2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

[WaitTilNextYear]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I'm going to take the Pirates and I want to build around McCutchen, but I want another great batter. Ryan Braun would be great, but I don't know a trade that would work for that. I know this isn't very realistic.

Wow. Yeah, no way to do this with realism.

For fairness, you'd be looking at perhaps:

Gerrit Cole + Jameson Taillon + Garrett Jones + Gregory Polanco + Tony Sanchez

for Braun. So you'd really have to give up a lot.

Proscia is a high C, but I could give them Chris Taylor who is a low B SS, and the Jays lack youth there as well. Would that work better? Or should I target someone else? If so, do you have any ideas? I'm just hoping to find a leadoff hitter for me in the future.

I'd go with the SS. Blue Jays could use Jose Reyes' eventual replacement. I think Beavan + Taylor for Davis is decent.

[nowitsourtime]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Seattle already has a CY on their staff called King Felix who just signed a 7 yr 175 million dollar deal. Pretty sure they plan on building around him. Not looking to add a Price as a #2 that would cost them their Top-4 prospects.

Just because they have Felix doesn't mean you can't have Price. Just because the Phillies had Halladay and Hamels, didn't mean that adding Cliff Lee is out of the question.Starting Pitching is vital to a team's success. Just look at the Giants.

Plus come playoff time, if I had to face Felix and Price 4 times in a 7 game series, I wouldn't like my chances all too much.

There's no sure thing that all these prospects will turn out. If I'm serious about becoming a title contender, I trade for Price. Price is worth 3 A's and a B IMO

Hey guys need your opinion on this CPU offered trade (to another CPU)

Chicago Cubs ( 28-29 ) Offers:
RP Michael Bowen (4-0 3.21 ERA)
SP Edwin Jackson (4-2 3.24 ERA)

Chicago White Sox ( 27-30 ) Give up:
RP Nate Jones (2-0 4.09 ERA)
19 Y/O A Potential Courtney Hawkins, CF (Class-A)
23 Y/O B Potential Erik Johnson, SP (Class-A)


ALSO another trade:

Royals ( 22-34 )Offers:
RP Kelvin Herrera (0-3 12.71 ERA) would play in the MLB

Mets ( 20-37 ) Give up:
RP LaTroy Hawkins (3-4 5.56 ERA) Would play in the MLB
SP Noah Syndergaard (5-4 5.15 ERA) Would be moved up from AA to AAA


Thanks in advance

The White Sox and the Mets are both being ripped off. No way the White Sox trade Hawkins for a pitcher of Edwin Jackson's caliber. He's not worth that.

Herrera is an intriguing reliever but right now he's just that, a reliever. Syndergaard is their 3rd best prospect in their system

I'm going to take the Pirates and I want to build around McCutchen, but I want another great batter. Ryan Braun would be great, but I don't know a trade that would work for that. I know this isn't very realistic.

Gerrit Cole, Jameson Taillon, Sterling Marte, Pedro Alvarez for Braun could get it done although I think the Brewers would want more but that right there is 3 As and a high B

Perhaps Alan Hanson instead of Alvarez would be a better offer

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

*cough*buthedidnt*cough* but seriously who cares then he was 1b in the race he's still worth 2-3 A's and a B or two

*cough*votersareidiots*cough* haha but I agree, he's definitely worth along the lines of that. And for those asking why they'd use him as a #2, David Price as a #2 is elite depth. Which is, y'know, kinda useful and necessary.

Beaven for for D.J. Davis straight up? Or do I need to add something? Beaven is only worth 2 mid c's on the spreadsheet, and Davis I think is a low-mid b-pot CF.

Davis is a mid B, I made him for OSFM.

Beaven is most certainly NOT worth that. You're gonna have to give something better back, preferably a pitcher.

Hisashi Iwakuma or Erasmo Ramirez for Davis?

[LifeOfAHooper27792]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

*cough*votersareidiots*cough* haha but I agree, he's definitely worth along the lines of that. And for those asking why they'd use him as a #2, David Price as a #2 is elite depth. Which is, y'know, kinda useful and necessary.



Davis is a mid B, I made him for OSFM.

Beaven is most certainly NOT worth that. You're gonna have to give something better back, preferably a pitcher.

Hisashi Iwakuma or Erasmo Ramirez for Davis?

You don't agree with Beaven and Taylor for Davis?

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

You don't agree with Beaven and Taylor for Davis?

Nah, you're still a bit off.

[LifeOfAHooper27792]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I am willing to ship them Iwakuma, if that's both fair and somewhat realistic. I'd be fine with that for sure. That's Ok?

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I am willing to ship them Iwakuma, if that's both fair and somewhat realistic. I'd be fine with that for sure. That's Ok?

Yeah, it's fine.

[MrPolo7]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I didn't see him on the spreadsheet and obviously in an unrealistic world, but what would it take to get billy hamilton off Cincy?

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

I didn't see him on the spreadsheet and obviously in an unrealistic world, but what would it take to get billy hamilton off Cincy?

What team are you?

[MrPolo7]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

What team are you?

Ha that'd probably help....im playing with Cleveland osfm v2 rosters

[AC]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Ha that'd probably help....im playing with Cleveland osfm v2 rosters

Dorssys Paulino and Michael Brantley?

[MrPolo7]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Dorssys Paulino and Michael Brantley?

That's it? Hmm I may take this to the arbitration board, thanks AC

[ML]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Brewers (32-27 5.5 Games out of 1st) Offer:
RP Burke Badenhop (4-1 3.20 ERA)
C Martin Maldonado (.241 AVG 5HR 19RBI)
1B Corey Hart (.267 AVG 9 HR 30 RBI)

Red Sox (35-26 in 1st by 2.5 Games) Give Up:
RP Junichi Tazawa (0-1 1.95 ERA)
SS Xander Bogaerts (Hitting .256 in AA)
SP Allen Webster (5-5 3.79 ERA in AAA)

[Pesan915]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Hey guys, on my Braves franchise I'm 32-15 while the Rays are 19-28. I'm pretty weak at 3B, what would it take to snatch Longoria from the Rays? I'm Willing to offer Brian McCann, Teheran and who else would it take to get this deal done? Another 3B I'm willing to trade for too is Olt, what would be a fair trade for both of these guys? Thanks.

[37]

Re: 2013 The Show Official Trade Discussion Thread

Brewers (32-27 5.5 Games out of 1st) Offer:
RP Burke Badenhop (4-1 3.20 ERA)
C Martin Maldonado (.241 AVG 5HR 19RBI)
1B Corey Hart (.267 AVG 9 HR 30 RBI)

Red Sox (35-26 in 1st by 2.5 Games) Give Up:
RP Junichi Tazawa (0-1 1.95 ERA)
SS Xander Bogaerts (Hitting .256 in AA)
SP Allen Webster (5-5 3.79 ERA in AAA)

that is a horrific trade from the Red Sox standpoint