The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[z Revis]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

3 team Melo deal in my Bulls Association:

Chicago receives:
Carmelo Anthony(from DEN)
Sam Young(from MEM)

Memphis receives:
Luol Deng(from CHI)
Taj Gibson(from CHI)
1st round pick(from CHI)

Denver receives:
Joakim Noah(from CHI)
Rudy Gay(from MEM)

I think it's pretty fair. Must note that I'm using Rashidi's rosters and he has Melo at an 87. I doubt it'd work if he were a 93 or whatever 2k has him at.

So now I have Rose, Melo, and Boozer. Ronnie Brewer is playing the 2 and I'm not sure who's going to play the 5. Right now all I have is Kurt Thomas. I'm probably going to maneuver one more trade and get a good rebounder to play center and replace Noah's rebounding production.

[parker987]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

3 team Melo deal in my Bulls Association:

Chicago receives:
Carmelo Anthony(from DEN)
Sam Young(from MEM)

Memphis receives:
Luol Deng(from CHI)
Taj Gibson(from CHI)
1st round pick(from CHI)

Denver receives:
Joakim Noah(from CHI)
Rudy Gay(from MEM)

I think it's pretty fair. Must note that I'm using Rashidi's rosters and he has Melo at an 87. I doubt it'd work if he were a 93 or whatever 2k has him at.

So now I have Rose, Melo, and Boozer. Ronnie Brewer is playing the 2 and I'm not sure who's going to play the 5. Right now all I have is Kurt Thomas. I'm probably going to maneuver one more trade and get a good rebounder to play center and replace Noah's rebounding production.

Ahh, beast team but just getting frustrated at the 2 spot and 5. Kurt thomas is really old and gonna retire in next year or 2

[thaprodigyisback]

The CPU just did this trade...

Suns Get:
Tim Duncan
George Hill

Spurs Get:
Vince Carter
Goran Dragic

The Suns are 1st in the west and the Spurs are 13th in the conference so I guess there rebuilding and wanted to get a expiring contract (Vince)

[IamLEGENDsince87]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Lakers get:
Trevor Ariza
Jarett Jack
Jarvis Hayes

Hornets get:
Ron Artest
Matt Barnes
Luke Walton
11' 1st round pick


Lakers get:
Marcin Gortat

Grizzlies get:
Steve Blake
Jarvis Hayes
Theo Ratliff


Wanted Ariza back and a PG for the future which is Jack, love his game on 2K...wasn't really feeling Barnes or Blake they were too inconsistant, got Gortat for the playoffs, he will rebound and play D...love the state of my team now

[tteeebooooow]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

making big moves on draft day

i had the #11 pick in the draft i picked C Jonas Valanciunas 69 ovr A- Potential

i decided to trade him to the knicks for Anthony Randolph and the #20 pick

now i am ready to make another trade should i do this?

Anderson Varejao
Jamario moon
2nd rd Pick

for
Omri Casspi

[parker987]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

making big moves on draft day

i had the #11 pick in the draft i picked C Jonas Valanciunas 69 ovr A- Potential

i decided to trade him to the knicks for Anthony Randolph and the #20 pick

now i am ready to make another trade should i do this?

Anderson Varejao
Jamario moon
2nd rd Pick

for
Omri Casspi

This is a fair trade, i think you could do this and move randolph at starting lineup

[definitivelife]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Lakers Receive
Lamarcus Aldridge
Greg Oden
Josh Smith(ATL)
Kirk Hinrich(WAS)

Lakers Give
Andrew Bynum
Pau Gasol
Ron Artest

Good or bad trade?

[Cuse 15]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Lakers Receive
Lamarcus Aldridge
Greg Oden
Josh Smith(ATL)
Kirk Hinrich(WAS)

Lakers Give
Andrew Bynum
Pau Gasol
Ron Artest

Good or bad trade?

Just by looking at the players you got back, the Lakers made out, got younger and more athletic, what would your starting line up be

Oden or Aldridge
Aldridge or J Smooth
Odom or J Smooth
Kobe
Fisher

either way Lakers win that trade

[ROABS]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Lakers Receive
Lamarcus Aldridge
Greg Oden
Josh Smith(ATL)
Kirk Hinrich(WAS)

Lakers Give
Andrew Bynum
Pau Gasol
Ron Artest

Good or bad trade?

let me guess your the lakers?

[definitivelife]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Yep, I'm the Lakers. I noticed the team isn't as efficient in rebounding with the Aldridge and Bynum replacement. I plan on somehow getting OJ Mayo in like two years into the association. Want to run a big lineup that's the reason for Hinrich.

Oh yeah, and re-signed Sun Yue and sent him to NBA D League.

The Lineup is...

PG Kirk Hinrich
SG Kobe Bryant
SF Josh Smith(Rating actually went up when moved to SF)
PF Lamarcus Aldridge
C Greg Oden

Notable Bench
Lamar Odom
Josh Howard
Shannon Brown

[thedukejr]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Yep, I'm the Lakers. I noticed the team isn't as efficient in rebounding with the Aldridge and Bynum replacement. I plan on somehow getting OJ Mayo in like two years into the association. Want to run a big lineup that's the reason for Hinrich.

Oh yeah, and re-signed Sun Yue and sent him to NBA D League.

The Lineup is...

PG Kirk Hinrich
SG Kobe Bryant
SF Josh Smith(Rating actually went up when moved to SF)
PF Lamarcus Aldridge
C Greg Oden

Notable Bench
Lamar Odom
Josh Howard
Shannon Brown

aldridge is more of a scoring big man than all around. it is a good trade since you got younger and more athletic but you went down on defense and in rebounding. make sure to give brown some playing time or he will start giving you problems. also what were the trades you made to get this line up?

[loloben]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

making big moves on draft day

i had the #11 pick in the draft i picked C Jonas Valanciunas 69 ovr A- Potential

i decided to trade him to the knicks for Anthony Randolph and the #20 pick

now i am ready to make another trade should i do this?

Anderson Varejao
Jamario moon
2nd rd Pick

for
Omri Casspi

I like the first trade but that is too much for Cassipi

[infamyice]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

About to start my 3rd season of my Suns franchise.
I noticed that Jared Dudley was fed up with not having floor time over Thaddeus Young starting position.
Here's my trade to get rid of him:

Boston Celtics recieves:
Jared Dudley (74 Ovr w/ 3yrs $12.75) & 2013 1st Round pick

Phoenix Suns recieves:
Kevin Garnett (75 Ovr w/ 3yrs $12.51) & 2013 1st Round pick

KG will come to us starting at PF.
We really don't have an effective PF and we have two centers (M. Gasol & M. Gortat w/ Lopez coming off bench) on the floor.
I don't like to really have two centers on the floor because I like for my PF to spread mid-range.

SO here's my current line up:
PG - N. Nixon (74)
SG - R. Jones (80)
SF - T. Young (78)
PF - K. Garnett (75)
C - M. Gasol (79)
6th - M. Thorton (75)
Role - M. Gortat (70)
Role - J.J. Barea (70)
Role - R. Lopez (69) <- Possible trade in future?

[definitivelife]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

aldridge is more of a scoring big man than all around. it is a good trade since you got younger and more athletic but you went down on defense and in rebounding. make sure to give brown some playing time or he will start giving you problems. also what were the trades you made to get this line up?

Lakers Trade
Pau Gasol and 2012 First Pick for Aldridge and Oden
Artest, Barnes, and Walton for Hinrich and Josh Howard
Andrew Bynum for Josh Smith and 2012 1st Round Pick

[frostygimphoof]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Hello everyone. I'm new to the forum so here we go. I'm the Hawks for my franchise and I already made a trade to get a little more size.

Grizz get: Jason Collins
Maurice Evens
Josh Powell
Atl 1st rd pick

Hawks get: Hasheem Thabeet
Grizz 1st rd pick

Figured there 1st rd would be better then mine so I didn't do to bad. This enabled me to put J Smooth at SF and Horford at PF where he has averaged a double double since the trade. Now I'm looking to move M. Williams because he is worthless when he comes of the bench. I want someone young but i can't figure a good one that would be fair. Any help would be great. Thanks and have a good one.