2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

[Gocanes44]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

First off, great job on the rosters. I played a few games and it plays great.

I’m a cubs fan and started a franchise. I went to add Ian’s Happ’s and Nico’s Hoerner’s extensions and I saw some of the contracts are off for cubs players (Dansby with a 2 year deal, stroman with 4 years, Barnhart with 8) etc.

Just wanted to see if you had seen this

Yes, I noticed this also

[TheSteelGamecock]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Question about speed and arm strength ratings I’ve noticed a lot of odd speed ratings especially for rf/1b. (Examples Chase Declatuer being a 50 same for George Valera )

How are these arrived at? I know a rf might typically be more of a power bat/arm guy is that the formula ? Positional ?

Thanks in advance


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[JWDixon120]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

First off, great job on the rosters. I played a few games and it plays great.

I’m a cubs fan and started a franchise. I went to add Ian’s Happ’s and Nico’s Hoerner’s extensions and I saw some of the contracts are off for cubs players (Dansby with a 2 year deal, stroman with 4 years, Barnhart with 8) etc.

Just wanted to see if you had seen this

Hmmm. That’s really odd. I specifically added those contracts before the roster released.

I wonder if the game adjusts them like it does with many other features?

[Mrlunchbox]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Hmmm. That’s really odd. I specifically added those contracts before the roster released.

I wonder if the game adjusts them like it does with many other features?

Not sure. I did check the other major FA signings (Bogaerts, Turner, Judge) and they look accurate.

[TheSteelGamecock]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Is there an unintended consequence of top prospects being too easily affordable as their ratings are “surpassed” in the game engines eye ? I’m seeing even more unusual trade offers

Also does this roster eliminate the possibility of fast rising or break out older players as you used age as a means of projection ?


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

[cubby blue]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Do you use default sliders or is there a set you would recommend with this roster?

[Quag]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

First off, great job on the rosters. I played a few games and it plays great.

I’m a cubs fan and started a franchise. I went to add Ian’s Happ’s and Nico’s Hoerner’s extensions and I saw some of the contracts are off for cubs players (Dansby with a 2 year deal, stroman with 4 years, Barnhart with 8) etc.

Just wanted to see if you had seen this

Contracts were not edited. I thought we hit the Happ extension but we might have missed it.

I might be wrong, but Dansby might have an opt out? As far as the rest, if the contracts are wrong that’s an SDS thing unfortunately

[Quag]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Question about speed and arm strength ratings I’ve noticed a lot of odd speed ratings especially for rf/1b. (Examples Chase Declatuer being a 50 same for George Valera )

How are these arrived at? I know a rf might typically be more of a power bat/arm guy is that the formula ? Positional ?

Thanks in advance


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

Admittedly there are some limitations to our prospect system. “Run” grades were used to determine speed but unfortunately that grade encompasses more than just speed it also includes bass running. We are looking into possibly using some advanced data that is available to help generate prospect speed ratings for next season

[Quag]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Is there an unintended consequence of top prospects being too easily affordable as their ratings are “surpassed” in the game engines eye ? I’m seeing even more unusual trade offers

Also does this roster eliminate the possibility of fast rising or break out older players as you used age as a means of projection ?


Sent from my iPhone using Operation Sports

Trades are wonky regardless of roster form my experience. As far as breakouts it’s really hard to tell because the dynamic potential system is difficult to track/figure out how it works

[Mrlunchbox]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Contracts were not edited. I thought we hit the Happ extension but we might have missed it.

I might be wrong, but Dansby might have an opt out? As far as the rest, if the contracts are wrong that’s an SDS thing unfortunately

I don't think Dansby does - I think it's 7 years with a no trade clause.

Which roster did you use as the base? I didn't see the same differences in the live rosters. I also saw Seiya's contract was treating him as a pre-arb player (720k) rather than the 5 year $85 mil contract.

Again, great job on the roster. I don't want to sound critical - these ratings play great in the few games I've played thus far. Just trying to get this fixed before I start up my franchise.

[Quag]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

I don't think Dansby does - I think it's 7 years with a no trade clause.

Which roster did you use as the base? I didn't see the same differences in the live rosters. I also saw Seiya's contract was treating him as a pre-arb player (720k) rather than the 5 year $85 mil contract.

Again, great job on the roster. I don't want to sound critical - these ratings play great in the few games I've played thus far. Just trying to get this fixed before I start up my franchise.

We used SDS base roster smh

[NAFBUC]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

Do you use default sliders or is there a set you would recommend with this roster?

Hey Cubby, go Cubs! I would start with the default sliders and tweak them to your playing level.
\

Go Cubs Go!

[BrewCrew823]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

I was just manually moving guys down after ST in franchise mode. I noticed almost every player has three options left? I checked the roster from the saved file and it’s the same way. Any idea how that happened?

[CBoller1331]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

I was just manually moving guys down after ST in franchise mode. I noticed almost every player has three options left? I checked the roster from the saved file and it’s the same way. Any idea how that happened?

The base roster doesn't have accurate option years (been like that for years).

Thanks to Ridin & the roster team at SDS they fixed a ton of guys in latest roster update but those don't transfer between roster files

[Quag]

Re: 2023 Franchise Fidelity to Reality Roster Project (Official Thread)

The base roster doesn't have accurate option years (been like that for years).

Thanks to Ridin & the roster team at SDS they fixed a ton of guys in latest roster update but those don't transfer between roster files

It is very frustrating that that wasn't something the game just came with