The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[bSmooth]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Using official roster, the first released


Cavs send: Sessions, Graham
Lakers send: Brown, Vujacic

Cavs send: Jamison, Jawad Williams, Anthony Parker
Mavs send: Chandler, Dominique Jones, 11 1st round pick, Cardinal

Cavs send: AI, Mo, JJ
Bobcats send: Augustin, Tyrus Thomas, Derrick Brown, Nazr Mohammed

Cavs send: Chandler, Jones
Bulls send: Deng

Horrible.

You destroyed the Mavs with those trades. They gain nothing. Parker and Williams would ride the pine. Dallas has more than enough personal to play the 2 & 3 spot. I see Jamison and Cardinal as an even swap. So in the end the Mavs gave up a starting C, that anchors their defense, for 3 people to ride the pine, plus they lose a pick. Nope, not gonna happen.

As for the Bobcats, DJ is not likely to be going anywhere for the next few years, especially not for the likes of Mo Williams. And Thomas is a huge part of the Bobcats defense and energy off the bench. Although bringing JJ back to Carolina isn't such a bad thing.

[Cairns_baller]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Started an association with the Lakers but am controlling all the teams. Since LA like to reload rather then rebuild, I've decided to make things interesting in a 3 team trade with LA, Magic and Hornets

LA Trade: Gasol, Artest, Bynum, Fisher

LA Get: CP3, D12 and Trevor Ariza

Magic Trade: D12, Gilbert Arenas

Magic Get: Okafor, Gasol, Fisher

Hornets trade: CP3, Okafor and Ariza

Hornets get: Bynum, Artest, Arenas

Warning to any trolls, I have based this on the situation where Paul and Howard have demanded trades. And IMO if they did and these offers were on the table it would be hard to say no.

[bSmooth]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Started an association with the Lakers but am controlling all the teams. Since LA like to reload rather then rebuild, I've decided to make things interesting in a 3 team trade with LA, Magic and Hornets

LA Trade: Gasol, Artest, Bynum, Fisher

LA Get: CP3, D12 and Trevor Ariza

Magic Trade: D12, Gilbert Arenas

Magic Get: Okafor, Gasol, Fisher

Hornets trade: CP3, Okafor and Ariza

Hornets get: Bynum, Artest, Arenas

Warning to any trolls, I have based this on the situation where Paul and Howard have demanded trades. And IMO if they did and these offers were on the table it would be hard to say no.

That actually seems like a plausible trade where all three teams benefit. Nice work.

[Cairns_baller]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

That actually seems like a plausible trade where all three teams benefit. Nice work.

Cheers mate, it's an amazing deal for LA. And there are pro's and negatives for Magic and NO, but as I said if Howard and Paul pushed for a trade, these deals would be hard to turn down by either GM. Now I gotta find a decent SF.

[Lyko]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Totally unrealistic. The cavs or any team for that matter would never give up a top 5 draft pick and a player for an over the hill center with maybe 2 years left in his career. The Chandler trade is pretty unfair also. However, you nailed the traid with the wolves.

[nyj721]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Rate my 2 trades with my 2nd year knicks.

Get: A. Jefferson
Give: C. Billups, R Balkman, Shelden Williams, 1st rounder 2011


Get: O.J Mayo, 2nd rounder
Give; L Fields, 1st rounder 2012

I would say these are pretty realistic, but I'm not sure I would make either of them. I'm curious in seeing your lineup now though.



In my first Knick franchise I just did:
Golden State Gets: 11 1st Round, Ronnie Turiaf
New York Gets: Ekpe Udoh, Acie Law
The only reason I think this was realistic is because Udoh had low morale because of a lack of playing time.

[Lyko]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I just kinda did that for fun. That team was too good. I scrapped that association and am now rebuilding the wizards. But I ran s. Mack - mayo - Anthony - amare - Jefferson - and Douglas Williams walker and turiaf played big bench minutes.

[Biistli]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Jameer Nelson, Jason Richardson and Daniel Orton <-------> Amare Stoudemire, Renaldo Balkman and Andy Rautins

So now I got best defensive big man (Dwight Howard) and best offensive big man (Amare Stoudemire). Double towers dominating paint all night long, and if opposite try to double team, Agent Zero, J.J, Hedo, Q-Rich and Larry Hughes get open threes.

Sounds good, right?

[TomZeWolf]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Maybe O.J. Mayo for a developing SG/PG?

[mvspree8]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Simmed the first season with the Timberwolves (added a CAP of Rubio and kept him inactive). Ended up at 37-45 and out of the playoffs.

Trades:
Beasley/Ridnour to TOR for Derozan
Webster to HOU for Thabeet
2011 first/Pekovic to OKC for Aldrich
2012 second to DET for 2013 second

Signees:
Luc Richard Mbah a Moute for 5/$23M
Jason Terry for 2/$5.5M (second year team option)
Sundiata Gaines for 2/$3.7M

Rubio/Flynn/Gaines
Derozan/Terry/Ellington
Johnson/Mbah a Moute/Hayward
Love/Randolph
Aldrich/Milicic/Thabeet

I believe I'm rated 88 offensive/80 defensive/84 overall, and I was 9th in the preseason power rankings. Not bad for the fiscally prudent offseason signings. Derozan will cost a lot after the 2013 season (I believe his last year of his rookie deal) and Love will as well, but otherwise I'm in a great spot, capwise.

[Cairns_baller]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Three way team trade -

Bulls Trade: Boozer (hasn't been great)

Bulls Recieve: Rip Hamilton (need a good SG)


Jazz Trade: AK47 (free agent after this season)

Jazz Recieve: Boozer (back to Utah, where he did well)


Detroit Trade: Rip Hamilton

Detroit Recieve: AK47


Thoughts?

[iad]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Thunder Trade , K.Perkins and Morris Peterson for Tyson Chandler and Peja stojakovic

I wanted Chandler badly and getting Stojakovic as a good shooter to come off the bench didnt hurt either...

[Sammidysam]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

This is a question, sorta a "should I do this trade?"

Oklahoma City (me) trades:
James Harden
Kendrick Perkins
Golden State trades:
Monta Ellis

I hate James Harden's shooting motion, I don't need very good inside men, and Monta Ellis would make the Oklahoma City Thunder deadly.

[vstro]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

This is a question, sorta a "should I do this trade?"

Oklahoma City (me) trades:
James Harden
Kendrick Perkins
Golden State trades:
Monta Ellis

I hate James Harden's shooting motion, I don't need very good inside men, and Monta Ellis would make the Oklahoma City Thunder deadly.

I don't know how that trade matches up in the game, but I think in real life that's giving up entirely too much on your end. I would try to get a 1st round pick, or another player to even it up.

[13]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

If you have the up to date contracts for the players that trade will work. I agree though, you should try to get a pick in there because you're losing out big if you don't.