The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[Raider131]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

New Jersey:
Deron Williams and '13 1st rounder

OKC:
Russell Westbrook

[Bballplaya72]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Rebuilding the Suns.

3 team trade, that I feel is very realistic involving Phoenix, Miami, and Houston.

I ship Nash, Grant Hill, Channing Frye, and Hakim Warrick to Miami.

Miami sends Chris Bosh to Phoenix, Mike Miller to Phoenix, and two (presumably late) first round picks to Houston.

Houston sends Goran Dragic back to Phoenix, along with Samuel Dalembert.

Bottom Line Phoenix: The Suns not only get talent, but younger. By bringing Bosh and having them be their go-to, they get a 25-10 guy, and a young player while getting rid of Nash/Hill. They also pick up Goran Dragic back from Houston who proved to be more than capable during his time in Phoenix. Dalembert was a throw in, with a 6m expiring contract, but can fill in when needed and provides defense.

Bottom Line Miami: By giving up Bosh, the Heat are essentially all in for the next 2 years. In picking up Nash, they get an elite PG who is an immediate major upgrade over Chalmers, but who only has a year or two left, along with Grant Hill, a player with a year or two left but can do everything well and can either add tremendous depth off the bench, or start at the 3. Miami can be a run and gun team and either start Hill at the 3 and Lebron at the 4, or slow it down and go Lebron at the 3, and Haslem at the 4. Both Nash and Hill fit in with Miami well, and it gives Nash a chance to play out East for a title contender. Channing Frye is just the type of player they need who can space the floor and hit 3's. The Heat were not likely to get much value out of their late round picks anyway, and gave them to Houston.

Bottom Line Houston: Houston will now have 3 first round picks this year, and 2 next year, in an attempt to overhaul their roster. They were unlikely to resign Dragic, along with Dalembert, so the move was made purely for the future.

[plumplylumpkin]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Would you trade Andrew Bynum for both Danny Granger and Roy Hibbert?

Nope. Andrew Bynum is a beast in this game and can abuse anyone in the paint.

NYK
Amare Stoudemire
tonyey douglas
Jerome Jordan
2013 1st round pick

Atl
Al Horford : Switch him back to his natural PF
Marvin Williams

IS this fair Fair trade i was thinking of doing this.
I would move J Smooth back to the three spot and Maybe sign greg oden to ATl

The Amare=Horford is not fair in favor to the ATL of course then you've added a 1st draft pick that made it even worse for the Knicks.

[K.So]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Warriors Trade: David Lee, Shelden Williams
Jazz Trade: '12 1st Round Pick (Top 5 projected)

[NFCastle]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Nope. Andrew Bynum is a beast in this game and can abuse anyone in the paint.




The Amare=Horford is not fair in favor to the ATL of course then you've added a 1st draft pick that made it even worse for the Knicks.

I disagree. Amare's contract is one of the most undesirable on the NBA plus he has injury issues.

His tradevalue would be lower than expected

[NFCastle]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Rebuilding the Suns.

3 team trade, that I feel is very realistic involving Phoenix, Miami, and Houston.

I ship Nash, Grant Hill, Channing Frye, and Hakim Warrick to Miami.

Miami sends Chris Bosh to Phoenix, Mike Miller to Phoenix, and two (presumably late) first round picks to Houston.

Houston sends Goran Dragic back to Phoenix, along with Samuel Dalembert.

Bottom Line Phoenix: The Suns not only get talent, but younger. By bringing Bosh and having them be their go-to, they get a 25-10 guy, and a young player while getting rid of Nash/Hill. They also pick up Goran Dragic back from Houston who proved to be more than capable during his time in Phoenix. Dalembert was a throw in, with a 6m expiring contract, but can fill in when needed and provides defense.

Bottom Line Miami: By giving up Bosh, the Heat are essentially all in for the next 2 years. In picking up Nash, they get an elite PG who is an immediate major upgrade over Chalmers, but who only has a year or two left, along with Grant Hill, a player with a year or two left but can do everything well and can either add tremendous depth off the bench, or start at the 3. Miami can be a run and gun team and either start Hill at the 3 and Lebron at the 4, or slow it down and go Lebron at the 3, and Haslem at the 4. Both Nash and Hill fit in with Miami well, and it gives Nash a chance to play out East for a title contender. Channing Frye is just the type of player they need who can space the floor and hit 3's. The Heat were not likely to get much value out of their late round picks anyway, and gave them to Houston.

Bottom Line Houston: Houston will now have 3 first round picks this year, and 2 next year, in an attempt to overhaul their roster. They were unlikely to resign Dragic, along with Dalembert, so the move was made purely for the future.

You are ripping off miami hard.

They are losing bosh miller and 2 first round picks for what...
Two vets who will retire in a year, and 2 scrubs who probably wont even play 15 mins a game combined.

Nash is an upgrade over chalmers...but the downgrade from losing bosh is much more noticeable.

Plus Nash is 38....bosh is what 27-29?

[dynamicswish]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I started an Online Association with the Philly 76ers with their real roster. I decided when I first started that, while Philly has a great cast of guards and Small Forwards, their bigs leave a lot to be desired.

Trade 1:

76ers Give Up:

PF -Elton Brand
SF -Andre Igoudala
SF -Sam Young
2013 first rounder

Lakers Give Up:

PF -Pau Gasol
PF -Josh McRoberts
SF - Metta World Peace

Trade 2:

76ers Give Up:

PG - Louis Williams
SF - Andres Nocioni
2012 1st rounder

Mavericks Give Up:

SG - Jason Terry
SG - Kelenna Azubuike
C - Ian Mahinmi


Lemme know what you guys think.

[ItBeBrianYo]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Brand, Iggy, Lou Will, and 2 first rounders for pretty much Pau, Jason Terry and Artest?

Idk about that! But I have to admit, Pau is one of my favorite players to use online, him in the post is just WOW. So I guess it is good if you like the players you traded for, which I assume you do!

[Bballplaya72]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

You are ripping off miami hard.

They are losing bosh miller and 2 first round picks for what...
Two vets who will retire in a year, and 2 scrubs who probably wont even play 15 mins a game combined.

Nash is an upgrade over chalmers...but the downgrade from losing bosh is much more noticeable.

Plus Nash is 38....bosh is what 27-29?

Nash/Hill both have expiring contracts for 17 million total. Heat gain much needed cap space. There is already talk Bosh might be on his way out after this year anyway.

[dynamicswish]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Brand, Iggy, Lou Will, and 2 first rounders for pretty much Pau, Jason Terry and Artest?

Idk about that! But I have to admit, Pau is one of my favorite players to use online, him in the post is just WOW. So I guess it is good if you like the players you traded for, which I assume you do!

I resculpted the trades and made a few other trades.

Trade 1:

Philadelphia 76ers
Elton Brand
Andre Iguodala
Sam Young
2013 1st rounder

for

Los Angeles Lakers
Pau Gasol
Josh McRoberts
Metta World Peace


Trade 2:

Philadelphia 76ers
Spencer Hawes
Andres Nocioni
2012 1st rounder

for

Dallas Mavericks
Ian Mahinmi
Jason Terry
2012 1st rounder


Trade 3:

Philadelphia 76ers
Louis Williams
Lavoy Allen

for

Indiana Pacers
George Hill

Trade 4:

Philadelphia 76ers
Nikola Vucevic
Jodie Meeks

for

Toronto Raptors
James Johnson
2013 2nd rounder

Trade 5

Philadelphia 76ers
Craig Brackins
Tony Battie

for

Denver Nuggets
Corey Brewer
2012 2nd rounder

Summary:
I also signed Greg Oden to a one-year deal and lot of these moves were designed to give me skilled size, (Gasol, Mahinmi, Oden), a tough bench, (Hill, Terry), And a much tougher defense with Peace and Brewer. Plus, I dropped the dead weight of Battie and Brackins for example.

[SaylaB]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Nash/Hill both have expiring contracts for 17 million total. Heat gain much needed cap space. There is already talk Bosh might be on his way out after this year anyway.

Nash is an upgrade over Chalmers, but the Heat don't need the ball handler. LeBron can handle the ball. He's much better with the ball in his hands than without it, same with Wade. I get that Nash would be able to distribute to the rest of the team, but it's not worth losing a solid big man in Bosh.

Hill isn't really the piece they need, at all. He's nice to have coming off the bench I suppose, but they don't need another small forward.

Frye is a guy that can spread the floor, but he's going to get abused defensively and is a liability on that end of the court. Bosh had almost an identical role in Miami. And had more versatility in his offensive game to complement the other 2 stars.

The Heat's draft picks aren't worth much value because they're going to be so late in the draft. I guess it's not bad if Dragic and Dalembert weren't going to resign, but I can't help but feel like you robbed Houston on this one. Now all Houston has at center is Marcus Camby? And the only good point guard they have is Kyle Lowry? C'mon now.

The Suns clearly got the best end of this deal. They give up 2 guys near retirement, a soft big in Frye, and a bench warmer in Warrick and get back a nice young point guard, one of the best offensive bigs in the game, a defensive minded center, and a gunner off the bench.

Sorry, but it just doesn't seem like a fair deal to me.

[Insight23]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Im Orlando about halfway thru the season, im thinking about trading Dwight Howard just to make a switch to the team although I have a cool record (24-12).

Orlando trade: Dwight Howard

Clippers trade: Blake Griffin, Deandre Jordan, First round pick

I already got rid of Hedo. I know its not a trade that would really happen but I dont think its too far fetched. Clippers are title contenders with their squad after this trade with Billups not injured in my season & im fine with having to build around Griffin, Ive really wanted to build around him just dont want to play with the Clippers.

Give feedback

[Hassan Darkside]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Im Orlando about halfway thru the season, im thinking about trading Dwight Howard just to make a switch to the team although I have a cool record (24-12).

Orlando trade: Dwight Howard

Clippers trade: Blake Griffin, Deandre Jordan, First round pick

I already got rid of Hedo. I know its not a trade that would really happen but I dont think its too far fetched. Clippers are title contenders with their squad after this trade with Billups not injured in my season & im fine with having to build around Griffin, Ive really wanted to build around him just dont want to play with the Clippers.

Give feedback

I don't think LAC would do it, especially not giving up DeAndre and a 1st on top of Blake Griffin.

I'm Washington trading with Minny:
Was Gives:
Jordan Crawford (72)
Andray Blatche (76 but he's poison)
Chris Singleton (73)

Minny gives:
Derrick Williams (71)
Anthony Randolph (71 but unhappy and a 63 that wants out)
Malcolm Lee (66)

Basically I have too many rotation players right now. I'd like to add a PF that can step out and make Js and also finish at the rim. I drafted MKG so have no use for Singleton and signed JR Smith and don't want Jordan Crawford. This trade will also help out Minny's backcourt.

[rosque]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

What do you think about these trades?

[mpac]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Im thinking of trading westbrook to make my game more challenging and balanced. I won a title and thinking of placing rw to a team where he will be the new star. I like to get a young and rising guard to complement kd and ibaka:

Options: (package of players included to balance salary but i will only mention my target)
1- irving
Pros- 84 A potential, reliable inside and outside offense
Cons- cp3 signed with cavs and two pg stars is not realistic

2-wall
Pros 84 A+ potential, high flyer
Cons- other players to be in trade package is not interesting

3-steph curry
Pros 86 A potential, outside shooter
Cons weaker defender compared to rw

4-rubio
Pros 84 A+ potential great passer
Cons a bit lacking in offense

5- d rose
Pros Mvp
Cons not realistic

Thoughts?