The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[K.So]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Im thinking of trading westbrook to make my game more challenging and balanced. I won a title and thinking of placing rw to a team where he will be the new star. I like to get a young and rising guard to complement kd and ibaka:

Options: (package of players included to balance salary but i will only mention my target)
1- irving
Pros- 84 A potential, reliable inside and outside offense
Cons- cp3 signed with cavs and two pg stars is not realistic

2-wall
Pros 84 A+ potential, high flyer
Cons- other players to be in trade package is not interesting

3-steph curry
Pros 86 A potential, outside shooter
Cons weaker defender compared to rw

4-rubio
Pros 84 A+ potential great passer
Cons a bit lacking in offense

5- d rose
Pros Mvp
Cons not realistic

Thoughts?

I have Curry in my Warriors Association; putting him in a Training Camp, and in the '15 season, his Perimeter Defense is 'A' and is Top 8 in steals. Has been an All-Star 4 years straight. He is a 92 OVR during our playoff run; we are the 4 seed.

[killstory]

What do you guys think of this trade?

Lakers trade: Andrew Bynum, Metta World Peace, & 2012 2nd round pick.

Pacers trade: Danny Granger, Roy Hibbert, & 2012 1st round pick.

Lakers get another scoring option in Danny Granger and a pretty good replacement in Roy Hibbert.

Pacers get either the best center or 2nd best center in the NBA (however you see Bynum as) and a still decent lock down defender in World Peace who can still hit the 3 shot.

[NFCastle]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

What do you guys think of this trade?

Lakers trade: Andrew Bynum, Metta World Peace, & 2012 2nd round pick.

Pacers trade: Danny Granger, Roy Hibbert, & 2012 1st round pick.

Lakers get another scoring option in Danny Granger and a pretty good replacement in Roy Hibbert.

Pacers get either the best center or 2nd best center in the NBA (however you see Bynum as) and a still decent lock down defender in World Peace who can still hit the 3 shot.

I dont see the pacers giving up a 2012 1st round pick in that trade.

Maybe swapping a 2012 first for a 2013 1st with the lakers.

But hibbert's value is pretty high + granger is their #1 option.

[NFCastle]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I am the lakers.


Lakers trade:
83 ovr Pau Gasol pf/c
2013 2nd round pick

Rockets (perennially interest in Gasol it seems) trade:
66 ovr Marcus morris pf
74 ovr Goran Dragic pg
59 greg smith c/pf


Rockets get the big man they have desired for years in gasol/their new #1 option...they move him to center, play him alongside scola. They also get a draft pick to add some lost youth.

Lakers get a pg to replace sessions who left via free agency, and 2 nice young prospects

What do you guys think?

[mpac]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I have Curry in my Warriors Association; putting him in a Training Camp, and in the '15 season, his Perimeter Defense is 'A' and is Top 8 in steals. Has been an All-Star 4 years straight. He is a 92 OVR during our playoff run; we are the 4 seed.

Yep thanks! I go for Steph Curry to make us a great shooting team and makes it more challenging and new for me, as KD and RW is becoming unstoppable in the 2nd season.

Here's the breakdown of my trade:

OKC gets Steph Curry 86, Breidrins 66, D Wright 71, Jajuan Johnson 70 (all expiring contracts)
GS gets Westbrook 93, S Young 70, Turiaf 60

My new lineup:
PG - Curry, Hinrich
SG - Ray Allen, Bradley Beal
SF - Durant, Sefolosha, Wright
PF - Ibaka, J Thompson
C - Perkins, Breidrins, Aldrich, Drew Cook

[juggalotusx]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Ok, starting a new year with magic will sim first year and fire gundy. I need to know what is a good trade for D.Howard, what should I look for to get? Any Ideas. I could get Durant but that feels cheap to me.

[rosque]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

So I am managing Houston.. And I wanted to acquire new Point Guard as I'm now happy with lowry and I wanted to see what they want for Isaiah Thomas and this is what they came up with.. I'm curently 6-6 and will most likely go to the lotery

Houston get: I. Thomas (2,5 star, B pot, 72 Rating), Tyreke Evans(2starts, 78 rating, potential B-)
Kings get: 1rn '12 pick, 2rnd '12 pick and Kyle Lowry (3starts, 82 rating, c+ potential)

Is this fair? I know that there are roumors about getting rid of Tyreke but I think I'm ripping them off in one way..

[KnickNation17]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Just started A NOLA association

Pg-Diamion Lillard
Sg-Eric Gordan
Sf-Trevor Ariza
Pf-Thomas Robinson
C-Ekpe Udoh

I need a good Sf. I was think Derrick Williams, Tyreke Evans... Suggestions?

[texasbum06]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I am the lakers.


Lakers trade:
83 ovr Pau Gasol pf/c
2013 2nd round pick

Rockets (perennially interest in Gasol it seems) trade:
66 ovr Marcus morris pf
74 ovr Goran Dragic pg
59 greg smith c/pf


Rockets get the big man they have desired for years in gasol/their new #1 option...they move him to center, play him alongside scola. They also get a draft pick to add some lost youth.

Lakers get a pg to replace sessions who left via free agency, and 2 nice young prospects

What do you guys think?

I'm a Rockets fan and I love that trade, but to be completely honest I think the Rockets would have to give up more than that to acquire Gasol.

[LewisCAVS]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm the Cavs.

Cavs get:

Rudy Gay
Darrell Arthur
Josh Selby

Grizzlies get:

2012 1st round pick
Tristan Thompson
Verajao (I got Oden in free agency)

[NFCastle]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm a Rockets fan and I love that trade, but to be completely honest I think the Rockets would have to give up more than that to acquire Gasol.

Thanks for feedback... Seems like no one ever replies to posts. Ppl just post their trades

[Suntan Superman]

I would reply, but I got Pm'd by posters about not agreeing with any trade.(not true) so I stopped critiquing.

[bizness x1]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I am the hawks;

hawks get rajon rondo

celtics get horford plus 2012/2013 first

hawks get terrence williams 2012 second

kings get jeff teague

get a point guard who is can take over ball control duties from aging jj, sf who has terrific potential and will contribute today. brings back the highlight factory (also sign greg oden)

celtics get picks to either trade to keep contending or use to rebuild around a more scoring threat in horford rather then build around a pg who can't score too well

kings get a point guard to put tyreke on at 2

all fair and realistic IMO

[bizness x1]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Ok, starting a new year with magic will sim first year and fire gundy. I need to know what is a good trade for D.Howard, what should I look for to get? Any Ideas. I could get Durant but that feels cheap to me.

everyone normally goes for a future dominating big man (bynum, lopez) so they don't have to change the rest of the roster, but I think it'd be fun to get 3 really good players and get rid of all the one dimensional players.

maybe get gay, mayo, gasol (or randolph) from grizzles (who in real life try to get big name guys, AI signed offer sheet for josh smith, been trying to get ellis for years, signed arenas) so they get a big names and clear the center position and rid of their sixth man who needs a change of scenery and gay who although talented, was not part of their big playoff run last year.

[ThePixel]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm the Cavs.

Cavs get:

Rudy Gay
Darrell Arthur
Josh Selby

Grizzlies get:

2012 1st round pick
Tristan Thompson
Verajao (I got Oden in free agency)

The first pick wont be that useful since you will probably make the playoffs. Grizzlies get 2 good backup big man but have no one to fill the SF spot and Gay is a star and I don't feel Thompson and verajao are good enough for him alone but Darrel Arthur and Josh Selby it's a steal for the cavs and the Memphis get robbed but hey it's your association