The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[geisterhome]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

im in my first year with the celtics and id like to get rid of marquis daniels and possibly mikeal pietrus (have jeff green on my roster) as well chris wilcox. they all got only 1 year of contract left. should i just wait until the end of the season until their contracts expire or should i try to trade them somewhere before. i used the trade finder and got a lot of offers but i would like to make some realstic moves. any suggestions?

[CincyPride2014]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

If I were to trade for Dwight Howard.. Would this work of be logical.

Magic get:
Kris Humphries
Brook Lopez
'12 1st round pick
A solid role player

Nets get:
Dwight Howard

If you don't like this, you are welcomes to give me any suggestions.

[d.geronimo]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

If I were to trade for Dwight Howard.. Would this work of be logical.

Magic get:
Kris Humphries
Brook Lopez
'12 1st round pick
A solid role player

Nets get:
Dwight Howard

If you don't like this, you are welcomes to give me any suggestions.

I think Magic will be trade Howard only with Turkoglu.

[xrobbyh14x]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

lufc, I like that trade a lot and agree with your assessment. These "potential" players that haven't done much by their third or fourth years can and should be traded all day for guys like Iggy. One of the best defenders in the league as well. He's Scottie Pippen Lite. Go for it.

[ojandpizza]

So I started a association hoping to get the Cavs back to playoff contention with life after LeBron..

I made 1 trade: Jamison and I think my pics (maybe some fillers can't remember the players) to the Rockets for Kevin Martin, Courtney Lee and Dalembert..

And then signed Lamar Odom

I started -
Kyrie, Martin, Gee, Odom, Varejao
Bench -
Gibson, Lee, Casspi, Thompson, Dalembert, Harris, Samuels

Made it to the second round of the playoffs game 5, and improved record by like 30 wins.. Kyrie and Martin both all stars, and Kyrie rookie of the year and Martin at 28ppg.. I played only 10 games or so..

In the off season signed: Chris Paul, Andre Miller, Landry Feilds, DJ White, and re-signed Lee&Dalembert..

Then made a 3 team trade with Orlando and Phoenix

Cavs trade: Paul(ORL), Thompson(ORL), Varejao(PHO),and 1st pick(ORL)
Magic Trade: Howard(CLE),D Collisin(PHO),Glen Davis(PHO)
Suns Trade: Moris(CLE),Gortat(ORL), J Terry(ORL), and 1st pick(ORL)

In the end the magic gain a new starting PG, SG, PF, and C while also adding two first round pics to build with

The Suns before the trade were starting Willie Warren at PG(61ovr) and upgraded to Collison(81), and also gained a starting PF and C to compliment Wes Johnson and Dorell Wright (their Wing men)

And I end up with my line-up of - Irving, Martin, Gee, Morris/Odom, and Dwight..
With solid bench- Lee, Fields, Dalembert, A Miller, and Casspi

What do y'all think? I think I was pretty fair along the way with the trades and trying to balance it out somewhat.. I got Dwight out of Orlando and left them with 4 new starters, one who is a complete superstar, one only 21 years old and 2 new 1st round picks, made a trade with the recently "trade happy" Rockets, and significantly improved the Suns at the PG spot to deal with losing Nash while replacing their lost Center and upgrading them at PF..

[Comduklakis]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I know there isn't a lot of actvity these days around 2k12, mostly folks talking about 2k13. However, I have a dynasty in its third season (linked in my sig) that I want some advice about some possible mid-season trades.

Current Playoff picture: Heat, Knicks 2 gb, Bulls, 2.5, Pistons (me), 2.5, Celtics 6.5, Pacers 8.5, Raptors 8.5, 76ers 10.5 Outside looking in: Wizards 11.0 gb, Magic 11.5, Hawks 13.5, Bucks 14, Cavs 14.5, Bobcats 14.5, Nets 22.0

Trail Blazers, Lakers 2 gb, Twolves 4.5, Memphis 11.5 (bad division), Thunder 5.0, Nuggets 8.5, Kings 9.5, Clippers 10.5, Rockets 12, Spurs 12.5, Mavs 13.5, Warriors 14.5, Jazz 15.5, Suns 17.5, Hornets 21

The following trades are ones I came up with and are considering:

For Manu Ginobili who is in the final year of his one year contract at 5.51m (gave a hometown discount) and is 36. He is not a long term option for anyone

Bulls: SG P.J. Hairston (65 OVR, 73 POT), Tony Allen 1/2.0m, Baron Davis 1/2.0m and a 2014 1st round pick

Clippers: Eric Bledsoe, Devin Ebanks, Samardo Samules, 2014 1st, Spurs also give James Johnson along with Ginobili

Blazers: Luke Babbitt (68OVR, 75 POT), Wesley Mathews, 2014 1st

Kevin Martin: Martin has a 4 year/30.67m deal with the Orlando Magic, who are trying to rebuild around Andrew Bynum ,Tu Holloway, and Adonis Thomas.

Bulls: P.J. Hairston, Tony Allen, Taj Gibson (3/14.84m), 2014 1st while Magic also send Courtney Fortson (1/487k), Jerome Harper (1/487k)

Blazers: Wesley Mathews, 2014 1st

Three-Way Trade
Clippers: Chauncey Billups 1/3.0m, retiring and shooting under 35%) (DEN), Eric Bledsoe (ORL), Samardo Samuels (ORL), 2014 1st (ORL)
Nuggets: Jordan Hamilton (LAC), Casper Ware (ORL), Dexter Strickland ORL)
Orlando: Kevin Martin (LAC), 2015 2nd (DEN)

Celtics: Avery Bradley (HOU), JaJuan Johnson (ORL), Wesley Johnson (ORL), 2014 2nd (ORL)
Rockets: Corey Magette (BOS), 2014 1st (ORL),
Magic: Kevin Martin (BOS), Courtney Fortson (HOU)

Joe Johnson: He has a 3 year/69.53m contract. He, Horford, and Josh Smith make close to 50 million a year together, hampering any other moves. The Hawks are struggling to make the playoffs after making it to the Eastern Conference Finals last season (swept by Miami). I'm not sure they are even ready for a move but I'm exploring options for all three

Clippers: Caron Butler (1/8.0m), Billups, DeAndre Jordan (2/21.5m), 2014 1st get back Johnson, Jerome Jordan

Al Horford: (3 years/36.0m)

Celtics: Robin Lopez (1/1.93m), Avery Bradley (1/2.51m), David West (2/12.91m)
Rockets: Kyle Lowry (1/6.21m), Timofy Mozgov (2/3.92m), 2014 1st

Josh Smith: (5 years/69.14m)
Bulls: Taj Gibson, Carlos Boozer (2/32.10m), 2014, 16, and 18 1st round picks
Rockets: Courtney Lee (2/6.56m), Marcus Morris (73OVR 79POT, already averaging 13.2ppg in 20.0m .479%), 2014, 16, 18 1st round picks
Timberwolves: Dorrell Wright (3/15.71m), Luke Ridnour (1/4.32m), Brandon Rush (1/3.0m and the league's leading 3 point shooter in about 20 MPG), 2014, 16, 18 1st round picks

Dirk Nowitzki: yes, the unthinkable. Dirk is 35 and in the last year of his contract (22.70m). The Mavs need to rebuild and Dirk has value to a contender. He's still averaging 18ppg and 9.7 rpg in 31.2mpg.

Bulls: Taj Gibson, Carlos Boozer, 2014, 16, 18 1st round picks

Jeff Green: He has a 3 year/20.72m deal. that may a bit much for his production on a non-playoff team.

Three Way Trade
Lakers: Rodney Williams (69OVR, 60POT 6.9ppg .440% 18.9mpg) (MIL), 2015 1st (MIL) Hedo Turkoglu (1/12.0m) (PHO)
Bucks: Jeff Green (LAL)
Suns: Tayshaun Prince (2/14.95m) (MIL)

Timberwolves: Ridnour, Rush, 2014 1st

John Wall: Washington drafted Tony Wroten with the 7th pick. He's a 68 with 70 potential and is averaging 6.8ppg and 4.8apg in 20.2mpg on .444 shooting. In three previous seasons, Wall has shot .409, .411, and .410. He is currently at a career high .439 and a career high .333 from 3 pt land. He is in the last year of his contract and wants a max deal. I'm not even sure he would stay in Washington or that they would pay him a max deal with Wroten.

Houston Rockets: Donatas Motiejunas (monster prospect, averaging 7.2ppg in just 13.5mpg and under team control for 2 more years after this one), 2014, 16, 18 1st round picks

Danny Granger: Final year of his deal with the New Orleans Hornets, who are the worst team in the league and are building around Anthony Davis. Granger has sent mixed signals that he wantst to stay in New Orleans and is expected to get 15 million or so per year.

Clippers: Caron Butler, Devin Ebanks, Samardo Samuels, Wille Green 1/866k), 2014 and 2016 1st round picks

Three way Trade:

Lakers: Turkoglu (NOH), Rodney Williams (NOH), PF Tarik Black (66OVR, 69 POT) (ORL), 2015 1st (NOH)
Hornets: Granger (LAL), PF Milan MacVan (64OVR, 79POT) (ORL), Jon Leurer (LAL)
Magic: Courtney Fortson (NOH), 2014 1st (NOH)

Rockets: Motiejunas, PF Xavier Gibson (59OVR, 65 POT), Chandler Parsons, 2014, 2016 1st rounders

Let me know what you think about any of the deals. Thanks.

[Comduklakis]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

So I started a association hoping to get the Cavs back to playoff contention with life after LeBron..

I made 1 trade: Jamison and I think my pics (maybe some fillers can't remember the players) to the Rockets for Kevin Martin, Courtney Lee and Dalembert..

And then signed Lamar Odom

I started -
Kyrie, Martin, Gee, Odom, Varejao
Bench -
Gibson, Lee, Casspi, Thompson, Dalembert, Harris, Samuels

Made it to the second round of the playoffs game 5, and improved record by like 30 wins.. Kyrie and Martin both all stars, and Kyrie rookie of the year and Martin at 28ppg.. I played only 10 games or so..

In the off season signed: Chris Paul, Andre Miller, Landry Feilds, DJ White, and re-signed Lee&Dalembert..

Then made a 3 team trade with Orlando and Phoenix

Cavs trade: Paul(ORL), Thompson(ORL), Varejao(PHO),and 1st pick(ORL)
Magic Trade: Howard(CLE),D Collisin(PHO),Glen Davis(PHO)
Suns Trade: Moris(CLE),Gortat(ORL), J Terry(ORL), and 1st pick(ORL)

In the end the magic gain a new starting PG, SG, PF, and C while also adding two first round pics to build with

The Suns before the trade were starting Willie Warren at PG(61ovr) and upgraded to Collison(81), and also gained a starting PF and C to compliment Wes Johnson and Dorell Wright (their Wing men)

And I end up with my line-up of - Irving, Martin, Gee, Morris/Odom, and Dwight..
With solid bench- Lee, Fields, Dalembert, A Miller, and Casspi

What do y'all think? I think I was pretty fair along the way with the trades and trying to balance it out somewhat.. I got Dwight out of Orlando and left them with 4 new starters, one who is a complete superstar, one only 21 years old and 2 new 1st round picks, made a trade with the recently "trade happy" Rockets, and significantly improved the Suns at the PG spot to deal with losing Nash while replacing their lost Center and upgrading them at PF..

Not sure Phoenix got enoug. Gortat is arguably the 5th-8th best center in the league. Markieff Morris showed some real promise. Jason Terry is always a 6th man of the year candidate and you gave up a 1st. I'm fine with considering Collision straight up for Terry. Glenn Davis or Varajeo for Gortat isn't a great deal for Phoenix. Davis or Varajeo for Morris is also questionable. But even if you call all three as straight up fair, they still tossed in an extra 1st rounder. For what? Gortat isn't under a bad contract. Is Terry? Unless he's under a 5 year/50 million deal or something I don't think Phoenix got enough. I think the stuff with Orlando and Cleveland is workable though. Maybe another player to Phoenix or a 4th team involved to make it more equitable?

[Hadzialijagic]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

What about this trade?
I want to make it realistic so let me know if i should tweak it at all.

Clippers trade: Griffin, Jordan, Butler, Bledsoe
Hornets trade: Davis, Gordon, Lewis
Bobcats trade: MKG, Diop, 2014 2nd

Clippers receive: Davis, MKG, Lewis
Hornets receive: Griffin Jordan Butler Diop
Bobcats receive: Gordon, Bledsoe

I think i might be giving up too much but my team clears a ridiculous amount of cap space so we can go after Dwight/Bynum in FA.

Hornets upgrade Davis into Griffin and a disgruntled Gordon into 2 valuable starters.

Bobcats were rumoured to be interested in trading the 2nd pick for Harden and Gordon is just as good if not better. Getting Bledsoe as well makes this a must do trade.

[NFCastle]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Let me start off by saying im aware that neither one of these trades will ever happen in real life as.
A. The bulls wont trade D rose.
B. The pacers most likely want to build around George.

Out of these two, which is a better deal for the pacers...I do not care about if it is a good deal for me or not.

A.
Bulls Recieve
Danny Granger 2 yr 27 mil contract
Paul George 1 yr + team option 2.57 first year
Miles Plumlee 2 yr 2.19 mil + 2 yr team

Pacers Recieve
Derrick Rose 5 yr 95 mil
Vladimir Radmanovic 1 yr 1.35 mil

or

B.
Bulls Recieve
Paul George 1 yr 2.57 mil+ team option
David West 1 yr 10 million
George Hill 5 yr 40.01 million

Pacers Recieve:
Luol Deng 2 yr 27.63 mil
Joakim Noah 4 yr 50.5 mil
1st Rd pick this year


Which one is a better deal for the pacers? A or B?