raburn,he is good right

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

he was hiting .220 w/3hr. he was pretty bad. how is the deal with raburn,he is good right

Wow, that was pretty unfair, you really ripped them off...

[AC]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

What do you think a good trade for James Paxton would be? Scouts are souring on him last I heard, and in game, he's been pretty bad- 4+ ERA last year.

Mariners are still rebuilding... would they need a young bat?

How would a Gose for Paxton trade work?

[Totte]

What do you think a good trade for James Paxton would be? Scouts are souring on him last I heard, and in game, he's been pretty bad- 4+ ERA last year.

Mariners are still rebuilding... would they need a young bat?

How would a Gose for Paxton trade work?

The M's need all the offense they can get but thy got plenty of journeymen OF in Trayvon Robinson, Casper Wells, Mike Carp and Michael Saunders, Franklin Gutierrez. Then there's Eric Thames and Francisco Peguero. Gose would obviously be a fit anyway and add that speed they lost with Ichiro.

I'm thinking Hechevarria could be a fit. Nick Franklin is the SS/2B of the future in Seattle and is playing for AAA Tacoma. He could easily slide over to 2B pushing Ackley to LF leaving SS for Hechevarria. I'm assuming the M's would wanna keep Kyle Seager at either 3B or 2B next season.

Gose for Paxton is fair and I don't know that much about Hechevarria to say if he's enough for Paxton. Maybe throw in a C prospect as well...

[AC]

The M's need all the offense they can get but thy got plenty of journeymen OF in Trayvon Robinson, Casper Wells, Mike Carp and Michael Saunders, Franklin Gutierrez. Then there's Eric Thames and Francisco Peguero. Gose would obviously be a fit anyway and add that speed they lost with Ichiro.

I'm thinking Hechevarria could be a fit. Nick Franklin is the SS/2B of the future in Seattle and is playing for AAA Tacoma. He could easily slide over to 2B pushing Ackley to LF leaving SS for Hechevarria. I'm assuming the M's would wanna keep Kyle Seager at either 3B or 2B next season.

Gose for Paxton is fair and I don't know that much about Hechevarria to say if he's enough for Paxton. Maybe throw in a C prospect as well...

Hech and Moises Sierra? Sierra's a real nice bat. Good power. High C.

I would make sure to do those position changes you said. Good idea.

Does anyone really care where I sent this from?

[pickle2002]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I'm with the jays in my first season...

I'm looking to trade for a starting pitcher. I want to keep Romero and Morrow, I will trade anybody else.

And..

I want to trade mathis ( I can't hit with him) Any backup catcher that I can trade for??

Thanks!

[Totte]

I'm with the jays in my first season...

I'm looking to trade for a starting pitcher. I want to keep Romero and Morrow, I will trade anybody else.

And..

I want to trade mathis ( I can't hit with him) Any backup catcher that I can trade for??

Thanks!

What kind of starter would you like to acquire? An ace? Middle of the rotation starter? Swingman for spot starts and LRP appearances? 5th man?

As for catcher, I'd try for John Jaso or Miguel Olivo from the M's. They have 3 catchers on the MLB roster (Montero, Jaso and Olivo) so that's a realistic target for you. Both guys are a C prospect each

[Totte]

Hech and Moises Sierra? Sierra's a real nice bat. Good power. High C.

I would make sure to do those position changes you said. Good idea.

Does anyone really care where I sent this from?

Is it Hechevarria or Hechavarria? Either way I think Hech and a C is fair. Guess Sierra would add AAA depth for Tacoma to begin with but he's got a good bat like you said. I have no problem doing that deal since the M's are in desperate need of offense

[AC]

I'm with the jays in my first season...

I'm looking to trade for a starting pitcher. I want to keep Romero and Morrow, I will trade anybody else.

And..

I want to trade mathis ( I can't hit with him) Any backup catcher that I can trade for??

Thanks!

How about Adonys Cardona and Dwight Smith Jr for Jake Peavy?

Is it Hechevarria or Hechavarria? Either way I think Hech and a C is fair. Guess Sierra would add AAA depth for Tacoma to begin with but he's got a good bat like you said. I have no problem doing that deal since the M's are in desperate need of offense

Adeiny Hechavarria

Does anyone really care where I sent this from?

[Totte]

Yeah Peavy is a nice target for the Jays like AC says and what he's suggesting is fair value

[pickle2002]

Re: 2012 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

What kind of starter would you like to acquire? An ace? Middle of the rotation starter? Swingman for spot starts and LRP appearances? 5th man?

As for catcher, I'd try for John Jaso or Miguel Olivo from the M's. They have 3 catchers on the MLB roster (Montero, Jaso and Olivo) so that's a realistic target for you. Both guys are a C prospect each

A middle of the rotation starter...

I will look at Jaso and Olivo.

Thanks!