I use facegen for everyone (generate pictures for all players/coaches).
1-20 ratings scale. I don't use full coaching system, I don't use full scouting system (or if I do, it's 100% accurate.) 20-80 scale for overall/potential. I turn the trade difficulty to hard normally, and use Normal injuries (OOTP Classic). I find that in my games with injuries set on high (modern day MLB) players get injured way too often. I'm talking 8+ starters on the DL at one time isn't a rare occurence for me.
Once my pictures generate, I'll post up screenies of my settings. Also, I high recommend downloading the 2013 all-in-one mod from the in-game mod central.





Comment